Efstathiou et al., 2012 [33] |
348 patients with MIBC |
Complete TURBT |
CR: 79% for complete resection vs. 57% for incomplete resection |
Complete TURBT associated with better CR and survival rates |
James et al., 2012 [21] |
360 patients with MIBC |
Majority did not undergo maximal debulking |
Superior 5-year OS (48% vs. 35%) with chemoradiation vs. radiation alone |
Good outcomes despite lack of maximal TURBT in most patients |
Mak et al., 2014 [32] |
468 patients with MIBC (T2-T4) |
Complete vs. Incomplete TURBT |
the presence of hydronephrosis, higher clinical stage (T3/T4), and visibly incomplete TURBT are predictors of worse disease-specific survival on univariate analysis. |
Only visibly complete TURBT remained a significant predictor of disease-specific survival on multivariable analysis. It is unclear whether a visually complete TURBT before TMT is truly a prognostic factor or a surrogate marker of a lower local tumor stage. |
Suer et al., 2016 [36] |
90 patients with MIBC |
Second TURBT |
Higher 5-year DSS (68% vs. 41%) and OS (63.7% vs. 40.1%) |
Second TURBT significantly improves 5-year DSS and should be performed in patients with MIBC who are going to be treated with bladder-preserving protocols. |
Zamboni et al., 2019 [42] |
433 patients with MIBC undergoing RC |
Complete TURBT |
53% had MIBC at RC; no clear correlation with oncologic outcomes |
Complete TURBT not clearly associated with improved outcomes. |
Pak et al., 2021 [35] |
93 patients with MIBC before neoadjuvant chemotherapy (NAC) |
Complete vs. Incomplete TURBT |
Superior survival for complete TURBT prior to NAC |
Complete TURBT before NAC linked to better survival outcomes |