Table 1. Characteristics of the studies included in qualitative analysis.
Reference | Region | Study design | Patient no /lesion no | Confounder | Lesion type and location | Diagnosis of lesion | Gender | Age, (years) | Intervention | Comparison | Follow-up period |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Dillenburg et al (2014) 21 | Brazil | RCT | 42 patients (21 in each group) | None | Symptomatic atrophic/erosive OLP, tongue, buccal and labial mucosa, floor of mouth, gingiva, palate | Histopathology | 7 males, 35 females | Clobetasol: 61.33 ± 11.85, PBMT: 55.14 ± 15.96 | PBMT was administered using a continuous wave, InGaAlP diode laser diode laser with a wavelength of 660 nm, power output of 40 mW, output density of 1,000 mW∕cm 2 , energy density of 6 J∕cm2, 6-s exposure time per point, and 0.24 J of total. PBMT was administered 3x/week for 4 weeks, totaling 12 sessions. | Clobetasol propionate gel 0.05%, 3x/day applications for 30 days, candidiasis prevention was done with nystatin application | Follow-up weekly until a month and 4 weeks and 8 weeks after completion of treatment |
Mirza et al (2018) 22 | Saudi Arabia | RCT | 45 patients (divided into 3 equal groups) | None | Erosive-atrophic OLP; tongue, buccal mucosa | Histopathology | 8 males, 37 females | Group 1 (52.6 ± 11.4), Group 2 (50.8 ± 14.7), Group 3 (49.2 ± 10.6) | • Group-2 (low level laser therapy): diode laser, 1.5 J/cm2 per session; 2 times/week for max 10 sessions | • Group-1 (toluidine blue-PDT): topical 1mg/ml toluidine blue followed by GaAlAs laser (630 nm, 1.5 J/cm2 per session); 2 sessions, 2x/week for 1 month • Group-3 (control group): Topical dexamethasone |
Follow-up weekly until a month and 1 year after completion of treatment |
El-Shenawy and Eldin (2015) 23 | Egypt | NRCT | 24 patients (12 in each group) | 2 patients are hypertensive, 1 patient is diabetic, and 4 patients are diabetic and hypertensive | Erosive-atrophic OLP, site not mentioned | Histopathology | 5 males, 19 females | PBMT: 53.6 ± 13.2, CORT: 52.2 ± 6.4 | 12 patients were subjected to laser sessions with 970 nm diode laser, continuous non-contact mode with (320 µm) diameter fiber optic, 2x/week for max 10 sessions | 12 patients treated with topical corticosteroids (0.1% triamcinolone acetonide orabase) | Follow-up weekly up to 4 weeks after completion of treatment |
Kazancioglu and Erisen (2015) 24 | Turkey | RCT | 120 patients (divided into 4 equal groups) | None | Atrophic-erosive OLP, tongue or buccal mucosa | Clinically and histopathology | 56 males, 64 females | 42.6 ± 8.3 | Group-1 (PBMT): GaAlAs laser (808 nm, 0.1 W, continuous wave) was used as a light source. A light exposure dose of 120 J/cm2 was used for 2.5 minutes, 2x/week for max 10 sessions | • Group-2 (ozone therapy): performed by using an ozone generator with a tissue probe, applied intraorally for 10s, 2x/week for max 10 sessions. • Group-3 (positive control): dexamethasone mouthwash for 5 minutes, followed 30 minutes later by 30 drops of nystatin solution, 4x/day for 1 month • Group-4 (negative control): A special solution filled with base ointment without the corticosteroid component was prepared, gargled solution for 5 minutes, 4x/day for 1 month |
Follow-up at 1, 3, and 6 months after the treatment |
Jajarm et al (2011) 25 | Iran | RCT | 24 patients for analysis, 30 recruited, randomly allocated | Atrophic-erosive biopsy-proven OLP in the tongue or buccal mucosa | Histopathology | Not mentioned | Not younger than 20 | Group 1- A diode laser was used as a light source (Mustang2000 þ, Russia, KLO3 probe, 630 nm, 10 mW, continuous wave, spot size: 11 cm). Irradiation was done 2x/week for a maximum of 10 sessions | Group 2- dexamethasone (0.5 mg in 5 ml water) mouth wash for 5 minutes, followed 30 minutes later by a mouth rinse with 30 drops of Nystatin (100,000 units) for 5 minutes. This treatment was repeated 4x/day for 1 month | Follow-up weekly up to 1 month after completion of treatment | |
Jain et al (2021) 26 | India | RCT | 30 patients, 15 in each group | None | Symptomatic OLP, site not mentioned | Clinically and histopathology | 10 males, 20 females | 18-30 | Group-1 (Steroid + PBMT): topical 0.1% triamcinolone acetonide oral base, 5 x/day for 28 days or till the lesions heal + PBMT delivered by the photon (3W) zolar diode laser with wavelength: 810 nm, mode: continuous defocused non-contact mode, power output: 0.8–0.9 W, time duration: 10 minutes laser equipment, 2x/week for 9 sessions | Group-2 (Steroid): topical 0.1% triamcinolone acetonide oral base, 5x/day for 28 days or till the lesions heal | Follow-up once every 15 days for 2 months after completion of treatment |
Bhatt et al (2022) 27 | India | RCT | 60 patients (divided equally in to 2 groups) | None | Oral lichen planus | Clinically and histopathology | 38 females, 22 males | Mean age of 40.73 | GaAlAs diode laser (980 nm wavelength twice weekly for 2 months. 0.6 W/cm2, 12 J/cm2, twice weekly for 2 months | Aloe vera extract 500 mg capsule was mixed with carboxymethylcellulose powder, applied topically for 30 minutes, for 2 months | Follow-up weekly for 9 months after completion of treatment |
Ferri et al (2021) 28 | Brazil | RCT | 34 patients, 17 in each group | None | Reticular-atrophic-erosive OLP, buccal mucosa, gingiva, tongue, palate, lips, alveolar ridge, floor of mouth | Histopathology | 32 females, 2 males | mean age of 62.2 | GaAIAs diode laser, with 660nm wavelength, irradiance: 35.4mW/cm2, radiant exposure: 177J/cm2, 5 sec exposure time per point and 0.5J of total energy per point, 2x/week for 4 weeks, for 8 sessions | Clobetasol propionate gel 0.05%, covering the OLP lesions completely, applied 3 x/day for 30 consecutive days | Follow-up at 60 days, 90 days, and 120 days after the treatment |
Abbreviations: GaAIAs, gallium-aluminum-Arsenide laser; InGaAlP, aluminum-gallium- indium-phosphide laser; NRCT, nonrandomized controlled trial; OLP, oral lichen planus; PDT, Photodynamic therapy; PBMT, photobiomodulation therapy; RCT, randomized controlled trial.