Skip to main content
. 2024 Oct 8;31(5):241–255. doi: 10.21315/mjms2024.31.5.17

Supplementary Table 1.

Summary of all three domains after Fuzzy Delphi analysis findings for the new norm elements in ED in Malaysia during the COVID-19 pandemic

No. Items/Elements Threshold value, D < 0.2 Percentage of expert consensus, % Average of fuzzy numbers (A value) Ranking Verdict
Domain: Governance
1 NNG-1 0.094 93.3% 0.909 6 Retained
2 NNG-2 0.111 86.7% 0.911 5 Retained
3 NNG-3a 0.138 93.3% 0.898 9 Retained
4 NNG-3b 0.425 33.33% 0.613 15 Discarded
5 NNG-3c 0.383 40.00% 0.638 14 Discarded
6 NNG-4 0.094 93.33% 0.909 6 Retained
7 NNG-5 0.377 40.00% 0.371 16 Discarded
8 NNG-6 0.068 100.00% 0.933 3 Retained
9 NNG-7a 0.252 86.67% 0.818 11 Retained
10 NNG-7b 0.060 100.00% 0.940 1 Retained
11 NNG-8 0.094 93.33% 0.909 6 Retained
12 NNG-9 0.402 46.67% 0.642 13 Discarded
13 NNG-10 0.290 60.00% 0.742 12 Discarded
14 NNG-11 0.094 100.00% 0.878 10 Retained
15 NNG-12 0.068 100.00% 0.933 3 Retained
16 NNG-13 0.060 100.00% 0.940 1 Retained
DOMAIN: INFRASTRUCTURE
1 NNI-14a 0.321 53.3% 0.738 10 Discarded
2 NNI-14b 0.410 40.0% 0.716 11 Discarded
3 NNI-15 0.116 93.3% 0.909 4 Retained
4 NNI-16a 0.155 93.33% 0.873 6 Retained
5 NNI-16b 0.186 93.33% 0.829 9 Retained
6 NNI-17 0.244 86.67% 0.842 8 Retained
7 NNI-18 0.089 93.33% 0.922 1 Retained
8 NNI-19 0.183 93.33% 0.860 7 Retained
9 NNI-20 0.076 100.00% 0.920 2 Retained
10 NNI-21 0.076 100.00% 0.913 3 Retained
11 NNI-22 0.131 93.33% 0.878 5 Retained
DOMAIN: HUMAN RESOURCE
1 NNHR-23 0.409 20.0% 0.647 8 Discarded
2 NNHR-24 0.291 66.7% 0.704 6 Discarded
3 NNHR-25 0.087 100.0% 0.896 1 Retained
4 NNHR-26 0.373 40.00% 0.662 7 Discarded
5 NNHR-27 0.197 93.33% 0.842 4 Retained
6 NNHR-28 0.145 93.33% 0.829 5 Retained
7 NNHR-29 0.173 93.33% 0.878 2 Retained
8 NNHR-30 0.119 93.33% 0.864 3 Retained

Notes: Threshold value (d) < 0.2 (three decimal points is accepted); Percentage expert consensus agreement > 75%; Average fuzzy value (A value ) > 0.5; All three must be fulfilled for the elements to be retained