Skip to main content
. 2024 Jun 10;14(3):586–612. doi: 10.1007/s44197-024-00247-z

Table 1.

Effective steps and barriers to SBE management

Region Countrya Manufacturer(s) Effective steps Barriers in SBE management References
Asia China

National Institute of Preventive Medicine

Shanghai Serum Bio-technology Co Ltd

Haphazard ASV supply

Non-specific ASVs

ASV shortage

[31]
India

Biological E Limited

Premium Serums and Vaccines Pvt. Ltd

VINS Bioproducts Ltd

King Institute of Preventative Medicine and Research

Haffkine Biopharmaceutical Corporation Ltd

Bharat Serums and Vaccines Limited

Emergency ambulance service with lifesaving equipment and drugs, including ASV

Under reporting of SBE and mortality

Lack of safe and effective antivenoms

Poor healthcare facilities

Inclination towards traditional healers

ASV manufactured only against big four

Untrained medical staff

[9194]
Indonesia PT Bio Farma (Persero)

Antivenom cross-neutralization data required for marketing approval

SBE treatment costs covered on co-payment basis

A single ASV is available

Costly and limited ASV

Antivenom ineffective against many Indonesian species

Absence of antivenom in nearby health care facilities and lack of transportation

Absence of cold-chain storage

Cultural barriers

[75, 95]
Iran

Razi Vaccine & Serum Research Institute

Padra Serum Alborz

Toxicology trained physicians

National unified protocol for SBE management

Under-reporting of SBE cases

Preference of traditional treatment

No formal clinical trial of one antivenom

Antivenom starting dose not established by formal clinical trial

Wound incision and fasciotomy still practiced

[74]
Israel Kamada limited

Short distance to hospital in some areas

Uncertain snake identification in many cases

Lack of uniform treatment protocol for SBE

No antivenom available against one of the venomous endemic species-Atractaspis engaddensis

[96, 97]
Japan KM Biologics Co. Ltd Snake institute to help physicians Unapproved antivenom against R. tigrinus [98]
Myanmar Myanmar pharmaceutical factory

Myanmar Snakebite Project

Antivenom usage reported to ministry

lack of pharmaceutical logistic system affects antivenom distribution [75]
Pakistan National Institute of Health

Inclination towards traditional healers

Long transportation times

Manufactures liquid antivenom but has poor refrigeration facilities

Low domestic supply

No guidance protocol for antivenom production

Inadequately trained health care workers

[99]
Philippines Biologicals Manufacturing Division (Research Institute for Tropical Medicine)

Subsidised antivenom production

SBE treatment cost included in health insurance

Seek traditional healers

ASV shortage

Ineffective ASV supply chain

[75]
Republic of Korea KoreaVaccine Co Ltd National reference standard for antivenom

Costly antivenoms

Validated guideline for antivenoadministration unavailable

No ASV against R. tigrinus

[100102]
Saudi Arabia National Antivenom & Vaccine Production Center (NAVPC)

Good medical facility

Antivenom available even in remote areas

Established national records

[103]
Thailand Queen Saovabha Memorial Institute

Well-established supply chain

real-time antivenom inventory

No national training on SBE management since 2016 [75]
Vietnam Institute of Vaccines and Biological Substances (IVAC)

Inclination towards traditional practices

Poor documentation of SBE records

Lack of SBE statistics

Limited studies on clinical presentation of SBE

No national protocol for SBE management

Antivenom shortage and high cost

Long distance to hospitals

Lack of trained HCPs

Lack of SBE education and public awareness

Monovalent antivenoms prevalent which require accurate snake identification

Use of antivenoms of unknown efficacy and potency

Only one study on adverse reaction to antivenom so far

[68]
Africa South Africa South African VaccinProducers (SAVP)

Free toxicology advice to HCPs and public at all hours

Trained physicians

Free snake identification charts

Discrepancy in antivenom availability in urban and rural areas

SBE reporting not mandatory

Need of cold chain transport

Short expiry of ASVs

[39, 104]
Tunisia Institut Pasteur de Tunis

No validated scale of SBE severity

Limited studies on SBE

Lack of health facilities in rural areas

Delay between bite and hospital arrival

Propensity for at home first aid such as tourniquets

[105]
North America Costa Rica Instituto Clodomiro Picado

Free antivenom

SBE notification mandatory

Traditional medicine rarely used

Quality control of antivenoms

Good cold chain

National protocol for SBE diagnosis and treatment

Regular training sessions on SBE management

A part of population is devoid of SBE related governmental aids, such as agricultural workers

Access to health facility delayed in some regions

[106]
Mexico

Birmex (Instituto Nacional de Higiene)

Laboratorios Silanes, S. A. de C. V

Inclination towards traditional healers

Limited data on SBE epidemiology

[107]
United States

BTG International Inc

Wyeth (owned by Pfizer)

Cost transparency

Concerns about insurance cover

Antivenom not available at all facilities

Costly antivenom

Controversial maintenance therapy

[108, 109]
South America Bolivia Ministerio de Salud y Deportes, Instituto Nacional de Laboratorios De Salud

Snake misidentification

Untrained HCPs

[110]
Brazil

Fundacao Ezequiel Dias (FUNED)

Centro de Producao e Pesquisas de Immunobiol

Instituto Butantan

Instituto Vital Brazil S.A

Compulsory case notification

Free antivenom

Inclination towards traditional practices

No antivenom in rural areas

Lack of trust in local health care

Low confidence among clinicians in SBE management

Overdosing and under-dosing of antivenoms

Antivenom expiration owing to lack of inventory

Antivenom storage issues due to lack of stable electricity

Limited ASV production capacity

[64, 111]
Colombia

Instituto Nacional de Salud (CO)

Laboratorios Biologicos PROBIOL Ltda

Mandatory reporting

Regular antivenom shortage

Lack of cold chain transport

No policy for antivenom distribution

[63]
Ecuador Instituto Nacional de Higiene y Medicina Tropical "Leopoldo Izquieta Pérez" Fixed maximum price for antivenom

Antivenom production stopped in 2012

Dependent on import of ASV from Costa Rica

[24]
Europe Croatia Imunološki Zavod (Institute of Immunology) Low reported mortality

Last antivenom batch expired in 2019

Dependent on imports now

[25]
Serbia Institute of Virology, Vaccine and Sera TORLAK

Antivenom available

Snakes protected by law

HCPs unawareness of species in their areas

Snake misidentification common

[85]
Spain INOSAN BIOPHARMA S. A. (Spain) Very few cases and fatalities [112]
The United Kingdom Micropharm Ltd 24 h rapid clinical advice available through poison centres Exotic snakebites a challenge [113]
Australia Australia Seqirus Pty Ltd

Costly ASV

Need of cold chain transport

Limited shelf-life

Single antivenom to treat envenoming by all sea snakes – due to rarity of sea snake envenoming-more time for administering antivenom than terrestrial SBE cases

Limited clinical evidence to support use of this antivenom for sea snake envenoming

[21]

The table lists the anti-snake venom (ASV) manufacturing countries and companies. Additionally, it presents a non-exhaustive list of effective steps taken by ASV manufacturing countries and the existing gaps in snakebite management. The information has been sourced from the WHO snake ASV database [23] and the most recent literature (2020-present) to provide insights into the present situations in these countries. The list is by no means exhaustive and additional steps or gaps might be present in the respective countries

aFor Algeria, Argentina, Bulgaria, Egypt, Peru, Poland, Russia, Turkey, Uzbekistan, and Venezuela, no relevant literature, published 2020 onwards, could be found