TABLE 4.
Study and year | Mean/median Age/Range (yrs) | Patients (n) | Male/Female (n) | Wounds (n) | Wound aetiology (n) | Acute/Chronic | Wound base (n) | Wound location (n) | Average Surface area of BTM cm2/%TBSA | Follow up period (months) | Outcomes |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Wagstaff et al., April 2015, 16 | 62.2 (mean) | 10 | Not reported | 10 | Alt flap–3 | 10:0 | Not reported | Upper limb–4 | Not reported | 12 months | Integration (91.0%) |
Fibular osseous flap–3 radial/ulnar forearm flap–4 | Lower limb–6 | ||||||||||
(46–76) | |||||||||||
Integration time (29.5 days) | |||||||||||
SSG take (90.5%) | |||||||||||
Infection rate (40.0%) | |||||||||||
Wagstaff et al., June 2015, 27 | 58.5 (mean) | 10 | Not reported | 10 | Fibular osseous flap–2 | 10:0 | Not reported | Upper limb–7 | Not reported | 2.9–14.1 months | Integration (100%) |
Lower limb–2 | |||||||||||
Radial forearm flap–7 | |||||||||||
(48–68) | Integration time (35.4 days) | ||||||||||
SSG take (100%) | |||||||||||
Infection rate (4.5%) | |||||||||||
Greenwood et al., 2017 1 | 42.2 (mean) | 5 | 5 males | 5 | Burns–5 | 5:0 | Extensive wound with burn eschar excision | Axilla–1 | 23% | 12 months | Integration (89.8%) |
Upper limb–5 | |||||||||||
(18–70) | |||||||||||
Trunk–3 | Integration time (33.2 days) | ||||||||||
Lower limb–3 | |||||||||||
SSG take (98.4%) | |||||||||||
Infection rate (40.0%) | |||||||||||
Wagstaff et al., 2019, 4 | 51.6 (mean) | 7 | 4 males | 7 | Post‐debridement of necrotising fasciitis–7 | 7:0 | Gland–1 | Neck–2 | 8.57% | 1–20 months (range) | Integration (98.1%) |
3 females | Muscle–1 | Chest–2 | |||||||||
Blood vessels–2 | Lower limb–3 | Integration time (34.0 days) | |||||||||
Exposed bone denuded of periosteum–2 | |||||||||||
SSG take (100%) | |||||||||||
Exposed joints–1 | |||||||||||
Infection rate (6.2%) | |||||||||||
Solanki et al., 2020 11 | 50 (median) | 25 | 19 males | 25 | Acute full thickness burn–3 | 20:5 | Exposed bone–8 exposed tendon–11 wound temporalisation with SSG–3 Desirable/aesthetic reconstruction–5 | Head–2 | Not reported | 3 months (median) | Integration time (37.8 days) |
6 females | Neck–2 | ||||||||||
(15–86) | Burn scar/contracture release–5 | Upper limb–9 | |||||||||
Trunk–3 | |||||||||||
Lower limb–9 | 1–7 months (range) | Infection rate (20.0%) | |||||||||
Necrotising soft tissue infection–7 | |||||||||||
Tumour excision–3 | |||||||||||
Traumatic loss–7 | |||||||||||
Li et al., 2021, 5 |
73.7 (mean) (47–95) |
27 | 19 males | 35 | Pressure ulcer–2 | 16:11 | Muscle–10 | Head and neck–12 | Not reported | 3–18 months (range) | Integration (96.9%) |
8 females | |||||||||||
Failed SSG–5 | Bone–7 | Breast–1 | |||||||||
Wound breakdown–4 | Tendon–10 | Upper limb–7 | Integration time (35.4 days) | ||||||||
Fat–7 | Abdomen–1 | ||||||||||
Surgical wounds–12 | Paratenon–2 | Lower limb–14 | |||||||||
Trauma–4 | Perichondrium–3 | ||||||||||
Periosteum–2 | SSG take (87.9%) | ||||||||||
Infection rate (1.4%) | |||||||||||
Lo et al., 2021, 2 |
45.2 (mean) (18–70) |
26 |
22 males 4 females |
100 | Burn–26 | 26:0 | Not reported | Chest–23 | 2137.8 cm2 | 12 months | Integration (88.6%) |
Abdomen–13 | |||||||||||
Back–2 | Integration time (31.9 days) | ||||||||||
Upper limb–34 | |||||||||||
Lower limb–28 | |||||||||||
SSG take (81.9%) | |||||||||||
Infection rate (38.5%) | |||||||||||
Kuang et al., 2022, 19 |
56 (median) (31–86) |
18 |
16 males 2 females |
18 |
Debridement–9 Amputation–8 Ulcer–1 |
17:1 |
