Table 1.
Current bio‐piezoelectric platforms and their biomedical applications
Biomedical application | Piezoelectric phase | Morphology | Dimension | Synthesis route | Application | Working site | Working condition | Properties | Ref. |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Physical Health Monitoring | P(VDF‐TrFE) | Nanowire |
Diameter: ≈400 nm Length: ≈10 µm |
Nanotemplate‐based electricity‐grown | Monitor small human activities | Human skin | 10 mm × 10 mm device effective area | ≈4.8 V maximum voltage, ≈0.11 µA cm–2 current density | [ 66 ] |
PZT | Thin film | \ | Inorganic‐based laser lift‐off | Monitor epidermal pulse signals | Human skin | Within 30 kPa pressure | 0.018 kPa−1 sensitivity, 60 ms response time | [ 122 ] | |
PVDF | Film | Thickness:≈200 nm | \ | Monitor cyclic expand‐contract movement of the chest | Human chest | 37 N, 1.4 Hz cyclic mechanical force | ≈1.5 V open‐circuit voltage, ≈400 nA short‐circuit current | [ 120 ] | |
PZT | Ceramic | Thickness: ≈20 µm | \ | Monitor gait signals during movement | Human foot | 0.4 MΩ load resistance and 12 N, 1 Hz force | 32 µW maximum power per chip (5 mm × 5 mm) | [ 124 ] | |
PVDF | Nanofiber | Average diameter: 100–120 nm | Continuous electrospinning | Monitor body motions | Human foot | 8.3 kPa of the applied stress amplitude | ≈48 V open‐circuit voltage, ≈6 µA short‐circuit current | [ 172 ] | |
PVDF BaTiO3 |
Nanofiber | \ | Electrospinning | Monitor body motions | Human skin | Within 40 kPa pressure | 0.017 kPa−1 sensitivity, 290 ms response time | [ 173 ] | |
PVDF | Nanofiber | \ | Electrospinning | Monitor micropressure changes outside cardiovascular walls | Cardiovascular wall | 1.5 Hz, 1 kPa pressure | 1154 V cm–3 piezoelectric output | [ 115c ] | |
PMN‐PZT | Film | Thickness: ≈20 µm | Solid‐state crystal growth | Monitor the heartbeat | Epicardium | 2 cm curvature radius, 0.4 Hz frequency mechanical bending | ≈40 V open‐circuit voltage, ≈4.5 µA short‐circuit current | [ 109 ] | |
Disease Diagnosing | PVDF | Film | \ | Spin‐coating | Detection of disease gas markers | Exhaled air | 4–9 m s–1 airflow rate | 0–600 ppm gas markers concentration detection range | [ 134 ] |
ZnO | Film | Thickness: ≈600 nm | Radio frequency sputtering | Detection of acute myocardial infarction markers | Serum | 10 µL sample consumption | 20 pg mL–1 cTnI concentration detection limit | [ 131 ] | |
PZT | Ceramic | \ | \ | Detection of cancer markers | Serum | 1 µL sample consumption, within 30 min | 0.25 ng mL–1 PSA concentration detection limit | [ 106 ] | |
PZT | Ceramic | \ | \ | Detection of mechanical heterogeneity in thyroid tissue lesions | Thyroid tissue | Standard Becton Dickinson (BD) 25 Gauge 3.50″ fine needle | Malignant tissue lesions were rapidly detected based on heterogeneity of tissue hardness/stiffness | [ 132 ] | |
ZnO | Nanowire |
Diameter: ≈150 nm Average length: ≈12 µm |
Seed‐assisted hydrothermal synthesis | Detection of the urea/uric‐acid concentration | Human skin | Urea concentration range: 0–80 × 10–3 m, uric acid concentration range: 0–0.6 × 10–3 m | Linear response to urea concentration and uric acid concentration | [ 174 ] | |
