Skip to main content
. 2024 Sep 30;24:424. doi: 10.1186/s12886-024-03665-6

Table 4.

Direct and indirect costs in the systematic review

Author, Year of Publication, Country Included costs Direct medical costs Direct non-medical or indirect (patients’) Costs Indirect (societal) costs Perspective year(s) of cost Main outcomes Main results
Pushkar & Tiwari, 2022 India [9] Direct medical and Indirect costs

Spectacles;

PRP laser;

Surgical procedure;

Medicine;

Clinical fee;

Investigation.

Travelling;

Diet control;

Health classes and Miscellaneous.

Not- included Payers in 2018 Cost

Average annual direct costs

INR 1,901,000

(US$ 24,142.7); indirect costs

INR 10,096,000

(US$ 128,219.2).

Currency Exchange Rate

INR 1 = US$ 0.0127

Orji et al., 2021, India [10]

Direct medical

and non-

medical costs

Consultation, Investigation;

PRP laser;

IV injection; and

Surgery

Transportation; boarding; and loading Not-included Payers, medical institutes, societal and third party in 2019. Cost

Total cost of 1000 pts

INR 23,767. 838

(US$ 320,865.8).

Median cost per patient INR 8,214

(US$ 110).

Currency Exchange Rate

1 INR = US$ 0.0135

Toth et al., 2020,

Hungary [11]

Direct medical and

indirect costs

Screening mobile camera;

General eye exam;

OCT, FA & U/S;

PRP laser; and Vitrectomy.

Loss of workdays Not-included

Satutory health insuranc and patients

in 2016 and in 2045

Cost

In 2016, screening cost with no DR per pt $3.0;

mild/ observable DR $46.0; referable NPDR

$207.8; proliferative DR $2376.2; proliferative DMO $3517.3.

In 2045, screening with no DR per pt $12.8;

mild/ observable DR $7.0;

referable NPDR $2.7;

proliferative DR $115.4;

and proliferative DMO

$69.

Sasongko et al., 2019

Indonesia [12]

Direct medical and indirect costs

Screening Mobil unit transport per pt;

Camera maintenance; Photographer;

Medications;

nurse/ field assistant.

Hospital costs includes Registration; General eye exam and referral letter per visit.

Additional examination OCT per eye; PRP laser;

IV injection; and Vitrectomy.

Transportation cost for screening per session and referral letter per session.

Loss of workdays per day and

hospital treatment.

Healthcare perspective and patients perspectives in 2017 and in 2025. Cost

In 2017, Screening costs without DR $20 million;

mild to moderate NPDR

$5.9 million; VTDR requiring laser PRP

$2.6 million; VTDR requiring additional IVJ anti-VEGF

$1751.7 million;

advanced PDR needing vitrectomy

$251.6 million.

In 2025, screening cost mild to moderate NPDR

$92 million;

laser treatment for VTDR

$901.9 million;

additional IVJ anti-VEGF

$6279 million;

and vitrectomy for advanced PDR

$1587 million.

Heintz et al., 2010,

Sweden [6]

Direct medical costs Cost of hospital overheads, ophthalmologist fees, eye examinations including photographs of the retina, PRP, hospitalizations, and other resource use related to vitrectomy Not-included Not-included National cost per patient principle, in 2008 Cost

Total annual healthcare cost

€ 9.9 million

US$ 10.494 million;

representing an overall healthcare cost of

€ 106,000 million US$ 112.36 million

per 100,000 population.

Currency Exchange Rate

EUR 1 = US$ 1.37

Schmier et al.,

2009,

USA [13]

Direct medical costs

Inpatient care per beneficiary in cohort cases (NPDR and PDR ) and control in cohort.

Compared to outpatient care cases (NPDR and PDR ) and control.

Inpatient care for beneficiaries with one or more claim cases (NPDR and PDR) and control. compared to outpatient care cases (NPDR and PDR) and control

Not-included Not-included Medicare claim service from 1999 to 2004 Cost

An average annual direct cost

Inpatient care for control and case groups

US$ 1,223

Outpatient care for control and case groups

US$ 28.

Lee et al., 2008, USA [14] Direct medical and Indirect non-medical costs

Medical services; mean hospital inpatient stays; emergency visits; outpatient visits; and other services.

