Skip to main content
. 2024 Oct 21;24:229. doi: 10.1186/s12894-024-01620-7

Table 3.

Comparison between complications of partial and radical nephrectomy between PMSI-MCO in 2018 and other studies

Complications French PMSI data Other studies data
Veinous thrombosis
Laparoscopic PN 1.5% 1.7% [20]
Open PN 2% 1.7-2% [6, 20]
RN* 2.2–2.9% 1.1% [20]
Bleeding
Laparoscopic PN 9.3% 5.8-9% [5, 6, 12, 15, 20]
Open PN 15.3% 2-12.7% [46, 12, 15, 20]
Laparoscopic RN 8.8 1.14–11.9% [6, 1214]
Open RN 10.6% 2.09-19% [6, 1214]
False aneurysm
Laparoscopic 1.1% 0.42–3.6% [4, 24, 26, 30]
Open 1.6% 0.06–5.5% [4, 24, 26, 30]
Urinary fistula
Laparoscopic 1.1% 0.37-4% [5, 15, 20, 26]
Open 2.1% 0.87–4.3% [5, 15, 20, 24]
Urinary infections*
PN 6.4–8.9% 0.51–7.9% [6, 19, 20, 24]
RN 6.9–10.1% 0.57–11.8% [6, 15, 19, 20]
Wound complications
Laparoscopic PN 1.2% 0.53–0.8% [15, 20, 26]
Open PN 3% 1-3.21% [6, 15, 20, 24, 26]
Laparoscopic RN 2.6% 0% [6]
Open RN 3.4% 1.33% [6]
Occlusions
Laparoscopic PN 0.8% 0-0.8% [6, 20, 24]
Open PN 1.5% 0.8–2.1% [6, 20, 24]
Laparoscopic RN 1.9% 0% [6]
Open RN 3.1% 0.57% [6]
Peritonitis*
PN 0% 0.5% [17]
RN 0-0.4% 1.3% [17]
Pulmonary infection*
PN 1.2–2.3% 0.79–4.3% [17, 24, 26]
RN 1.6–2.6% 0.76–2.6% [17, 20]

PN: Partial nephrectomy; RN: Radical nephrectomy; * laparoscopy and open approaches not separated