Skip to main content
. 2024 Sep 30;18(9):e0012000. doi: 10.1371/journal.pntd.0012000

Table 5. Advantages and disadvantages of a conventional Illumina sequencing-based HLA genotyping assay versus an ONT sequencing-based HLA genotyping assay.

HLA genotyping method Advantages Disadvantages
AlloSeq Tx17 (CareDx; Illumina-based) • Includes all exons for all genes, improving HLA allele calling and resolving ambiguities.
• Up to the 4th field (8-digit) resolution.
• Also includes the HLA-E, -F, -G, -H, MICA, and MICB genes.
• Time-intensive (days instead of hours)
• No real-time sequencing
• Need for high capital investment (Illumina sequencing devices)
• Short-read data
NanoTYPE (Omixon; ONT-based) • Turnaround time of hours instead of days
• User-friendly workflow with minimal time spent preparing library
• Low capital investment (can run on an ONT MinION device of ~1000USD)
• Portable (MinION Mk1B device is palm-sized)
• Sequencing can be monitored and stopped in real-time once sufficient coverage has been reached
• Limited to the 3rd field (6-digit) resolution
• Does not include all exons (more ambiguities)
• Does not include all HLA region genes