Skip to main content
. 2024 Sep 20;32(10):676. doi: 10.1007/s00520-024-08847-y

Table 4.

Overview arguments per standardized patient assessment

Setting and substance Number of SPA Advice Arguments for advice Total arguments for advice Total arguments mentioned
Change No change
Substance use is unhealthy in general Changed taste or desire during treatment Risk of complications or side effects Negative impact on treatment effect Negative impact on physical condition during treatment in general Making use of the opportunity Quality of life is all that matters No impact on treatment effects
Curative
Smoking 01 Change X X 2 2
02 Change X X X 3 3
03 Change X X 2 2
04 Change X 1 1
05 Change X X X 3 3
06 Change X X 2 2
07 Change X X 2 2
08 Change X X X 3 3
09 Change X X 2 2
10 Change X X 2 2
Alcohol 11 Change X X 2 2
12 No change O X 1 2
13 Change X 1 1
14 Change X 1 1
15 No change O 0 1
16 Change X 1 1
17 No change 0 0
18 Change 0 0
19 Change X 1 1
Palliative
Smoking 20 No change O 0 1
21 No change O 0 1
22 No change X X 2 2
23 Change X 1 1
24 No change O O 0 2
25 Change X X 2 2
26 No change O X 1 2
27 No change O O X 1 3
28 No change O X X 2 3
29 No change X 1 1
Alcohol 30 Change X O 1 2
31 No change 0 0
32 No change O X 1 2
33 No change O O 0 2
34 No change O 0 1
35 No change O 0 1
36 No change O X 1 2
37 Change 0 0
38 Change X 1 1
39 No change O 0 1

X = arguments used by oncologists to support their advice (change or no change); O = arguments mentioned by oncologists that did not match their advice

Abbreviation: SPA standardized patient assessment