Skip to main content
. 2024 Oct 14;21(10):e70025. doi: 10.1111/iwj.70025

TABLE 4.

Summary of demographic characteristics as well as wound aetiology, wound acuity, structures in wound base, anatomical location, area of wound, follow up periods for all included studies and outcomes analysed.

Study and year Mean/median Age/Range (yrs) Patients (n) Male/Female (n) Wounds (n) Wound aetiology (n) Acute/Chronic Wound base (n) Wound location (n) Average Surface area of BTM cm2/%TBSA Follow up period (months) Outcomes
Wagstaff et al., April 2015, 16 62.2 (mean) 10 Not reported 10 Alt flap–3 10:0 Not reported Upper limb–4 Not reported 12 months Integration (91.0%)
Fibular osseous flap–3 radial/ulnar forearm flap–4 Lower limb–6
(46–76)
Integration time (29.5 days)
SSG take (90.5%)
Infection rate (40.0%)
Wagstaff et al., June 2015, 27 58.5 (mean) 10 Not reported 10 Fibular osseous flap–2 10:0 Not reported Upper limb–7 Not reported 2.9–14.1 months Integration (100%)
Lower limb–2
Radial forearm flap–7
(48–68) Integration time (35.4 days)
SSG take (100%)
Infection rate (4.5%)
Greenwood et al., 2017 1 42.2 (mean) 5 5 males 5 Burns–5 5:0 Extensive wound with burn eschar excision Axilla–1 23% 12 months Integration (89.8%)
Upper limb–5
(18–70)
Trunk–3 Integration time (33.2 days)
Lower limb–3
SSG take (98.4%)
Infection rate (40.0%)
Wagstaff et al., 2019, 4 51.6 (mean) 7 4 males 7 Post‐debridement of necrotising fasciitis–7 7:0 Gland–1 Neck–2 8.57% 1–20 months (range) Integration (98.1%)
3 females Muscle–1 Chest–2
Blood vessels–2 Lower limb–3 Integration time (34.0 days)
Exposed bone denuded of periosteum–2
SSG take (100%)
Exposed joints–1
Infection rate (6.2%)
Solanki et al., 2020 11 50 (median) 25 19 males 25 Acute full thickness burn–3 20:5 Exposed bone–8 exposed tendon–11 wound temporalisation with SSG–3 Desirable/aesthetic reconstruction–5 Head–2 Not reported 3 months (median) Integration time (37.8 days)
6 females Neck–2
(15–86) Burn scar/contracture release–5 Upper limb–9
Trunk–3
Lower limb–9 1–7 months (range) Infection rate (20.0%)
Necrotising soft tissue infection–7
Tumour excision–3
Traumatic loss–7
Li et al., 2021, 5

73.7 (mean)

(47–95)

27 19 males 35 Pressure ulcer–2 16:11 Muscle–10 Head and neck–12 Not reported 3–18 months (range) Integration (96.9%)
8 females
Failed SSG–5 Bone–7 Breast–1
Wound breakdown–4 Tendon–10 Upper limb–7 Integration time (35.4 days)
Fat–7 Abdomen–1
Surgical wounds–12 Paratenon–2 Lower limb–14
Trauma–4 Perichondrium–3
Periosteum–2 SSG take (87.9%)
Infection rate (1.4%)
Lo et al., 2021, 2

45.2 (mean)

(18–70)

26

22 males

4 females

100 Burn–26 26:0 Not reported Chest–23 2137.8 cm2 12 months Integration (88.6%)
Abdomen–13
Back–2 Integration time (31.9 days)
Upper limb–34
Lower limb–28
SSG take (81.9%)
Infection rate (38.5%)
Kuang et al., 2022, 19

56 (median)

(31–86)

18

16 males

2 females

18

Debridement–9

Amputation–8

Ulcer–1

17:1

Granulation tissue–12

Bone–3

Fascia/peroneal retinaculum/plantar fascia–3

Foot–18 Not reported 3–18 months (range) Intergration time (38.8 days)
Infection rate (7.1%)
Schlottmann et al., 2022, 7

50.8

(median)

(15–82)

20

12 males

8 females

27

Pressure ulcer–2

Neurofibromatosis–1

Necrotising fasciitis–1

Burn–7

Chronic ulcer–2

Malignancy resection–2

Unstable scar–2

Full thickness soft tissue defect–3

14:6 Not reported Head–3 Not reported Not reported
Neck–2
Upper limb–6
Trunk–4
Lower limb–11
Genital–1
Wu et al., April 2022, 20

48.2 (mean)

(18–93)

51 33 males 51 Burn–7 Not categorised Not reported Head and neck–5 110 cm2 6.4 months (median) Infection rate (17.6%)
18 females Trauma–24
Surgical wound/pressure ulcer–10 Upper limb–24
Trunk–1
Osteomyelitis–2 Lower limb–21
Compartment syndrome–2
Skin Malignancy–2
Others–4
Wu et al., July 2022, 28 66 (mean) 5 3 males 5 Burn–2 Not categorised Not reported Head and neck–5 213 cm2

15.3 (median)

Range: 3.8–26.8

Infection rate (20.0%)
2 females Trauma–1
Surgical wound or pressure ulcer–1
Skin Malignancy–1
Austin et al., 2023, 18 46.6 (mean) 28 16 males 79 Burns–20 23:5 Not reported Not reported 1227 cm2 Not reported Integration time (31.6 days)
12 females Complex wound–5
Trauma–3
Infection rate (3.8%)
Cereceda‐monteoliva et al., 2023, 12

60 (mean)

(5–91)