Mean of prescription drugs includes OHG and insulin

Not-included Absenteeism and disablity Payers, Medical and prescription claims and disability claim) for 12 months Cost

Mean annual total direct & indirect costs of DR employees ($18218 vs. $3548), respectively.

Direct and indirect costs of no-DR employees

($11898 vs. $2374), respectively.

Happich & Reitberger, 2008, Germany [15]

Direct medical cost (Statutory Health Insurance GKV) and indirect (social perspective)

costs

Range of medical devices; Temporary working disability; and Other services; Hospitalization; Ophthalmologist fee;

Medication;

Other physician fee;

Transport;

Further non-drug therapy; and rehabilitation

Not-included

Range of medical devices; Temporary work disability;

Other services;

Early retirement; Hospitalization;

Ophthalmic fee;

Medication;

Other physician fee;

Further non-drug therapy;

Home help services;

Rehabilitation and nursing services; and transport

GKV and societal, in 2002 Cost

Average annual social perspective € 3.51 bn

(US$ 3.3345 bn)

while GKV perspective

€ 2.23 bn

(US$ 2.1185 bn).

Currency Exchange Rate

EUR 1 = US$ 0.95

Rein et al.,

2006,

USA [5]

Direct medical, direct non-medical, and indirect costs Outpatient and inpatient visits.

Long term care; nursing home; guide dogs; independent living services for elderly

blind individuals;

national library services for the blind; physically handicap;

and American printing house.

Productivity loss, decrease wages. Medicare claims and MarketScan claims in 2004 Cost

Total cost of Major visual disorders $35.4 bn;

Direct medical cost

US$ 16.2 bn.

Other direct costs

US$ 11.1 bn.

Productivity loss

US$ 8 bn.

Phillips et al., 1994,

Mexico [16]

Direct medical direct non-medical and indirect costs

Checkup; angiogram; echography;

internal medicine;

laboratory;

PRP; cryotherapy; vitrectomy;

cataract; and

eyeglasses.

Transportation

accommodation, and others.

Time loss; productivity loss; income loss;

Disability; and percentage poor sight 51%.

Payers in 1985 and in 1991 Cost

Average cost per pt to pt

Mex$ 1,549,515

(US$ 80,574.78).

Average social cost of hospital treatment per pt

Mex$ 1,877,035

(US$ 97,605.8).

Currency Exchange Rate

Mex$3 = US$1

Morsanutto

et al., 2006,

Italy [17]

Direct medical costs

Drugs;

Visit to specialist;

visit to GP;

diagnosis;

hospitalizations

Not-included Not-included National Health Service in 2002 Cost

Mean total healthcare cost of DM € 1909.67

US$2,272.50.

Mean cost of single DM-related complication

€ 1808.17

US$ 2,151.72.

Total cost per pt with DR

€ 1,329.9

US$ 1,582.59.

Currency Exchange Rate

€ 1 = US$ 1.19

Schmitt

et al., 2004,

Switzerland [18]

Direct medical costs

Drug costs;

Ambulatory costs include consultations,

Outpatient diagnostic procedures, outpatient invasive procedures, and laboratory tests.

Hospital care.

Not-included Not-included Swiss Health Insurance in 1998. Cost

Total direct cost

CHF 0.582

US$ 0.874 bn;

represented

2.2% total country healthcare.

Currency Exchange Rate

CHF 1 = US$ 1.50

O’Brien

et al., 2003,

Canada [19]

Direct medical costs Outpatient visits, labs, and laser treatment. Not-included Not-included

Health Insurance and government,

in 2000

Cost

Blindness cost in the state

US$ 1794.35

Currency

Exchange Rate

Cand$1 = US$ 0.85

STDR ( Sight-threatening Diabetic Retinopathy); IVJ (Intravitreal Injection); FA (Fluorescein Angiography); OCT (Ocular Coherence Tomography);

RAAB-DR (Rapid Assessment of Avoidable Blindness with the Diabetic Retinopathy Module; VTDR (Vision- threatening Diabetic Retinopathy;

PRP (Pan-retinal photocoagulation); NPDR (Non-proliferative Diabetic Retinopathy); PDR (Proliferative Diabetic Retinopathy; DME (Diabetic

Macular Edema)Macular Edema). EMR (Electronic Medical Records); MR (Medical Records); bn (billion); pt (patient).CDWO (Care Date

Warehouse in Ostergotland); NDR (National Diabetic Register); GKV(Gesetzliche Krankenversicherung); and GP (General practitioner)