PVDF | Film | Thickness: ≈28 µm | \ | Detection of tactile signals of submucosal tumors | Mucosa | Young's modulus range: 1.01–3.51 MPa | Sensor response is proportional to the Young's modulus of test sample | [ 175 ] | |
Bionic/Smart Devices | ZnO | Nanowire |
Average diameter: ≈250 nm Average length: 10–14 µm |
Seed‐assisted hydrothermal synthesis | Detection of taste‐producing substances | Taste bud | 2 × 10−2 m ascorbic acid | 171.7 relative response value | [ 139 ] |
ZnO | Nanowire |
Diameter: ≈50 nm Aspect ratio: 20 |
Solution‐based hydrothermal synthesis | Detection of both static and dynamic tactile stimuli | Human skin | Within 0.3 kPa pressure | –6.8 kPa−1 sensitivity | [ 88 ] | |
ZnO PVDF |
Film | \ | Thermal evaporation and wet‐chemical method | Detection of motion‐powered atmosphere | Human skin | 57° bending angle, relative oxygen concentration range: 20%‐50%, relative humidity range: 45%‐85% | Linear response to oxygen concentration and relative humidity | [ 137 a] | |
PVDF | Film | \ | \ | Detection of plantar pressure signals | Human plantar | Within 200 kPa pressure | 0.00814 V kPa–1 sensitivity | [ 176 ] | |
PZT | Nanofiber | \ | Electrospinning | Detection of tactile pressure | Human skin | Measurement pressure range: 0–1300 kPa | 18.96 V kPa–1 sensitivity | [ 177 ] | |
PVDF | Nanofiber | Average diameter: 993 ± 631 nm | Electrospinning | Sensing of pressure, integrating cold/heat | Human skin | Measurement force range: 3–53 N, measurement initial temperature range: 20–80 °C | Pressure‐sensing signal became steady‐state, while pyroelectric signal appeared as a pulse | [ 138 ] | |
PZT P(VDF‐TrFE) |
Film | Thickness: ≈100 µm | Hydrothermal method | Harvested and converted mechanical energy from human activities | \ | <5 Hz bending frequency | ≈16 V maximum output voltage | [ 100 ] | |
Cancer treatment | BaTiO3 | Nanoparticle | Radius: ≈150 nm | \ | Generated electrical stimulation to cancer cells | Cancer cell | 1 MHz, 1 W cm–2 ultrasonic wave | Blocked the cell cycle of cancer cells and slowed their proliferation | [ 27a ] |
Black phosphorus | Nanosheet |
Average thickness: 5.3 ± 3.7 nm Average lateral dimension: 162.4 ± 99.4 nm |
Ultrasonic exfoliation | Eliminated cancer cells with reactive oxygen species | Cancer cell | 1 MHz, 1.5 W cm–2 ultrasonic wave | >70% cell viability losses of cancer cells | [ 146 ] | |
P(VDF‐TrFE) | Nanoeel | \ | Templated method | Magnetic manipulation for locomotion and pulsatile drug release | Cancer cell |
5‐15 mT, 1–16 Hz magnetic field (locomotion) 10 mT, 7 Hz magnetic field (drug release) |
≈35% cancer cell death | [ 148 ] | |
P(VDF‐TrFE) | Nanowire | Average diameter: ≈250 nm | Templated method | Magnetic manipulation for locomotion and magnetoelectric drug release | Cancer cell |
<10 mT rotating magnetic field (locomotion) Alternating magnetic field with same energy source (drug release) |
≈40% cancer cell death | [ 178 ] | |
BaTiO3 | Nanoparticle | Average diameter: 106.91 ± 49.72 nm | Solvothermal process and thermal annealing | Eliminated cancer cells with reactive oxygen species | Cancer cell | 1 W cm–2 ultrasonic wave | Cancer cell viability decreased to 12.6% | [ 67b ] | |
KNNSe | Ceramic |
Diameter: ≈10 mm Thickness: ≈1 mm |