Granulation tissue–12 Bone–3 Fascia/peroneal retinaculum/plantar fascia–3 |
Foot–18 | Not reported | 3–18 months (range) | Intergration time (38.8 days) |
Infection rate (7.1%) | |||||||||||
Schlottmann et al., 2022, 7 |
50.8 (median) (15–82) |
20 |
12 males 8 females |
27 |
Pressure ulcer–2 Neurofibromatosis–1 Necrotising fasciitis–1 Burn–7 Chronic ulcer–2 Malignancy resection–2 Unstable scar–2 Full thickness soft tissue defect–3 |
14:6 | Not reported | Head–3 | Not reported | Not reported | |
Neck–2 | |||||||||||
Upper limb–6 | |||||||||||
Trunk–4 | |||||||||||
Lower limb–11 | |||||||||||
Genital–1 | |||||||||||
Wu et al., April 2022, 20 |
48.2 (mean) (18–93) |
51 | 33 males | 51 | Burn–7 | Not categorised | Not reported | Head and neck–5 | 110 cm2 | 6.4 months (median) | Infection rate (17.6%) |
18 females | Trauma–24 | ||||||||||
Surgical wound/pressure ulcer–10 | Upper limb–24 | ||||||||||
Trunk–1 | |||||||||||
Osteomyelitis–2 | Lower limb–21 | ||||||||||
Compartment syndrome–2 | |||||||||||
Skin Malignancy–2 | |||||||||||
Others–4 | |||||||||||
Wu et al., July 2022, 28 | 66 (mean) | 5 | 3 males | 5 | Burn–2 | Not categorised | Not reported | Head and neck–5 | 213 cm2 |
15.3 (median) Range: 3.8–26.8 |
Infection rate (20.0%) |
2 females | Trauma–1 | ||||||||||
Surgical wound or pressure ulcer–1 | |||||||||||
Skin Malignancy–1 | |||||||||||
Austin et al., 2023, 18 | 46.6 (mean) | 28 | 16 males | 79 | Burns–20 | 23:5 | Not reported | Not reported | 1227 cm2 | Not reported | Integration time (31.6 days) |
12 females | Complex wound–5 | ||||||||||
Trauma–3 | |||||||||||
Infection rate (3.8%) | |||||||||||
Cereceda‐monteoliva et al., 2023, 12 |
60 (mean) (5–91) |
38 | 26 males | 40 | Skin cancer–19 | 35:3 | Exposed tendon–14 | Scalp–6 | 1.29% | 3.4 months (mean) | Infection rate (13.2%) |
12 females | Burns–12 | Exposed bone–8 | Face–2 | ||||||||
Scar revision–3 | Exposed tendon and bone–10 exposed tendon and bone plus failed SSG–2 | Upper limb–8 | |||||||||
Infection–3 | Trunk–2 | ||||||||||
Lower limb–22 (including 1 perineal burn) | |||||||||||
Trauma–3 | |||||||||||
Failed skin graft–2 | |||||||||||
Pressure area–2 | |||||||||||
Delayed wound healing–1 | |||||||||||
Overlying umbilicus–1 | |||||||||||
Concannon et al., 2023, 10 |
55 (mean) (17–94) |
55 | 41 males | 70 |
Burns–15 Trauma–19 Infection–10 Ischaemic–7 Oncological defect reconstruction–4 |
55:0 |
Exposed bone devoid of periosteum–42 Exposed tendon–21 Bone and tendon–7 |
Scalp–8 Neck–2 Upper limb–11 Trunk–5 Lower limb–31 |
Not reported |
18 months (mean) 3–72 months (range) |
Integration time (46.2 days) |
14 females | |||||||||||
Infection rate (12.7%) | |||||||||||
Tapking et al., Feb 2024, 44 | 54.2 (mean) | 300 | 199 males | 300 |
Burns–179 Trauma–59 Chronic wound–39 Infection–14 Malignancy–6 Not mentioned–3 |
39:261 |
Subcutis–144 Tendon–42 Joint capsule–46 Bone–29 Not mentioned–49 |
Head and neck–8 Trunk–47 Upper limb–70 Lower limb–141 Not mentioned–34 |
4.1 | Not reported | Integration (82.7%) |
101 females | |||||||||||
Integration time (32 days) | |||||||||||
SSG take (86%) | |||||||||||
Struble et al., 2024, 25 |
16.9 (mean) (0.3–81.4) |
54 | 28 males | 86 |
Trauma–31 Infection–16 Malignancy–10 Burns–9 Flap donor site–8 Chronic wound–6 Vasopressor necrosis–4 Flap loss–4 Fasciotomy site–1 |
80:6 |
Muscle–41 Tendon–33 Bone–19 Joints–11 Nerve–7 Blood vessel–6 |
Upper limb–45 | 60 cm2 | Not reported | Integration (88.6%) |
23 females | |||||||||||
Lower limb–41 | |||||||||||
3 transgender (FtM) | Integration time (27.7 days) | ||||||||||
