Table 2.
Studies Measuring Peripheral IL-6 or TNF-α in Association with Depression or Anxiety in Parkinson’s Disease. Number of Asterisks Denote Significance Level (* P<0.05, ** P<0.01, *** P<0.001)
| Assay source | Authors | Participants | Sudy design | Scale | Inflammatory marker | Results |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Serum | Fu et al 2023158 | PD = 273, HC = 91 | Cross sectional case control | HAMD-24, HAM-A, NMSS | TNF-α, IL-6, IL-8 | IL-6 positively correlated with HAMD*** and NMSS*** in PD patients. IL-8 and TNF-α showed no significant correlations |
| Serum | Rastegar et al 2019149 | PD = 160 (80 with LRRK mutation) | Longitudinal cohort study | GDS | MIP1β, IL-6, IFNY, IL-1RA, IL-5, GM-CSF, TNFα, CCL5, IL-2, IL-1β, CCL11, bFGF, VEGF, PDGF, CXCL10, IL-13, IL-4, MCP-1, IL-8, MIP1α, IL-10, GCSF, IL-15, IL-7, IL-12(p70), IL-17A, and IL-9 | The following baseline inflammatory markers correlated with fold change in GDS over 2 years in all patients: IL5 = 0.609**, IL8 = 0.415**, GCSF = 0.438**, MIP1β = 0.294*, IL10 = 0.435**, MIP1β = 0.294*, IL6 = 0.320*, IL1RA = 0.546**, TNFα = 0.436**, CCL5 = 0.337*, bFGF = 0.301*, VEGF = 0.640**, MIP1α = 0.435**, IL7 = 0.350*, IL15 = 0.643**. There were no other significant correlations with other markers. |
| Serum | Veselý et al 201887 | PD = 47 | Longitudinal cohort study | MADRS | CRP, C3, C4, IL-6 | Increased baseline levels of IL-6 associated with higher MADRS scores at follow up (2 years), rho = 0.366* |
| Plasma | Selikhova et al 2002162 | PD = 45 (27 with depression, 18 without depression), HC = 15 | Longitudinal cohort study | BDI, STAI | IL-6 | Higher IL-6 in PD with depression compared to PD**. Increases in IL-6 correlated with BDI scores r=0.64*** and anxiety scores r=0.65*** in PD group. |
| Blood (Unspecified) | Wan et al 2023164 | PD = 51 (with depression) HC = 51 | Cross sectional case control | HAM-A, HAMD | IL-6, S100β, mi-RNA-218-5p and mi-RNA-320a-5p | Negative correlation between miR-218-5p and HAM-A r = −0.4163**, HAMD r = −0.4927**. No other significant findings between inflamamtory markers and depression scores. |
| Blood (Unspecified) | Wang et al 2016165 | PD = 62 Control = 62 | Cross sectional case control | HAMD, HAMA | IL-1β, IL-6, IFNY, hsCRP, sIL-2R, TNF-α | In PD group, correlations between TNF-α r=0.345***, hsCRP r=0.393***, sIL-2R r=0.452*** and HAMD scores. Correlations with the same inflammatory markers and HAMA scores r=0.386*** r=0.423***, r = 0.364*** |
| Serum (with paired CSF) | Karpenko et al 2018153 | PD = 117, HC = 60 | Cross sectional case control | BDI, HADS, NMSS | IL-1β, IL-1RA, IL-6, IL-10, TNF-α | Correlation between HADS anxiety score r = 0.42*, HADS depression score r = 0.36* and serum IL-10 in PD. No significant associations found for CSF cytokines/other serum cytokines |
| Serum | Kim et al 2022166 | PD = 58 (45 at 3 year follow up), HC = 20) | Longitudinal cohort study | NMSS | IL-1β, IL-2, IL-6, IL-10, TNF-α, hsCRP | High PC3 (mainly loaded by IL-6 and IL-2) scores associated with worse NMSS over time*. High PC3 was associated with aggravation of mood and apathy* |
| Serum | Lindqvist et al 2012161 | PD = 86, HC = 40 | Cross sectional case control | FACIT, HAD, SCOPA-S | IL-6, TNF-α, sIL-2R, CRP | No significant correlations between non-motor symptoms and IL-6 or CRP. Regression analysis showed sIL-2R predicted FACIT scores β=−0.31*, HAD depression scores β=0.36***, and HAD anxiety scores β=0.32***. TNF-α predicted HAD depression score β= 0.31* in analysis with an outlier. |
| Plasma | Menza et al 2010163 | PD = 52 (comorbid depression) | Cross sectional cohort | HAMD-17, PDQ-8, SF36, CGI, PSQI | IL-1β, IL-6, IL-10, TNF-α | TNF-α correlated with higher PSQI r=0.347*, and HAMD-17 r= 0.44*** scores. After adjusting for multiple comparisons, correlation between TNF-α and HAMD-17 remained significant. |