Table 3.
Study ID | Report ID | Country | Intervention | N families | Family participants (treatment) | Family participants (control) | Family component |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1 | 1 | Greece | Family Talk Intervention |
Nt 30 Nc 32 |
Fathers 6 Mothers 26 Male offspring 14 Female offspring 16 |
Fathers 6 Mothers 24 Male offspring 19 Female offspring 13 |
Parent + partner + child take part One parents + child session per child. No sessions with siblings or other family members |
2 | 73 | GER | Family Talk Intervention (Group Version) |
Nt 28 Nc 9 |
Father – Mother – Male offspring 12 Female offspring 16 |
Father – Mother – Male offspring 4 Female offspring 5 |
One individual family session with parents and child. No information on involvement of siblings or other family members |
3 |
93 119 123 |
Finland | Family Talk Intervention |
Nt 53 Nc 56 |
Father – Mother – Offspring 76 |
Father – Mother – Offspring 69 |
Parent + partner + child One individual family session with parents and child. No information on involvement of siblings or other family members |
4 | 186 | USA | Family Talk Intervention | Nt 7 |
Parent 7 Partner 7 Offspring 8 |
na | 1–2 Family sessions. No information on involvement of siblings or other family members |
5 | 180 | USA | Family Talk Intervention | Nt+c 28 |
Parents 54 Average number of children in family 2 |
na | 1–2 Family sessions. No information on involvement of siblings or other family members |
6 |
148 162 177 178 179 |
USA | Family Talk Intervention |
Nt 55 Nc 44 |
Parents 97 Offspring 78 |
Parents 76 Offspring 54 |
1–2 Family sessions. No information on involvement of siblings or other family members |
7 | 5 | USA | Mobile-enhanced family-focused therapy (FFT) | Nt 22 |
Mother 16 Father 17 Male offspring 10 Female offspring 12 |
na | 12 Family sessions with child and parent(s). Other family members are invited to take part |
8 |
8 20 34 70 |
USA | Coping and promoting strength |
Nt 70 Nc 66 |
Mothers 107 across both groups Fathers 29 across both groups 113 offspring across both groups |
6 Sessions for all interested family members | |
9 | 132 | USA | Coping and promoting strength |
Nt 20 Nc 20 |
Parent 20 Partner – Offspring 20 |
Parent 20 Partner – Offspring 20 |
6 Sessions for all interested family members |
10 | 10 | UK | Young SMILES |
Nt 18 Nc 15 |
Parent 18 Partner – Male offspring 12 Female offspring 12 |
Parent 15 Partner – Male offspring 7 Female offspring 9 |
None |
11 |
11 19 31 48 |
USA | Ecologically based family therapy (EBFT) |
Nt 123 Nc 60 |
Mothers 123 across both groups Offspring 180 across both groups 36% included siblings across both groups 9% included partner across both groups 10% other family member across both groups |
All children, partners and other caregivers invited. 12 family sessions focus on needs assessment, problem-solving, communication | |
12 | 21 | USA | Ecologically based family therapy (EBFT) |
Nt 49 Nc 19 |
Mothers 49 Partners – Offspring – |
Mothers 19 Partners – Offspring – |
All children, partners and other caregivers invited. 12 family sessions focus on needs assessment, problem-solving, communication |
13 |
201 16 |
GER | Family Group Cognitive-Behavioural |
Nt 50 Nc 50 |
Parent 50 Offspring 50 Siblings 77% |
Parent 50 Offspring 50 Siblings 72% |
The first two sessions involve parents and children for the whole session, the remaining 6 sessions start and end in the family- and group- setting but include separate activities for parents and children. Siblings are allowed to join |
14 |
18 29 72 82 105 116 122 138 |
USA | Family Group Cognitive-Behavioural |
Nt 90 Nc 90 |
Mothers 160 across both groups Fathers 20 across both groups Female offspring 121 across both groups Male offspring 121 across both groups |
8–12 Sessions where parents and children meet together part of the time and separately part of the time. No information on involvement of siblings or other family members | |
15 | 26 | GER | Kanu Intervention |
Nt 41 Nc 26 |
Parents 46 Partner – Offspring 60 |
Parents 25 Partner – Offspring 44 |
10 Individual sessions involving parent (and partner) and children |
16 | 45 | Canada | The Renascent Children’s Programme | Nt 19 |
Mother 15 Father 6 Grandmother 3 Uncle 1 Stepparent 1 Male offspring 12 Female offspring 14 |
na | Parent, guardian or other family member can attend. Generally separate groups for parents and children with overlapping activities over 4 days. No specific information about the activities available |
17 | 62 | USA | Parent-Adolescent CBT (PA-CBT) protocol |
Nt 16 Nc 8 |
Parent 16 Offspring 16 |
Parent 8 Offspring 8 |
All 18 individual sessions with child concluded with a conjoint “check-in” meeting between parent and teen to enhance positive communication |
18 | 67 | AUS | Supporting Kids and Their Environment (SKATE) | Nt 89 |
Parents – Female offspring 51 Male offspring 38 |
na | Letters sent to parents with tasks that children and parents work on together |
19 | 71 | UK | CBT with mother–child interaction |
Nt 71 Nc 69 Nc 71 |
All mothers Offspring 71 |
All mothers Offspring 71 Offspring 69 |
Two sessions with mother and child completing task that are video recorded for later video-feedback |
21 | 91 | USA | Fortalezas Familiares (family strengths) | Nt 13 |
Mothers 13 Fathers 10 Grandmother 1 |
na | Other caregivers or children are invited to take part. All 12 sessions include all family members |
22 | 101 | USA | Project Hope |
Nt 16 Nc 14 |
Parent – Partner – Offspring – |
Parent – Partner – Offspring – |
