Table 1.
MRI Studies on Kaplan Fibers.
Study | Cases, n | Mean age, years | KF visibility (%) | MRI criteria | KF injury prevalence (%) | Time between ACL rupture and MRI | Other injury correlated with KF injury |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Van Dyck et al. (17) | 69 | 29 | 100 | Van Dyck | 33 | < 6 weeks | Significant difference in the frequency and grading between KF, and ALL injuries |
Batty et al. (18) | 161 | 26 | 97–100 | Batty | 24.3–6.4 | Before and after 90 days | Injury lateral meniscal injury/collateral ligaments injury/posteromedial tibial bone bruising |
Marom et al. (19) | 72 | 27.65 | 85–89 | Batty | 46–60 | < 6 weeks | NR |
Berthold et al. (49) | 104 | 26.8 | 100 | Van Dyck | 52.9 | < 90 days | Lateral supracondylar/tibial plateau BME |
Devitt et al. (27) | 267 | 23.6 | 100 | Batty | 17.6 | < 60 days | Lateral meniscal tears |
Devitt et al. (28) | 122 | 24.2 | 100 | Batty | 26.2 | < 60 days | NR |
Balendra et al. (20) | 100 | 22.3 | 100 | Batty | 61 | < 21 days | Lateral femoral condyle bone edema/injuries to the superficial MCL, deep MCL/ramp lesions |
Lynch et al. (24) | 131 | 27.8 | 88.5 | Van Dyck | 38.9 | < 90 days | No correlation between KF injury and meniscal tears, or posterolateral tibial bone bruise |
Lynch et al. (22) | 45 | 13.2 | 94.6 | Batty/Van Dyck | 37.7–11.1 | < 90 days | No correlation with meniscal tears/Segond fracture |
Runer et al. (25) | 66 + 25 | 38.4/14.3 | 84.8–76.0 | Runer | 18.2–16 | NR | NR |
Shi et al. (26) | 51 | 14.9 | 88.2 | Marom | 29.4–35.3 | 0–182 days | LCL injury/no correlation with MCL or meniscal injury |
Watanabe et al. (21) | 91 | 25 | 93.4 | Batty | 23.5 | < 90 days | No correlation between concomitant ligamentous injury, and meniscal injury |
Lord et al. (29) | 89 | 21 | 100 | Batty | 30.3 | < 60 days | NR |
Chandra et al. (10) | 134 | NR | 97.2 | Chandra | 34 | < 90 days | Meniscal tear and bone marrow edema in a classic pivot shift impaction injury pattern |
KF, Kaplan fiber; NR, not reported.