Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2024 Oct 23.
Published in final edited form as: Supercond Sci Technol. 2017;30(3):10.1088/1361-6668/30/3/033005. doi: 10.1088/1361-6668/30/3/033005

Table 2.

Summary of results for extrapolations from the minimum dataset for the moderate-Jc WST-ITER conductor, showing reductions in RMSE and RMSFD values for the ESE equation-set (2) similar to those in table 1 (red-italic values). These results are for voltage tap 1 on the WST-ITER conductor, located at the center of the magnet. Essentially the same results were obtained for taps 2 and 3 located just above and below the magnet center (not shown), which contribute statistical significance to the results. Differences in parameters between corresponding cases are highlighted in red (‘var’ denotes ‘variable’).

Case # WST Dataset (moderate-Jc ITER conductor): Extrapolation test cases RMSFD (%) RMSE (%)
Test case with all free parameters
1 All parameters simultaneously fitted 116.0 2.194

Polynomial bc2(ε), Taylor (2005)
2 Durham: polynomial bc2(ε),μ=2,η=var,w=2.2,s=1,v=1.5,p=0.5665,q=1.8111 13.6 0.340
3 ESE: polynomial bc2(ε),μ=2,η=var,w=3.0,s=var,v=1.5,p=0.5665,q=1.8111 5.0 0.168

Deviatoric bc2(ε), ten Haken (1994), Godeke et al (2006), Arbelaez et al (2009), Mentink (2008,2014)
4 G/ITER: deviatoric bc2(ε),μ=1,η=2,w=3.0,s=1,v=1.52,p=0.5665,q=1.8111 8.8 0.268
5 ESE: deviatoric bc2(ε),μ=1,η=var,w=3.0,s=var,v=1.5,p=0.5665,q=1.8111 5.5 0.144

6 MAG: deviatoric bc2(ε),ημ=1,μ=var,w=3.0,s=1,v=1.52,p=0.5665,q=1.8111 8.8 0.268
7 ESE: deviatoric bc2(ε),ημ=1,μ=var,w=3.0,s=var,v=1.5,p=0.5665,q=1.8111 5.5 0.145

Extended power law bc2(ε), NIST (Ekin 2006)
8 ESE: extended power law bc2(ε),μ=0,η=var,w=3.0,s=var,v=1.5,p=0.5665,q=1.8111 6.3 0.150
9 ESE: extended power law bc2(ε)μ=1,η=var,w=3.0,s=var,v=1.5,p=0.5665,q=1.8111 5.4 0.139
10 ESE: extended power law bc2(ε),μ=2,η=var,w=3.0,s=var,v=1.5,p=0.5665,q=1.8111 5.4 0.172

Invariant strain function bc2(ε), Markiewicz (2006)
11 ESE: invariant strain bc2(ε),μ=1,η=var,w=3.0,s=var,v=1.5,p=0.5,q=2.0613 5.3 0.135

Exponential bc2(ε), CERN (Bordini et al 2013)
12 ESE: exponential bc2(ε),μ=0,η=var,w=3.0,s=var,v=1.5,p=0.5665,q=1.8111 6.7 0.148
13 ESE: exponential bc2(ε),μ=1,η=var,w=3.0,s=var,v=1.5,p=0.5665,q=1.8111 5.7 0.134
14 ESE: exponential bc2(ε),μ=1,η=var,w=3.0,s=var,v=1.5,p=0.5665,q=1.8111, fit onlyε00.57% 6.4 0.181
15 ESE: exponential bc2(ε),μ=2,η=var,w=3.0,s=var,v=1.5,p=0.5665,q=1.8111 5.4 0.163