Skip to main content
. 2021 May 25;33(27):2008452. doi: 10.1002/adma.202008452

Table 1.

Current bio‐piezoelectric platforms and their biomedical applications

Biomedical application Piezoelectric phase Morphology Dimension Synthesis route Application Working site Working condition Properties Ref.
Physical Health Monitoring P(VDF‐TrFE) Nanowire

Diameter: ≈400 nm

Length: ≈10 µm

Nanotemplate‐based electricity‐grown Monitor small human activities Human skin 10 mm × 10 mm device effective area ≈4.8 V maximum voltage, ≈0.11 µA cm–2 current density [ 66 ]
PZT Thin film \ Inorganic‐based laser lift‐off Monitor epidermal pulse signals Human skin Within 30 kPa pressure 0.018 kPa−1 sensitivity, 60 ms response time [ 122 ]
PVDF Film Thickness:≈200 nm \ Monitor cyclic expand‐contract movement of the chest Human chest 37 N, 1.4 Hz cyclic mechanical force ≈1.5 V open‐circuit voltage, ≈400 nA short‐circuit current [ 120 ]
PZT Ceramic Thickness: ≈20 µm \ Monitor gait signals during movement Human foot 0.4 MΩ load resistance and 12 N, 1 Hz force 32 µW maximum power per chip (5 mm × 5 mm) [ 124 ]
PVDF Nanofiber Average diameter: 100–120 nm Continuous electrospinning Monitor body motions Human foot 8.3 kPa of the applied stress amplitude ≈48 V open‐circuit voltage, ≈6 µA short‐circuit current [ 172 ]

PVDF

BaTiO3

Nanofiber \ Electrospinning Monitor body motions Human skin Within 40 kPa pressure 0.017 kPa−1 sensitivity, 290 ms response time [ 173 ]
PVDF Nanofiber \ Electrospinning Monitor micropressure changes outside cardiovascular walls Cardiovascular wall 1.5 Hz, 1 kPa pressure 1154 V cm–3 piezoelectric output [ 115c ]
PMN‐PZT Film Thickness: ≈20 µm Solid‐state crystal growth Monitor the heartbeat Epicardium 2 cm curvature radius, 0.4 Hz frequency mechanical bending ≈40 V open‐circuit voltage, ≈4.5 µA short‐circuit current [ 109 ]
Disease Diagnosing PVDF Film \ Spin‐coating Detection of disease gas markers Exhaled air 4–9 m s–1 airflow rate 0–600 ppm gas markers concentration detection range [ 134 ]
ZnO Film Thickness: ≈600 nm Radio frequency sputtering Detection of acute myocardial infarction markers Serum 10 µL sample consumption 20 pg mL–1 cTnI concentration detection limit [ 131 ]
PZT Ceramic \ \ Detection of cancer markers Serum 1 µL sample consumption, within 30 min 0.25 ng mL–1 PSA concentration detection limit [ 106 ]
PZT Ceramic \ \ Detection of mechanical heterogeneity in thyroid tissue lesions Thyroid tissue Standard Becton Dickinson (BD) 25 Gauge 3.50″ fine needle Malignant tissue lesions were rapidly detected based on heterogeneity of tissue hardness/stiffness [ 132 ]
ZnO Nanowire

Diameter: ≈150 nm

Average length: ≈12 µm

Seed‐assisted hydrothermal synthesis Detection of the urea/uric‐acid concentration Human skin Urea concentration range: 0–80 × 10–3 m, uric acid concentration range: 0–0.6 × 10–3 m Linear response to urea concentration and uric acid concentration [ 174 ]
PVDF Film Thickness: ≈28 µm \ Detection of tactile signals of submucosal tumors Mucosa Young's modulus range: 1.01–3.51 MPa Sensor response is proportional to the Young's modulus of test sample [ 175 ]
Bionic/Smart Devices ZnO Nanowire

Average diameter: ≈250 nm

Average length: 10–14 µm

Seed‐assisted hydrothermal synthesis Detection of taste‐producing substances Taste bud 2 × 10−2 m ascorbic acid 171.7 relative response value [ 139 ]
ZnO Nanowire

Diameter: ≈50 nm

Aspect ratio: 20

Solution‐based hydrothermal synthesis Detection of both static and dynamic tactile stimuli Human skin Within 0.3 kPa pressure –6.8 kPa−1 sensitivity [ 88 ]

ZnO

PVDF

Film \ Thermal evaporation and wet‐chemical method Detection of motion‐powered atmosphere Human skin 57° bending angle, relative oxygen concentration range: 20%‐50%, relative humidity range: 45%‐85% Linear response to oxygen concentration and relative humidity [ 137 a]
PVDF Film \ \ Detection of plantar pressure signals Human plantar Within 200 kPa pressure 0.00814 V kPa–1 sensitivity [ 176 ]
PZT Nanofiber \ Electrospinning Detection of tactile pressure Human skin Measurement pressure range: 0–1300 kPa 18.96 V kPa–1 sensitivity [ 177 ]
PVDF Nanofiber Average diameter: 993 ± 631 nm Electrospinning Sensing of pressure, integrating cold/heat Human skin Measurement force range: 3–53 N, measurement initial temperature range: 20–80 °C Pressure‐sensing signal became steady‐state, while pyroelectric signal appeared as a pulse [ 138 ]

PZT

P(VDF‐TrFE)

