Table 2.
Characteristics of systematic reviews of outcome measurement instruments (n = 100)
Characteristic | Reviews (n) |
---|---|
Construct of interest | |
Patient-reported outcome | 51 |
Non-patient-reported outcome | 29 |
Patient- and non-patient-reported outcome | 20 |
Level of health of the construct of interest* | |
Biological and physiological variables | 29 |
Symptom status | 56 |
Physical state | 42 |
Emotional state | 19 |
Cognitive/mental state | 13 |
Functional status | 63 |
Physical functioning | 48 |
Social functioning | 22 |
Cognitive/mental functioning | 21 |
Role functioning | 9 |
General health perceptions | 37 |
Health-related quality of life | 36 |
Self-rated health | 3 |
Overall quality of life | 9 |
Age of the population of interest | |
Children 0–18 | 20 |
Adults 18 + | 58 |
Both | 22 |
Condition of the population of interest* | |
Circulatory system | 11 |
Congenital and genetic conditions | 8 |
Digestive, endocrine and metabolic system | 16 |
Ear, eye, and respiratory system | 14 |
Genitourinary and reproductive system | 9 |
Infections and parasites | 5 |
Injuries and external causes | 13 |
Mental and behavioral health | 19 |
Musculoskeletal system | 30 |
Neoplasms | 15 |
Nervous system | 16 |
Perinatal and pediatric health | 4 |
Skin and subcutaneous tissue | 10 |
Factors/symptoms influencing health status/contact with health services | 42 |
OMI type included* | |
Questionnaires | 41 |
Clinical rating scales | 41 |
Performance-based tests | 24 |
Observations | 7 |
Interviews | 7 |
Imaging tests | 6 |
Laboratory tests | 6 |
Diaries | 5 |
Videos | 1 |
Measurement properties considered per review, median [range]* | [1–9] |
Content validity | 64 |
Structural validity | 46 |
Internal consistency | 69 |
Cross-cultural validity/measurement invariance | 37 |
Reliability | 87 |
Measurement error | 47 |
Construct validity | 82 |
Criterion validity | 50 |
Responsiveness | 62 |
*Multiple characteristics could be reported for the same review