Solid phase sintering | Eliminated cancer cells | Cancer cell | 3 d of cocultivation | Cancer cell viability decreased to 30% | [ 179 ] | |
PVDF | Film | \ | \ | Eliminated cancer cells | Cancer cell | 12 d of intermittent continuous light stimulation | 87.46% tumor inhibition rate | [ 180 ] | |
Tissue regeneration | ZnO | Nanorod |
Length: 2.79 ± 0.14 µm Diameter: 0.58 ± 0.07 µm |
Hydrothermal method | Generation of endogenous electric field at the wound | Skin wound | 2 × 2 cm2 area with 95.2% ZnO nanorods filling density | Enhanced cell migration, metabolic activity, and differentiation | [ 153 ] |
BaTiO3 | Nanoparticle | \ | \ | Regenerated bone | Osteoblast cell | 60 N, 3 Hz force | Enhanced alkaline phosphatase activity and bone‐inducing activity | [ 27b ] | |
LiNbO3 | \ | \ | \ | Fabricated therapeutic vascular tissue | Skeletal muscle | 4 weeks after transplantation | 72.8% of blood flow restored | [ 181 ] | |
PVDF | Nanocomposite | \ | Solvent casting | Induced cellular mechano‐ and electro‐transduction process in bone | Osteoblast cell | 4 d of cocultivation | Formed a bone‐mimicking structure that improves cell seeding and proliferation | [ 151 ] | |
P(VDF‐TrFE) | Nanofiber | Diameter: 1.24 ± 0.13 µm | Electrospinning | Stimulated cardiac muscle cells | Cardiac muscle cell | 12 d of cocultivation | Promoted cardiomyocyte attachment, proliferation and alignment, preserving contractility | [ 182 ] | |
PVDF | Nanofiber | \ | Electrospinning | Stimulated osteoblast cells | Osteoblast cell | 3 d of cocultivation | Exhibited higher Saos‐2 cells activity | [ 105 ] | |
Neurotrauma and neurodegenerative treatment |
P(VDF‐TrFE) BaTiO3 |
Film | \ | \ | Enhanced differentiation during cell growth | Neuronal cell | 1 W cm–2 ultrasonic wave | Promoted neuronal maturation and neurite outgrowth in SH‐SY5Y | [ 183 ] |
BaTiO3 | Nanoparticle | Diameter: 58 ± 15 nm | \ | Induced differentiation of targeted neural stem‐like cell | Neural stem‐like cell | 1 MHz, 1 W cm–2 ultrasonic wave | Achieved navigation to a specific neural stem‐like PC12 cell in a controllable way | [ 159 ] | |
KNNS | Ceramic | \ | Solid phase sintering | Stimulated retina | Retina | 30 Vpp input voltage | ≈72 µA current, ≈9.2 nA µm–2 current density | [ 161 ] | |
PVDF | Nanocomposite | \ | \ | Stimulated differentiation and proliferation of neuronal cells | Neuronal cell | 7 d of cocultivation | Showed higher PC12 cell activity | [ 184 ] | |
PVDF | \ | \ | Solvent casting | Stimulated neuronal cells | Neuronal cell | 4 months after being implanted | Exhibited significant electrophysiological, morphological and functional nerve restoration | [ 185 ] | |
ZnO | Nanoparticle | Average diameter: 30–80 nm | \ | Stimulated cell attachment and proliferation | Schwann cell | 18 weeks in vivo | Improved severe nerve defect recovery | [ 104 ] | |
Antifouling treatment | BaTiO3 | Nanoparticle | Average diameter: ≈130 nm | Hydrothermal method | Whitened teeth | Teeth | 10 h of vibration | Exhibited a whitening effect | [ 27c ] |
PVDF | Film | Thickness: 110 µm | \ | Inhibited bacterial growth and antifouling effects | \ | 4 Hz stimuli | Inhibited biofilm formation effectively | [ 166 ] |