Skip to main content
. 2024 Aug 22;10(16):e36460. doi: 10.1016/j.heliyon.2024.e36460

Table 1.

Summary of the number of Identified Accents, L2, Acoustic Features, Classification Model used and type of Accent Class for several previous studies and this study.

Study L2 Accents Identified Features Model Performance%
Kat L.W. et al. [17] English 2 Prosodic HMM 73.38
Kumpf K. et al. [18] English 2 Phonotactic HMM 76.06
Hansen J.H. et al. [1] English 3 Prosodic HMM 88.09
Phapatanaburi K. et al. [19] English 2 MFCCs based GMM, DNN 93.00
Fohr D. et al. [20] English 3 Prosodic GMM 83.03
Choueiter G. et al. [21] English 23 plp-based vector HLDA+MMI 32.07
Kashif K. et al. [14] English 2 MFCCs based SVM 88.00
Bahari M.H. et al. [22] English 5 MFCCs based SVM 58.00
Behravan H. et al. [38] English 7 Attributes i-Vector 57.03
Sheng L.M.A. et al. [24] English 3 MFCCs based CNN, MLP 88.00
Jiao Y. et al. [25] English 11 MFCCs based DNN+RNN 52.48
Upadhyay R. et al. [27] English 6 MFCCs based DBN 90.02
Purwar A. et al. [26] English 9 MFCCs based CNN+LSTM 97.36
Rizwan M. et al. [29] English 7 MFCCs based ELM, SVM 76.92
Bryant M. et al. [31] English 5 MFCCs based GDA, NB 63.86
Widyowaty D.S. et al. [32] English 5 MFCCs based CNN 51.96
Singh Y. et al. [33] English 5 MFCCs based CNN 70.38
Widyowaty D.S. et al. [34] English 6 MFCCs based KNN 57.00
Ensslin A. et al. [35] English 3 Spectrogram based CNN 61.00
Parikh P. et al. [36] English 3 MFCCs based CNN, DNN, RNN 68.67
Weninger F. et al. in [30] Chinese 3 i-vector-based DBN, bLSTM 76.00
Chen T. et al. [28] Chinese 4 MFCCs based GMM 65.00
Berjon P. et al. [37] French 5 Spectrogram based 2-Layer CNN 70.65
Abbas K. et al. [39] Swiss German 7 phoneme-to-grapheme based wav2vec 52.08
Eiman A. et al. [40] Arabic 5 HMM phoneme based DNN 86.00
Present Study English 6 MFCCs+Prosodic MKELM 84.72