Skip to main content
. 2024 Sep 11;13(9):870. doi: 10.3390/antibiotics13090870

Table 3.

Comparative analysis of conventional and synthetic approaches to overcome challenges in phage therapy.

Challenges in Phage Therapy Conventional Approach Synthetic Approach
1 Narrow host range The use of phage cocktail [111,112] Genetic manipulation of receptor-binding protein [30,34]
2 Emergence of phage-resistant bacteria Phage cocktail; combined therapy of antibiotic and phage [113,114] Genetic manipulation of receptor-binding protein [115]; incorporation of small RNAs or CRISPR-Cas system to silence antibiotic resistance determinant [17,49] or delivery of genes encoding proteins to sensitize bacteria against antibiotics [116]
3 Necessitate identification of phage with therapeutic effect against patients’ isolates (personalized medicine) Establish phage biobanks (isolating large phage collections) [117] Engineering of phage tail fibers to alter host range [35,36,38]
4 Rapid clearance by reticuloendothelial system (RES) Multiple phage dosing [118] Phage capsid protein mutagenesis [41]; PEGylation of phage particles [43]
5 Phage pharmacokinetics (bioavailability through oral administration) Pharmacological neutralization of gastric acid [119] Encapsulation of phage in nanoparticles [120,121]
6 Limited accessibility to biofilm-producing bacteria Use only phages with intrinsic biofilm-degrading properties [122,123], or combined therapy using phage and biofilm-degrading enzymes [124] Engineered phages expressing biofilm-degrading enzymes [31]
7 Difficulties in defining pharmacokinetics (e.g., MIC) Standardize routes and dosages of administration (required specified combinations of phage-host for each infection) [125] Generation of non-proliferative anti-bacterial phage capsids [17]
8 Safety concern: risk of horizontal gene transfer The use of phage-derived endolysin [126] Development of well-characterized, non-propagating phages [127], introduction of antibacterial cargo using phagemids [128,129] or phage-inducible chromosomal islands (PICIs) [20]
9 Presence of potential hazardous genes in phage genome (toxin, virulence, antibiotic resistance genes, etc.) Obligate virulent phage is preferred in therapy [113]; whole-genome analysis should be done in the first place Custom-made phage can be generated easily using current techniques [30,34,130]; the use of self-destructive engineered phage (conjugation to gold nanorods) [29]
10 Low purity and potential toxin contamination in phage preparation Purification by CsCl density gradient and ion exchange column [113] or affinity chromatography [131] The use of cell-free system (cell-free-transcription-translation, TXTL) for phage production [130]