3 Sessions for parents and target child and 3 sessions for the whole family |
23 | 109 | USA | Keeping Families Stronger Intervention | Nt 10 |
Mothers 10 Partner 3 Children 16 |
na | Partners and children were invited to take part. Families attended 10 weekly multi-family sessions involving separate but concurrent parent and child groups and one individual family session. Home projects for families |
24 | 118 | GER | Eltern- und Kinder-Training in emotional belasteten Familien EFFEKT-E | 375a |
Mothers had average of 1.07- 1.99 children Partners – |
Not reported | Separate child and parent sessions and 1 mother–child session, where child and mother practise content learned together. No information on involvement of partners or other family members |
25 | 135 | USA | Prevention Intervention Programme (PIP) | Nt 9 |
Mothers 9 Partners 5 Male offspring 4 Female offspring 5 Siblings – |
na | One family session with main aim to increase shared understanding. Who takes part in family session is defined by families themselves |
26 | 143 | Spain | Family Competence Programme |
Nt 15 Nc 16 |
Parents 28 Offspring 19 |
Parents 30 Offspring 16 |
Over 14 sessions, families have lunch together, then separate parent and child groups (1 h). In second half (1 h), parents and children practise together. “Entire family” is invited to take part |
27 | 146 | USA | Strong African American Families (SAAF) |
Nt 98 Nc 69 |
Caregiver 98 Average children 2.75 |
Caregiver 69 Average children 2.84 |
Seven separate child and parent sessions followed by joint session to practise skills. No information on involvement of partners and other family members |
28 |
173 176 |
USA | Focus on Families |
Nt 75 Nc 55 parents |
Parents 78 Offspring 97 |
Parents 57 Offspring 81 |
Children join 12 family sessions to help families practise new skills. Parents have additional 20 separate sessions. No information on involvement of other family members |
29 | 164 | UK | Strength to Strength | Nt 10 | Not reported | na | Family sessions with parents and children form part of intervention. No information about frequency or length of sessions, or involvement of other family members |
30 | 200 | USA | Adolescent coping with Stress course |
Nt 45 Nc 49 |
Offspring 45 | Offspring 49 | No family component |
31 | 92 | USA | Multisystemic Therapy-Building Stronger Families Programme |
Nt 25 Nc 18 |
Mothers 25 Offspring 25 Fathers were excluded from study |
Mothers 18 Offspring 18 Fathers were excluded from study |
Family is assessed together and defines treatment goals together. Other members in and around family are involved to develop safety plan for child. Individual sessions are delivered based on family members’ needs, thus involvement of family members and activities can vary |
32 | 208 | USA | Multisystemic Therapy-Building Stronger Families Programme |
Nt 43 Nc 44 |
Parents 51 Mothers 94% Offspring 43 female offspring 47.1% |
Parents 46 Mothers 83% Offspring 43 female offspring 48% |
Family is assessed together and defines treatment goals together. Other members in and around family are involved to develop safety plan for child. Individual sessions are delivered based on family members’ needs, and thus, involvement of family members and activities can vary |
33 |
6 202 |
USA | Family-focused treatment |
Nt 61 Nc 66 |
Female offspring 37 Male offspring 24 |
Female offspring 45 Male offspring 21 |
12 Sessions with child, parent, partner and if possible siblings |
34 |
205 211 |
China | Multi Family Therapy |
Nt 34 Nc 27 |
Mothers 30 Fathers 4 Partner 12 Offspring 45 |
Mothers 22 Fathers 5 Partner 7 Offspring 18 |
4-Day programme plus 2 half day reunions that include multiple families and their members |
35 | 212 | Iran | Family Friendly Programme |
Nt 30 Nc 30 |
Parents 30 Offspring 30 |
Parents 30 Offspring 30 |
11 Sessions to enhance parent and child relationship using elements from parent–child interaction therapy and mindfulness-based cognitive therapy. No information about involvement of partners, siblings, or other family members |
36 | 94 | USA | Family-focused treatment |
NCt 21 NCc 19 |
Parents – Female offspring 10 Male offspring 11 |
Parents— Female offspring 7 Male offspring 12 |
Involved parent, partners, children, and siblings in 12 sessions |
37 | 2 | Sweden | Family Talk Intervention | Not reported |
8 parents 7 children |
na | 1–2 Family sessions. No information on involvement of siblings or other family members |
38 | 15 | AUS | The Family Model | Not reported |
15 parents 8 children 6 siblings |
na | 1 Session with family and clinician about impact of illness |
40 |
59 214 |
UK | Kidstime | Not reported |
5 parents 6 children |
na | Family sessions with separate parent and child sessions and shared dinner in the end |
41 | 79 | UK | Moving Parents and Children Together Programme | Not reported |
36 parents 37 children |
na | Eight sessions that involve multiple families, some sessions include separate activities for children and parents and some for the family unit |
43 | 206 | IRE | Family Talk Intervention | Not reported |
23 parents 7 partners 15 children |
na | 1–2 Family sessions. Clinician meets with whole family including siblings. No information on involvement of other family members |
44 | 213 | AUS | Enhanced CBT Intervention | Not reported | 10 parents | na | Parents and children get parallel treatment and learn about bidirectional impact of anxiety in parent and child. No joint sessions |
Note: Nt sample size treatment group, Nc sample size control group, na not applicable