Film Thickness: ≈100 µm Hydrothermal method Harvested and converted mechanical energy from human activities \ <5 Hz bending frequency ≈16 V maximum output voltage [ 100 ]
Cancer treatment BaTiO3 Nanoparticle Radius: ≈150 nm \ Generated electrical stimulation to cancer cells Cancer cell 1 MHz, 1 W cm–2 ultrasonic wave Blocked the cell cycle of cancer cells and slowed their proliferation [ 27a ]
Black phosphorus Nanosheet

Average thickness: 5.3 ± 3.7 nm

Average lateral dimension: 162.4 ± 99.4 nm

Ultrasonic exfoliation Eliminated cancer cells with reactive oxygen species Cancer cell 1 MHz, 1.5 W cm–2 ultrasonic wave >70% cell viability losses of cancer cells [ 146 ]
P(VDF‐TrFE) Nanoeel \ Templated method Magnetic manipulation for locomotion and pulsatile drug release Cancer cell

5‐15 mT, 1–16 Hz magnetic field (locomotion)

10 mT, 7 Hz magnetic field (drug release)

≈35% cancer cell death [ 148 ]
P(VDF‐TrFE) Nanowire Average diameter: ≈250 nm Templated method Magnetic manipulation for locomotion and magnetoelectric drug release Cancer cell

<10 mT rotating magnetic field (locomotion)

Alternating magnetic field with same energy source (drug release)

≈40% cancer cell death [ 178 ]
BaTiO3 Nanoparticle Average diameter: 106.91 ± 49.72 nm Solvothermal process and thermal annealing Eliminated cancer cells with reactive oxygen species Cancer cell 1 W cm–2 ultrasonic wave Cancer cell viability decreased to 12.6% [ 67b ]
KNNSe Ceramic

Diameter: ≈10 mm

Thickness: ≈1 mm

Solid phase sintering Eliminated cancer cells Cancer cell 3 d of cocultivation Cancer cell viability decreased to 30% [ 179 ]
PVDF Film \ \ Eliminated cancer cells Cancer cell 12 d of intermittent continuous light stimulation 87.46% tumor inhibition rate [ 180 ]
Tissue regeneration ZnO Nanorod

Length: 2.79 ± 0.14 µm

Diameter: 0.58 ± 0.07 µm

Hydrothermal method Generation of endogenous electric field at the wound Skin wound 2 × 2 cm2 area with 95.2% ZnO nanorods filling density Enhanced cell migration, metabolic activity, and differentiation [ 153 ]
BaTiO3 Nanoparticle \ \ Regenerated bone Osteoblast cell 60 N, 3 Hz force Enhanced alkaline phosphatase activity and bone‐inducing activity [ 27b ]
LiNbO3 \ \ \ Fabricated therapeutic vascular tissue Skeletal muscle 4 weeks after transplantation 72.8% of blood flow restored [ 181 ]
PVDF Nanocomposite \ Solvent casting Induced cellular mechano‐ and electro‐transduction process in bone Osteoblast cell 4 d of cocultivation Formed a bone‐mimicking structure that improves cell seeding and proliferation [ 151 ]
P(VDF‐TrFE) Nanofiber Diameter: 1.24 ± 0.13 µm Electrospinning Stimulated cardiac muscle cells Cardiac muscle cell 12 d of cocultivation Promoted cardiomyocyte attachment, proliferation and alignment, preserving contractility [ 182 ]
PVDF Nanofiber \ Electrospinning Stimulated osteoblast cells Osteoblast cell 3 d of cocultivation Exhibited higher Saos‐2 cells activity [ 105 ]
Neurotrauma and neurodegenerative treatment

P(VDF‐TrFE)

BaTiO3

Film \ \ Enhanced differentiation during cell growth Neuronal cell 1 W cm–2 ultrasonic wave Promoted neuronal maturation and neurite outgrowth in SH‐SY5Y [ 183 ]
BaTiO3 Nanoparticle Diameter: 58 ± 15 nm \ Induced differentiation of targeted neural stem‐like cell Neural stem‐like cell 1 MHz, 1 W cm–2 ultrasonic wave Achieved navigation to a specific neural stem‐like PC12 cell in a controllable way [ 159 ]
KNNS Ceramic \ Solid phase sintering Stimulated retina Retina 30 Vpp input voltage ≈72 µA current, ≈9.2 nA µm–2 current density [ 161 ]
PVDF Nanocomposite \ \ Stimulated differentiation and proliferation of neuronal cells Neuronal cell 7 d of cocultivation Showed higher PC12 cell activity [ 184 ]
PVDF \ \ Solvent casting Stimulated neuronal cells Neuronal cell 4 months after being implanted Exhibited significant electrophysiological, morphological and functional nerve restoration [ 185 ]
ZnO Nanoparticle Average diameter: 30–80 nm \ Stimulated cell attachment and proliferation Schwann cell 18 weeks in vivo Improved severe nerve defect recovery [ 104 ]
Antifouling treatment BaTiO3 Nanoparticle Average diameter: ≈130 nm Hydrothermal method Whitened teeth Teeth 10 h of vibration Exhibited a whitening effect [ 27c ]
PVDF Film Thickness: 110 µm \ Inhibited bacterial growth and antifouling effects \ 4 Hz stimuli Inhibited biofilm formation effectively [ 166 ]