Skip to main content

Table 1.

MRI Studies on Kaplan Fibers.

Study Cases, n Mean age, years KF visibility (%) MRI criteria KF injury prevalence (%) Time between ACL rupture and MRI Other injury correlated with KF injury
Van Dyck et al. (17) 69 29 100 Van Dyck 33 < 6 weeks Significant difference in the frequency and grading between KF, and ALL injuries
Batty et al. (18) 161 26 97–100 Batty 24.3–6.4 Before and after 90 days Injury lateral meniscal injury/collateral ligaments injury/posteromedial tibial bone bruising
Marom et al. (19) 72 27.65 85–89 Batty 46–60 < 6 weeks NR
Berthold et al. (49) 104 26.8 100 Van Dyck 52.9 < 90 days Lateral supracondylar/tibial plateau BME
Devitt et al. (27) 267 23.6 100 Batty 17.6 < 60 days Lateral meniscal tears
Devitt et al. (28) 122 24.2 100 Batty 26.2 < 60 days NR
Balendra et al. (20) 100 22.3 100 Batty 61 < 21 days Lateral femoral condyle bone edema/injuries to the superficial MCL, deep MCL/ramp lesions
Lynch et al. (24) 131 27.8 88.5 Van Dyck 38.9 < 90 days No correlation between KF injury and meniscal tears, or posterolateral tibial bone bruise
Lynch et al. (22) 45 13.2 94.6 Batty/Van Dyck 37.7–11.1 < 90 days No correlation with meniscal tears/Segond fracture
Runer et al. (25) 66 + 25 38.4/14.3 84.8–76.0 Runer 18.2–16 NR NR
Shi et al. (26) 51 14.9 88.2 Marom 29.4–35.3 0–182 days LCL injury/no correlation with MCL or meniscal injury
Watanabe et al. (21) 91 25 93.4 Batty 23.5 < 90 days No correlation between concomitant ligamentous injury, and meniscal injury
Lord et al. (29) 89 21 100 Batty 30.3 < 60 days NR
Chandra et al. (10) 134 NR 97.2 Chandra 34 < 90 days Meniscal tear and bone marrow edema in a classic pivot shift impaction injury pattern

KF, Kaplan fiber; NR, not reported.