Table 2.
Study | Study acronym | Country | Study type | Trial population | Key inclusion criteria | Model of care/involved teams | Setting (academic versus community) | Intervention arm | Standard-of-care arm |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Mohile et al., 20208 | COACH | USA | RCT (cluster-randomized), multisite | Patients: n = 541; meanA = 76.6 years; Caregivers: n = 414; meanA = 66.5 years |
Age ≥70 years; advanced solid cancer or lymphoma and ≥1 GA impairment at baseline; 1 caregiver of patients’ choice (optional) | Consultation | Community centers | Community oncology received GA and tailored recommendations for interventions | GA was carried out without reporting to oncologist, exception: alerts for depression/cognitive impairment |
Mohile et al., 20216 | GAP70+ | USA | RCT (cluster-randomized), multisite |
n = 718; meanA = 77.2 years |
Age ≥70 years; incurable solid cancer or lymphoma and ≥ 1 GA impairment at baseline | Consultation | Community centers | Community oncology received GA and tailored recommendations for interventions | GA was carried out without reporting to oncologist, exception: alerts for depression/cognitive impairment |
Li et al., 202124 | GAIN | USA | RCT, single site | n = 613; mdA = 71 years | Age ≥65 years; solid cancer, new therapy line intended | Consultation | Academic | CGA | GA results sent to oncologist for consideration; alerts for depression/cognitive impairment send with urgency |
Soo et al., 20229 | INTEGERATE | Australia | RCT, multisite | n = 154; mdA = 75.5 years | Age ≥70 years; solid cancer, or DLBCL; chemo-, immune-, or targeted therapy intended | Integrated oncogeriatric care | Academic | CGA, geriatric follow-up | No CGA, referral to geriatrician possible if requested by oncologist |
Puts et al., 202311 | 5C | Canada | RCT, multisite | n = 340; meanA = 76 years | Age ≥70 years; solid cancer, lymphoma, or myeloma; chemo-, immune-, or targeted therapy intended | Co-management | CGA, geriatric follow-up as needed | No CGA | |
Lund et al., 202112 | GERICO | Denmark | RCT, single site | n = 142; mdA = 75 years | Age ≥70 years; first diagnosis of CRC stage II-IV; adjuvant or palliative chemotherapy intended; G8 score ≤14 | Co-management | Academic and community centers | Pre-therapeutic CGA, regular geriatric follow-up as needed | No CGA |
Paillaud et al., 202225 | EGeSOR | France | RCT, multisite | n = 475; mdA = 75.3 years | Age ≥65 years; first diagnosis or late relapse of HN pre-treatment | Co-management | Academic + community centers | Pre-therapeutic CGA, geriatric follow-up for 24 months | Standard of care, no initial GA |
DuMontier et al., 202213 | — | USA | RCT, single center | n = 160 (IA: n = 100; SA: n = 60); meanA = 80.4 years | Age ≥75 years, initial consultation for multiple myeloma, lymphoma, or leukemia; transplant-ineligible; (pre-) frail | Consultation | Academic | Initial GA; geriatric consultation twice-weekly, geriatric interventions initiated | GA initially carried out, results blinded to oncologist, no geriatric consultations or interventions |
Orum et al., 202126 | — | Denmark | RCT, single center | n = 301; mdA = 75 years | Age ≥70 years, newly diagnosed solid cancer (LC, GI, HN), planned radiation or systemic cancer therapy | Consultation | Academic | CGA at study initiation with recommendations for interventions, further follow-up, and adaptation of interventions by the geriatric team | CGA at study initiation with recommendations for interventions without further follow-up or adaptation of interventions by the geriatric team |
Nipp et al., 202014 | — | USA | Pilot RCT, single center | n = 62; mdA = 72.3 years; LC: 43.55%; GI: 56.45% | Age ≥65 years, incurable GI cancer or LC | Co-management | Academic | Two in-person consultations with geriatrician, evaluation, and management of geriatric and palliative symptoms | Usual care without geriatric consultations |
Nipp et al., 202227 | — | USA | RCT, single center | n = 160 (n = 137 in PP analysis); mdA = 72 years | Age ≥65 years; GI, planned cancer surgery | Consultation | Academic | Preoperative geriatric consultation with CGA, one follow-up visit post-operative | No CGA, standard care |
Nadaraja et al., 202028 | — | Denmark | RCT, single center | n = 96; mA (IA) = 73.9 years; mdA (SA) = 76.8 years | Age ≥70 years; primary sites: GI, GU, GYN, or NSCLC; staring new line of systemic cancer therapy | Consultation | Academic | Screening with G8; if G8 < 14, CGA was carried out and treatment intensity discussed with MDT based on GA results; interventions initiated | Treatment as indicated, treatment decision based on the oncologist's clinical judgment |
Jeppesen et al., 201829 | — | Denmark | Pilot RCT, single center | n = 51; mdA = 72 years | Localized NSCLC, intended for SBRT, no age restriction | Consultation | Academic | SBRT +CGA | SBRT − CGA |
Hempenius et al., 2016, 201330,31 | LIFE | Netherlands | RCT, multicenter | n = 260; meanA = 77.4 years | Age ≥65 years; GFI <3; planned surgery for solid cancer | Co-management | Academic and community | Preoperative assessment of risk for delirium by the geriatric team, ongoing geriatric co-management after surgery | Usual care without geriatric co-management |
CGA, comprehensive geriatric assessment; CRC, colorectal cancer; DLBCL, diffuse large B-cell lymphoma; GA, geriatric assessment; GFI, Groningen Frailty Indicator; GI, gastrointestinal cancer; GU, genitourinary cancer; GYN, gynecological cancer; HN, head and neck cancer; IA, intervention arm; LC, lung cancer; meanA, mean age; mdA, median age; MDT, multidisciplinary team; NSCLC, non-small-cell lung cancer; PP, per protocol; RCT, randomized controlled trial; SA, standard arm; SBRT, stereotactic body radiotherapy.