Table 1.
Summary of the number of Identified Accents, L2, Acoustic Features, Classification Model used and type of Accent Class for several previous studies and this study.
| Study | L2 | Accents Identified | Features | Model | Performance% |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Kat L.W. et al. [17] | English | 2 | Prosodic | HMM | 73.38 |
| Kumpf K. et al. [18] | English | 2 | Phonotactic | HMM | 76.06 |
| Hansen J.H. et al. [1] | English | 3 | Prosodic | HMM | 88.09 |
| Phapatanaburi K. et al. [19] | English | 2 | MFCCs based | GMM, DNN | 93.00 |
| Fohr D. et al. [20] | English | 3 | Prosodic | GMM | 83.03 |
| Choueiter G. et al. [21] | English | 23 | plp-based vector | HLDA+MMI | 32.07 |
| Kashif K. et al. [14] | English | 2 | MFCCs based | SVM | 88.00 |
| Bahari M.H. et al. [22] | English | 5 | MFCCs based | SVM | 58.00 |
| Behravan H. et al. [38] | English | 7 | Attributes | i-Vector | 57.03 |
| Sheng L.M.A. et al. [24] | English | 3 | MFCCs based | CNN, MLP | 88.00 |
| Jiao Y. et al. [25] | English | 11 | MFCCs based | DNN+RNN | 52.48 |
| Upadhyay R. et al. [27] | English | 6 | MFCCs based | DBN | 90.02 |
| Purwar A. et al. [26] | English | 9 | MFCCs based | CNN+LSTM | 97.36 |
| Rizwan M. et al. [29] | English | 7 | MFCCs based | ELM, SVM | 76.92 |
| Bryant M. et al. [31] | English | 5 | MFCCs based | GDA, NB | 63.86 |
| Widyowaty D.S. et al. [32] | English | 5 | MFCCs based | CNN | 51.96 |
| Singh Y. et al. [33] | English | 5 | MFCCs based | CNN | 70.38 |
| Widyowaty D.S. et al. [34] | English | 6 | MFCCs based | KNN | 57.00 |
| Ensslin A. et al. [35] | English | 3 | Spectrogram based | CNN | 61.00 |
| Parikh P. et al. [36] | English | 3 | MFCCs based | CNN, DNN, RNN | 68.67 |
| Weninger F. et al. in [30] | Chinese | 3 | i-vector-based | DBN, bLSTM | 76.00 |
| Chen T. et al. [28] | Chinese | 4 | MFCCs based | GMM | 65.00 |
| Berjon P. et al. [37] | French | 5 | Spectrogram based | 2-Layer CNN | 70.65 |
| Abbas K. et al. [39] | Swiss German | 7 | phoneme-to-grapheme based | wav2vec | 52.08 |
| Eiman A. et al. [40] | Arabic | 5 | HMM phoneme based | DNN | 86.00 |
| Present Study | English | 6 | MFCCs+Prosodic | MKELM | 84.72 |