Skip to main content
. 2005 May 19;102(22):7882–7887. doi: 10.1073/pnas.0502300102

Table 2. Estimates of the scaled selection parameter γ(=2NCs) for conservative, moderate, and radical nonsynonymous changes, as defined by different measures of amino acid exchangeability, and for nonsynonymous mutations categorized as “benign,” “possibly damaging,” or “probably damaging” by the polyphen program, which uses site-specific structural and phylogenetic information.

Conservative
Moderate
Radical
Exchangeability measure Ref. Range Inline graphic Range Inline graphic Range Inline graphic
Physicochemical measures
    Miyata metric 16 x ≤ 0.89 -5.71* 0.89 < x ≤ 1.85 -8.45* x > 1.85 -14.06*
    Grantham's distance 17 x ≤ 44 -7.48* 44 < x ≤ 82 -7.77* x > 82 -12.04*
Experimental measures
    Experimental exchangeability 20 x > 0.354 -6.35* 0.256 < x ≤ 0.354 -8.79* x ≤ 0.256 -12.15*
General measures based on structural models
    Protein stability matrix 21 x > 0.210 -8.19* 0.030 < x ≤ 0.210 -8.55* x ≤ 0.030 -10.15*
Phylogenetic measures
    PAM-120 18 x > 1 -5.32 -1 < x ≤ 1 -8.35* x ≤ -1 -12.76*
    BLOSUM-45 19 x > 0 -8.41* -1 < x ≤ 0 -3.96 x ≤ -1 -13.39*
    BLOSUM-62 19 x > 0 -8.41* -1 < x ≤ 0 -4.09 x ≤ -1 -12.75*
    BLOSUM-80 19 x > 0 -8.46* -2 < x ≤ 0 -4.49 x ≤ -2 -13.52*
Site-specific structural/phylogenetic measures
    Polyphen 22 “Benign” (310 SNPs) -6.072* “Possibly damaging” (97 SNPs) -11.732* “Probably damaging” (56 SNPs) -23.602*

Ranges define the values of the exchangeability measure, x, over which the category extends.

*

Categories for which a likelihood ratio test rejects neutrality (P < 0.01).