Skip to main content
. 2024 Sep 8;14:20900. doi: 10.1038/s41598-024-71262-0

Table 5.

The Bonferroni post hoc test’s results for pairwise comparisons after the hierarchical mixed-effects multiple linear regression.

Factor Level (I) Level (J) Diff (I–J) SE P 95% CI
Facial index 0.86 (Mesoprosopic) 0.80 (Euryprosopic) 0.470 0.033 < 0.00000005 0.391 0.549
0.94 (Leptoprosopic) 0.80 (Euryprosopic) 0.301 0.033 < 0.00000005 0.222 0.381
0.86 (Mesoprosopic) − 0.169 0.034 0.0000015 − 0.249 − 0.088
Midline deviation 3 mm to the left 4 mm to the left 0.527 0.110 0.0000620 0.176 0.879
2 mm to the left 4 mm to the left 0.886 0.102 < 0.00000005 0.559 1.213
3 mm to the left 0.359 0.102 0.0152498 0.033 0.684
1 mm to the left 4 mm to the left 2.102 0.110 < 0.00000005 1.749 2.455
3 mm to the left 1.575 0.110 < 0.00000005 1.223 1.926
2 mm to the left 1.216 0.102 < 0.00000005 0.889 1.543
No midline deviation 4 mm to the left 2.406 0.113 < 0.00000005 2.045 2.767
3 mm to the left 1.878 0.112 < 0.00000005 1.520 2.237
2 mm to the left 1.520 0.105 < 0.00000005 1.185 1.855
1 mm to the left 0.304 0.113 0.2516422 − 0.056 0.664
1 mm to the right 4 mm to the left 2.359 0.113 < 0.00000005 1.999 2.719
3 mm to the left 1.832 0.112 < 0.00000005 1.473 2.190
2 mm to the left 1.473 0.104 < 0.00000005 1.138 1.808
1 mm to the left 0.257 0.112 0.8032928 − 0.103 0.617
No midline deviation − 0.047 0.115 1.0000000 − 0.414 0.321
2 mm to the right 4 mm to the left 1.745 0.112 < 0.00000005 1.387 2.102
3 mm to the left 1.217 0.111 < 0.00000005 0.862 1.573
2 mm to the left 0.859 0.104 < 0.00000005 0.527 1.190
1 mm to the left − 0.357 0.112 0.0501560 − 0.714 0.000
No midline deviation − 0.661 0.114 0.0000003 − 1.026 − 0.296
1 mm to the right − 0.614 0.114 0.0000027 − 0.979 − 0.250
3 mm to the right 4 mm to the left 0.967 0.113 < 0.00000005 0.605 1.328
3 mm to the left 0.439 0.112 0.0034681 0.079 0.799
2 mm to the left 0.081 0.105 1.0000000 − 0.255 0.416
1 mm to the left − 1.135 0.113 < 0.00000005 − 1.497 − 0.774
No midline deviation − 1.439 0.115 < 0.00000005 − 1.808 − 1.070
1 mm to the right − 1.392 0.115 < 0.00000005 − 1.761 − 1.024
2 mm to the right − 0.778 0.114 < 0.00000005 − 1.144 − 0.412
4 mm to the right 4 mm to the left 0.369 0.110 0.0280257 0.018 0.720
3 mm to the left − 0.158 0.109 1.0000000 − 0.507 0.190
2 mm to the left − 0.517 0.101 0.0000132 − 0.842 − 0.193
1 mm to the left − 1.733 0.109 < 0.00000005 − 2.084 − 1.382
No midline deviation − 2.037 0.112 < 0.00000005 − 2.395 − 1.679
1 mm to the right − 1.990 0.112 < 0.00000005 − 2.348 − 1.632
2 mm to the right − 1.376 0.111 < 0.00000005 − 1.731 − 1.021
3 mm to the right − 0.598 0.112 0.0000040 − 0.957 − 0.239
Midline Roll 10° to the left 15° to the left − 0.214 0.104 0.8432901 − 0.530 0.103
5° to the left 15° to the left 0.149 0.106 1.0000000 − 0.175 0.473
10° to the left 0.363 0.106 0.0127801 0.041 0.684
No midline roll 15° to the left 1.241 0.110 < 0.00000005 0.906 1.576
10° to the left 1.455 0.109 < 0.00000005 1.123 1.787
5° to the left 1.092 0.111 < 0.00000005 0.753 1.431
5° to the right 15° to the left 0.634 0.107 0.0000001 0.308 0.960
10° to the left 0.848 0.106 < 0.00000005 0.524 1.171
5° to the left 0.485 0.109 0.0001785 0.155 0.816
No midline roll − 0.607 0.112 0.0000015 − 0.948 − 0.266
10° to the right 15° to the left 0.488 0.108 0.0001467 0.158 0.817
10° to the left 0.701 0.107 < 0.00000005 0.375 1.028
5° to the left 0.339 0.110 0.0425100 0.005 0.672
No midline roll − 0.754 0.113 < 0.00000005 − 1.098 − 0.410
5° to the right − 0.146 0.110 1.0000000 − 0.482 0.189
15° to the right 15° to the left 0.629 0.104 < 0.00000005 0.313 0.944
10° to the left 0.842 0.103 < 0.00000005 0.529 1.155
5° to the left 0.480 0.105 0.0001151 0.160 0.800
No midline roll − 0.613 0.109 0.0000004 − 0.944 − 0.281
5° to the right − 0.005 0.106 1.0000000 − 0.328 0.317
10° to the right 0.141 0.107 1.0000000 − 0.185 0.466

Diff, the difference between the attractiveness score of the “I” level minus that of the “J” level. SE, standard error; CI, confidence interval.