Table 4.
Author, Year of Publication, Country | Included costs | Direct medical costs | Direct non-medical or indirect (patients’) Costs | Indirect (societal) costs | Perspective year(s) of cost | Main outcomes | Main results |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Pushkar & Tiwari, 2022 India [9] | Direct medical and Indirect costs |
Spectacles; PRP laser; Surgical procedure; Medicine; Clinical fee; Investigation. |
Travelling; Diet control; Health classes and Miscellaneous. |
Not- included | Payers in 2018 | Cost |
Average annual direct costs INR 1,901,000 (US$ 24,142.7); indirect costs INR 10,096,000 (US$ 128,219.2). Currency Exchange Rate INR 1 = US$ 0.0127 |
Orji et al., 2021, India [10] |
Direct medical and non- medical costs |
Consultation, Investigation; PRP laser; IV injection; and Surgery |
Transportation; boarding; and loading | Not-included | Payers, medical institutes, societal and third party in 2019. | Cost |
Total cost of 1000 pts INR 23,767. 838 (US$ 320,865.8). Median cost per patient INR 8,214 (US$ 110). Currency Exchange Rate 1 INR = US$ 0.0135 |
Toth et al., 2020, Hungary [11] |
Direct medical and indirect costs |
Screening mobile camera; General eye exam; OCT, FA & U/S; PRP laser; and Vitrectomy. |
Loss of workdays | Not-included |
Satutory health insuranc and patients in 2016 and in 2045 |
Cost |
In 2016, screening cost with no DR per pt $3.0; mild/ observable DR $46.0; referable NPDR $207.8; proliferative DR $2376.2; proliferative DMO $3517.3. In 2045, screening with no DR per pt $12.8; mild/ observable DR $7.0; referable NPDR $2.7; proliferative DR $115.4; and proliferative DMO $69. |
Sasongko et al., 2019 Indonesia [12] |
Direct medical and indirect costs |
Screening Mobil unit transport per pt; Camera maintenance; Photographer; Medications; nurse/ field assistant. Hospital costs includes Registration; General eye exam and referral letter per visit. Additional examination OCT per eye; PRP laser; IV injection; and Vitrectomy. |
Transportation cost for screening per session and referral letter per session. |
Loss of workdays per day and hospital treatment. |
Healthcare perspective and patients perspectives in 2017 and in 2025. | Cost |
In 2017, Screening costs without DR $20 million; mild to moderate NPDR $5.9 million; VTDR requiring laser PRP $2.6 million; VTDR requiring additional IVJ anti-VEGF $1751.7 million; advanced PDR needing vitrectomy $251.6 million. In 2025, screening cost mild to moderate NPDR $92 million; laser treatment for VTDR $901.9 million; additional IVJ anti-VEGF $6279 million; and vitrectomy for advanced PDR $1587 million. |
Heintz et al., 2010, Sweden [6] |
Direct medical costs | Cost of hospital overheads, ophthalmologist fees, eye examinations including photographs of the retina, PRP, hospitalizations, and other resource use related to vitrectomy | Not-included | Not-included | National cost per patient principle, in 2008 | Cost |
Total annual healthcare cost € 9.9 million US$ 10.494 million; representing an overall healthcare cost of € 106,000 million US$ 112.36 million per 100,000 population. Currency Exchange Rate EUR 1 = US$ 1.37 |
Schmier et al., 2009, USA [13] |
Direct medical costs |
Inpatient care per beneficiary in cohort cases (NPDR and PDR ) and control in cohort. Compared to outpatient care cases (NPDR and PDR ) and control. Inpatient care for beneficiaries with one or more claim cases (NPDR and PDR) and control. compared to outpatient care cases (NPDR and PDR) and control |
Not-included | Not-included | Medicare claim service from 1999 to 2004 | Cost |
An average annual direct cost Inpatient care for control and case groups US$ 1,223 Outpatient care for control and case groups US$ 28. |
Lee et al., 2008, USA [14] | Direct medical and Indirect non-medical costs |
Medical services; mean hospital inpatient stays; emergency visits; outpatient visits; and other services. Mean of prescription drugs includes OHG and insulin |