38 26 males 40 Skin cancer–19 35:3 Exposed tendon–14 Scalp–6 1.29% 3.4 months (mean) Infection rate (13.2%)
12 females Burns–12 Exposed bone–8 Face–2
Scar revision–3 Exposed tendon and bone–10 exposed tendon and bone plus failed SSG–2 Upper limb–8
Infection–3 Trunk–2
Lower limb–22 (including 1 perineal burn)
Trauma–3
Failed skin graft–2
Pressure area–2
Delayed wound healing–1
Overlying umbilicus–1
Concannon et al., 2023, 10

55 (mean)

(17–94)

55 41 males 70

Burns–15

Trauma–19

Infection–10

Ischaemic–7

Oncological defect reconstruction–4

55:0

Exposed bone devoid of periosteum–42

Exposed tendon–21

Bone and tendon–7

Scalp–8

Neck–2

Upper limb–11

Trunk–5

Lower limb–31

Not reported

18 months (mean)

3–72 months (range)

Integration time (46.2 days)
14 females
Infection rate (12.7%)
Tapking et al., Feb 2024, 44 54.2 (mean) 300 199 males 300

Burns–179

Trauma–59

Chronic wound–39

Infection–14

Malignancy–6

Not mentioned–3

39:261

Subcutis–144

Tendon–42

Joint capsule–46

Bone–29

Not mentioned–49

Head and neck–8

Trunk–47

Upper limb–70

Lower limb–141

Not mentioned–34

4.1 Not reported Integration (82.7%)
101 females
Integration time (32 days)
SSG take (86%)
Struble et al., 2024, 25

16.9 (mean)

(0.3–81.4)

54 28 males 86

Trauma–31

Infection–16

Malignancy–10

Burns–9

Flap donor site–8

Chronic wound–6

Vasopressor necrosis–4

Flap loss–4

Fasciotomy site–1

80:6

Muscle–41

Tendon–33

Bone–19

Joints–11

Nerve–7

Blood vessel–6

Upper limb–45 60 cm2 Not reported Integration (88.6%)
23 females
Lower limb–41
3 transgender (FtM) Integration time (27.7 days)
SSG take (92.1%)
Infection rate (4.7%)
Parker et al., 2023, 43

57 (mean)

(19–89)

23 14 male 24 Infection–8 21:3 Muscle–8 Lower limb–10 <1% Not reported Integration (95.2%)
9 female Malignancy–6 Bone–5 Head and neck–6
Burns–4 Fascia–5 Integration time (44.2 days)
Torso–3
Chronic wound–3 Tendon–4

Groin/genitals–3

Upper limb–1

Free flap failure–2 Testicle–3
Surgical wound dehiscence–1 SSG take (86.1%)
Fat and cartilage–1
Infection rate (8.3%)
Meagher et al., 2024, 6 (30–95) 22 16 male 22 Peripheral vascular disease–5 18:4 Not reported Lower limb–21 Not reported Not reported None
6 female
Chest–1=
Necrotising fasciitis–4
Pressure ulcers–4
Haematoma–3
Crush–2
Malignancy–1
Vasculitis–1
Lo et al., 2023, 29 49.1 (mean) 15 13 male 16 Burns–13 15:1 Subcutaneous fat–25 Upper limb–11 25.2% 56 None
2 female Necrotising fasciitis–2
Fascia–11 Lower limb–17
Bone–2
Secondary burn reconstruction–1 Mixed wound bed–1 Trunk–4
Head and neck–1
Multiple area–6
Kidd et al., 2023, 24

52 (mean)

(14–93)

37 24 male 37 Trauma–19 28:9 Muscle–17 Lower limb–21 1% (0.5%–15%) Not reported Integration time (53 days)
13 female Chrnoic wounds–9 Tendon–12 Upper limb–7
Infection–6 Bone–6 Torso–6 Infection rate (18.9%)
Malignancy–3 Head and neck–3
Jou et al., 2024, 45

44.3 (mean)

(13–97)

51 39 male 51 Trauma–30 51:0 Tendon–27 Upper limb–51 162.5 cm2 2–40 Integration time (51.7 days)
12 female Burns–12 Bone–24
Infection–8
Iatrogenic–1 Infection rate (9.8%)
Heard et al., 2023, 26

24.1 (mean)

(10–41)

10 7 male 10 Burns–10 10:0 Not reported Massive burns (mean 80.8% TBSA) Not reported Not reported Integration time (83.2 days)
3 female
Infection rate (40.0%)
Guerriero et al., 2023, 23 67.3 (mean) 22 19 male 23 Diabetic foot wounds–22 22:0 Not reported Foot–22 Not reported 5 months Infection rate (13.0%)
3 female
Fuest et al., 2023, 46

51 (mean)

(12–77)

27 16 male 27 Trauma–20 27:0 Not reported Hand–27 Not reported Not reported Integration time (43.6 days)
11 female Infection–4
Malignancy–1
Dupuyten's–1 SSG take (96%)
Dermatomyositis–1
Devine et al., 2024, 22 70 (mean) 12 8 male 12 Malignancy–12 12:0 Not reported Head and neck–8 Not reported Not reported Integration time (49 days)
4 female
Lower limb–3 SSG take (70.0%)
Genirourinary–1 Infection rate (25%)
Chen et al., 2024, 21 51.8 (mean) 37 22 male 37 Trauma–25 37:0 Not reported Lower limb–19 50.6 cm2 7.0 months Integration time (36.9 days)
15 female Necrotising fasciitis–6 Foot–10
(18–86) Hand–4
Burn–4
Other–2 Upper limb–3 Infection rate (2.7%)
Trunk–1

Abbreviation: BTM, biodegradable temporising matrix; SSG, split thickness skin graft: TBSA, total body surface area.