Skip to main content
. 2024 Sep 14;16(9):e69421. doi: 10.7759/cureus.69421

Table 3. VB-MAPP change in difference scores between the control (ABA) and experimental (ABA + HBOT) groups.

Cohen's d: Small effect size = 0.20; Medium effect size = 0.50; Large effect size = 0.80 or higher

ABA: Applied Behavior Analysis; HBOT: Hyperbaric Oxygen Therapy; VB-MAPP: Verbal Behavior Milestones Assessment and Placement Program

Scale Time HBOT mean (SD), n = 24 Non-HBOT mean (SD), n = 13 Mean difference 95% CI SE Effect size (Cohen's d) 95% CI p-value
Mand Pretest 2.41 (3.34) 2.96 (2.85)  
Posttest 6.43 (4.00) 4.33 (2.82)
Difference 4.02 (2.37) 1.38 (0.83) 2.65 1.53, 3.77 0.55 -1.33 -2.09, -0.553 <0.0001
Tact Pretest 2.24 (3.02) 3.00 (2.88)  
Posttest 6.50 (4.11) 4.17 (3.03)
Difference 4.26 (2.96) 1.17 (1.05) 3.09 1.69, 4.50 0.69 -1.24 -1.99, -0.474 <0.0001
Listener responding (LR) Pretest 3.20 (3.10) 3.92 (3.64)  
Posttest 7.50 (4.03) 5.71 (3.31)
Difference 4.30 (2.42) 1.79 (1.41) 2.51 0.96, 4.06 0.76 -1.18 -1.92, -0.416 0.0023
Visual perceptual skills and matching-to-sample (VP-MTS) Pretest 4.57 (2.77) 5.38 (3.49)  
Posttest 7.98 (3.65) 6.79 (3.12)
Difference 3.41 (1.86) 1.42 (1.13) 2 0.80, 3.19 0.59 -1.21 -1.96, -0.444 0.0018
Independent play Pretest 4.22 (3.92) 5.63 (2.82)  
Posttest 8.26 (4.10) 6.96 (2.56)
Difference 4.04 (2.75) 1.33 (1.37) 2.71 1.29, 4.13 0.70 -1.14 -1.88, -0.382 0.0005
Social play Pretest 2.22 (2.27) 2.88 (2.14)  
Posttest 6.22 (2.68) 4.50 (2.29)
Difference 4.00 (1.97) 1.63 (1.19) 2.38 1.11, 3.64 0.62 -1.36 -2.12, -0.581 0.0006
Motor imitation Pretest 1.93 (2.44) 2.29 (2.21)  
Posttest 6.24 (2.93) 4.00 (2.44)
Difference 4.30 (2.44) 1.71 (1.27) 2.6 1.32, 3.87 0.63 -1.22 -1.97, -0.458 0.0002
Echoic Pretest 1.65 (2.34) 4.08 (4.25)  
Posttest 5.98 (3.40) 4.29 (4.16)
Difference 4.33 (3.04) 0.21 (0.33) 4.12 2.79, 5.45 0.64 -1.65 -2.46, -0.840 <0.0001
Spontaneous vocalization Pretest 1.93 (1.73) 2.42 (1.74)  
Posttest 4.96 (2.50) 3.13 (1.57)
Difference 3.02 (2.28) 0.71 (0.78) 2.31 1.24, 3.39 0.53 -1.21 -1.96, 0.445 0.0001
Listener responding by function, feature, and class (LRFFC) Pretest 0.57 (1.23) 0.67 (2.02)  
Posttest 3.28 (2.71) 1.13 (2.07)
Difference 2.72 (2.13) 0.46 (0.94) 2.26 1.20, 3.32 0.52 -1.24 -1.99, 0.475 0.0001
Intraverbal Pretest 0.35 (0.83) 0.58 (1.29)  
Posttest 2.72 (2.40) 1.46 (1.66)
Difference 2.37 (1.86) 0.88 (0.93) 1.49 0.53, 2.46 0.47 -0.928 -1.63, 0.189 0.0033
Group behavior Pretest 0.89 (1.87) 2.13 (2.25)  
Posttest 4.67 (2.29) 3.25 (1.75)
Difference 3.78 (1.92) 1.13 (1.32) 2.66 1.39, 3.92 0.62 -1.52 -2.30, 0.726 0.0002
Linguistic structure Pretest 0.74 (1.57) 1.00 (1.71)  
Posttest 2.59 (2.64) 1.63 (2.43)
Difference 1.85 (1.91) 0.63 (0.91) 1.22 0.25, 2.19 0.48 -0.743 -1.46, 0.018 0.0151
Total score Pretest 26.91 (27.06) 36.92 (27.48)  
Posttest 73.33 (35.19) 51.33 (26.04)
Difference 46.41 (20.14) 14.42 (6.99) 32 22.44, 41.51 4.66 -1.23 -1.91, 0.548 <0.0001