SSG take (92.1%) | |||||||||||
Infection rate (4.7%) | |||||||||||
Parker et al., 2023, 43 |
57 (mean) (19–89) |
23 | 14 male | 24 | Infection–8 | 21:3 | Muscle–8 | Lower limb–10 | <1% | Not reported | Integration (95.2%) |
9 female | Malignancy–6 | Bone–5 | Head and neck–6 | ||||||||
Burns–4 | Fascia–5 | Integration time (44.2 days) | |||||||||
Torso–3 | |||||||||||
Chronic wound–3 | Tendon–4 |
Groin/genitals–3 Upper limb–1 |
|||||||||
Free flap failure–2 | Testicle–3 | ||||||||||
Surgical wound dehiscence–1 | SSG take (86.1%) | ||||||||||
Fat and cartilage–1 | |||||||||||
Infection rate (8.3%) | |||||||||||
Meagher et al., 2024, 6 | (30–95) | 22 | 16 male | 22 | Peripheral vascular disease–5 | 18:4 | Not reported | Lower limb–21 | Not reported | Not reported | None |
6 female | |||||||||||
Chest–1= | |||||||||||
Necrotising fasciitis–4 | |||||||||||
Pressure ulcers–4 | |||||||||||
Haematoma–3 | |||||||||||
Crush–2 | |||||||||||
Malignancy–1 | |||||||||||
Vasculitis–1 | |||||||||||
Lo et al., 2023, 29 | 49.1 (mean) | 15 | 13 male | 16 | Burns–13 | 15:1 | Subcutaneous fat–25 | Upper limb–11 | 25.2% | 56 | None |
2 female | Necrotising fasciitis–2 | ||||||||||
Fascia–11 | Lower limb–17 | ||||||||||
Bone–2 | |||||||||||
Secondary burn reconstruction–1 | Mixed wound bed–1 | Trunk–4 | |||||||||
Head and neck–1 | |||||||||||
Multiple area–6 | |||||||||||
Kidd et al., 2023, 24 |
52 (mean) (14–93) |
37 | 24 male | 37 | Trauma–19 | 28:9 | Muscle–17 | Lower limb–21 | 1% (0.5%–15%) | Not reported | Integration time (53 days) |
13 female | Chrnoic wounds–9 | Tendon–12 | Upper limb–7 | ||||||||
Infection–6 | Bone–6 | Torso–6 | Infection rate (18.9%) | ||||||||
Malignancy–3 | Head and neck–3 | ||||||||||
Jou et al., 2024, 45 |
44.3 (mean) (13–97) |
51 | 39 male | 51 | Trauma–30 | 51:0 | Tendon–27 | Upper limb–51 | 162.5 cm2 | 2–40 | Integration time (51.7 days) |
12 female | Burns–12 | Bone–24 | |||||||||
Infection–8 | |||||||||||
Iatrogenic–1 | Infection rate (9.8%) | ||||||||||
Heard et al., 2023, 26 |
24.1 (mean) (10–41) |
10 | 7 male | 10 | Burns–10 | 10:0 | Not reported | Massive burns (mean 80.8% TBSA) | Not reported | Not reported | Integration time (83.2 days) |
3 female | |||||||||||
Infection rate (40.0%) | |||||||||||
Guerriero et al., 2023, 23 | 67.3 (mean) | 22 | 19 male | 23 | Diabetic foot wounds–22 | 22:0 | Not reported | Foot–22 | Not reported | 5 months | Infection rate (13.0%) |
3 female | |||||||||||
Fuest et al., 2023, 46 |
51 (mean) (12–77) |
27 | 16 male | 27 | Trauma–20 | 27:0 | Not reported | Hand–27 | Not reported | Not reported | Integration time (43.6 days) |
11 female | Infection–4 | ||||||||||
Malignancy–1 | |||||||||||
Dupuyten's–1 | SSG take (96%) | ||||||||||
Dermatomyositis–1 | |||||||||||
Devine et al., 2024, 22 | 70 (mean) | 12 | 8 male | 12 | Malignancy–12 | 12:0 | Not reported | Head and neck–8 | Not reported | Not reported | Integration time (49 days) |
4 female | |||||||||||
Lower limb–3 | SSG take (70.0%) | ||||||||||
Genirourinary–1 | Infection rate (25%) | ||||||||||
Chen et al., 2024, 21 | 51.8 (mean) | 37 | 22 male | 37 | Trauma–25 | 37:0 | Not reported | Lower limb–19 | 50.6 cm2 | 7.0 months | Integration time (36.9 days) |
15 female | Necrotising fasciitis–6 | Foot–10 | |||||||||
(18–86) | Hand–4 | ||||||||||
Burn–4 | |||||||||||
Other–2 | Upper limb–3 | Infection rate (2.7%) | |||||||||
Trunk–1 |
Abbreviation: BTM, biodegradable temporising matrix; SSG, split thickness skin graft: TBSA, total body surface area.