Not-included | Absenteeism and disablity | Payers, Medical and prescription claims and disability claim) for 12 months | Cost |
Mean annual total direct & indirect costs of DR employees ($18218 vs. $3548), respectively. Direct and indirect costs of no-DR employees ($11898 vs. $2374), respectively. |
Happich & Reitberger, 2008, Germany [15] |
Direct medical cost (Statutory Health Insurance GKV) and indirect (social perspective) costs |
Range of medical devices; Temporary working disability; and Other services; Hospitalization; Ophthalmologist fee; Medication; Other physician fee; Transport; Further non-drug therapy; and rehabilitation |
Not-included |
Range of medical devices; Temporary work disability; Other services; Early retirement; Hospitalization; Ophthalmic fee; Medication; Other physician fee; Further non-drug therapy; Home help services; Rehabilitation and nursing services; and transport |
GKV and societal, in 2002 | Cost |
Average annual social perspective € 3.51 bn (US$ 3.3345 bn) while GKV perspective € 2.23 bn (US$ 2.1185 bn). Currency Exchange Rate EUR 1 = US$ 0.95 |
Rein et al., 2006, USA [5] |
Direct medical, direct non-medical, and indirect costs | Outpatient and inpatient visits. |
Long term care; nursing home; guide dogs; independent living services for elderly blind individuals; national library services for the blind; physically handicap; and American printing house. |
Productivity loss, decrease wages. | Medicare claims and MarketScan claims in 2004 | Cost |
Total cost of Major visual disorders $35.4 bn; Direct medical cost US$ 16.2 bn. Other direct costs US$ 11.1 bn. Productivity loss US$ 8 bn. |
Phillips et al., 1994, Mexico [16] |
Direct medical direct non-medical and indirect costs |
Checkup; angiogram; echography; internal medicine; laboratory; PRP; cryotherapy; vitrectomy; cataract; and eyeglasses. |
Transportation accommodation, and others. |
Time loss; productivity loss; income loss; Disability; and percentage poor sight 51%. |
Payers in 1985 and in 1991 | Cost |
Average cost per pt to pt Mex$ 1,549,515 (US$ 80,574.78). Average social cost of hospital treatment per pt Mex$ 1,877,035 (US$ 97,605.8). Currency Exchange Rate Mex$3 = US$1 |
Morsanutto et al., 2006, Italy [17] |
Direct medical costs |
Drugs; Visit to specialist; visit to GP; diagnosis; hospitalizations |
Not-included | Not-included | National Health Service in 2002 | Cost |
Mean total healthcare cost of DM € 1909.67 US$2,272.50. Mean cost of single DM-related complication € 1808.17 US$ 2,151.72. Total cost per pt with DR € 1,329.9 US$ 1,582.59. Currency Exchange Rate € 1 = US$ 1.19 |
Schmitt et al., 2004, Switzerland [18] |
Direct medical costs |
Drug costs; Ambulatory costs include consultations, Outpatient diagnostic procedures, outpatient invasive procedures, and laboratory tests. Hospital care. |
Not-included | Not-included | Swiss Health Insurance in 1998. | Cost |
Total direct cost CHF 0.582 US$ 0.874 bn; represented 2.2% total country healthcare. Currency Exchange Rate CHF 1 = US$ 1.50 |
O’Brien et al., 2003, Canada [19] |
Direct medical costs | Outpatient visits, labs, and laser treatment. | Not-included | Not-included |
Health Insurance and government, in 2000 |
Cost |
Blindness cost in the state US$ 1794.35 Currency Exchange Rate Cand$1 = US$ 0.85 |
STDR ( Sight-threatening Diabetic Retinopathy); IVJ (Intravitreal Injection); FA (Fluorescein Angiography); OCT (Ocular Coherence Tomography);
RAAB-DR (Rapid Assessment of Avoidable Blindness with the Diabetic Retinopathy Module; VTDR (Vision- threatening Diabetic Retinopathy;
PRP (Pan-retinal photocoagulation); NPDR (Non-proliferative Diabetic Retinopathy); PDR (Proliferative Diabetic Retinopathy; DME (Diabetic
Macular Edema)Macular Edema). EMR (Electronic Medical Records); MR (Medical Records); bn (billion); pt (patient).CDWO (Care Date
Warehouse in Ostergotland); NDR (National Diabetic Register); GKV(Gesetzliche Krankenversicherung); and GP (General practitioner)