Skip to main content
. 2024 Aug 28;14:20026. doi: 10.1038/s41598-024-70939-w

Table 2.

Provides an overview of several machine learning models discussed in the literature review. The bold letters represent the most optimal soft computing model in the research.

Authors AI technique Number of datapoints Details of input variables R2 test
Variables No.
Nguyen et al.20 SSO-ELM 216 B/S, DI, ST, MC, PF, HD, RQD, N, SD 9 0.91
Zhang et al.21 RF, CART, CHAID 102 DI, MC 2 0.94
Zhou et al.22 RF 102 DI, MC, PF, B, S, HD 6 0.93
Huang et al.23 FA-ANN 88 DI, MC, B, S, N 5 0.91
Zhou et al.24 GEP-MC 102 B/S, DI, ST, MC, PF, HD 6 0.91
Nguyen et al.25 SVR-GA 125 DI, MC 2 0.99
Nguyen et al.26 HKM-CA 136 DI, MC 2 0.99
Armaghani et al.27 ICA 73 B, S, ST, D, HD, PF, MC, DI 8 0.95
Hasanipanah et al.28 CART 86 DI, MC 2 0.95
Ghoraba et al.29 ANN, ANFIS 115 DI, MC 2 0.95
Shirani Faradonbeh et al.30 GEP 102 DI, MC 2 0.88
Hajihassani et al.31 ICA-ANN 95 MC, DI, TC 3 0.98
Hajihassani et al.32 PSO-ANN 88 BS, ST, PF, MC, DI, Vp, E 7 0.89
Hasanipanah et al.33 SVM 80 RD, E, UCS, TS, Js, B, S, HD/B, SC, ST, DPR, DI 12 0.96
Armaghani et al.34 ANFIS 109 BS, MC, HD, ST, SD, DI, PF, RQD 8 0.97
Armaghani et al.35 PSO-ANN 44 B, S, ST, N, MC, DI 6 0.94
Mohamadnejad et al.36 SVM, ANN 37 DI, MC 2 0.89
Monjezi et al.37 ANN 182 CD, DI, ST, HD 4 0.95
Mohamed38 ANN, FIS 162 DI, MC 2 0.94
Fişne et al.39 FIS 33 DI, MC 2 0.92
Iphar et al.40 ANFIS 42 DI, CD 2 0.99