Table 2.
Comparison between phage therapy and antibiotics (Kortright 2019)
| Sr. No. | Parameters | Phage therapy | Antibiotics |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1. | Bactericidal agent | Virulent phages cause cell lysis, which is bactericidal while bioengineered phages are bacteriostatic and prevent the growth of phages | Antibiotics cause cell death also known as bactericidal or can prevent the growth of bacteria known as bacteriostatic |
| 2. | Discovery | Phage discovery is easy and rapid | Antibiotic discovery is time-consuming, expensive which requires drug design and development processes along with toxic potential testing |
| 3. | Specificity | Bacteriophages are known to be highly specific and have a narrow spectrum of activity | Antibiotics have a broad spectrum of activity |
| 4. |
Microbiota disruption |
Host specificity of phages leads to no disruption of the normal microbiota | Antibiotics with a broad-spectrum mode of action lead to disruption of the normal microbiota |
| 5. | Side effects | Unlike antibiotics, phage therapy does not cause anaphylaxis in humans | Many include allergies and anaphylactic disorders |
| 6. | Toxicity | Phages are nontoxic but lysed cell remnants may cause allergies in some cases | Toxicity levels can vary depending on the dosage and conditions of the patient |
| 7. | Versatility |
Phages are versatile, i.e., they display genetic diversity and abundance Phages can be delivered by various delivery systems and approaches Phages can be customized, i.e., phage cocktails can be administered depending on the bacteria that is being targeted |
Antibiotics are not as versatile as compared to phages; to make them more effective, they can be used in combination with phages |
| 8. | Resistance |
The narrow range of activity of phages makes it specific; if resistance emerges then only a selected few bacterial species populations will be affected To reduce the chances of the development of resistance cocktail formulations can be used to treat antibiotic-resistant pathogens |
A broad range of activity means that a large population of bacteria can be exposed to the antibiotic and there are greater chances of development of resistance against the bacteria and the potential for widespread resistance to emerge is greater |
| 9. | Dosage | Dose concentration increases due to the process of host-dependent replication that increases the number of bacteriophages | The dose is dependent on the adsorption, distribution, metabolism, and excretion of the antibiotic |
| 10. | Self-limitation | Once the target bacteria are killed, the bacteriophages stop functioning | No self-limitation occurs in antibiotics |
| 11. | Availability of clinical evidence | Fewer clinical trials and studies are available; information about clinical relevance is still limited | Enough clinical studies and information about clinical relevance are available |
| 12. | Development costs | Rapid and low-cost | Time-consuming and expensive |
| 13. | Kinetics | Single hit or self-amplifying | Single hit |
| 14. | Formulation | Fixed or variable | Fixed |
| 15. | Immunogenicity | Low/yet to be established | Variable |
| 16. | Regulation | Underway | Well-established |