Table 1.
Comparison of different analytical approaches for study of cfDNA
Coverage | Output | Turnaround time from taking sample | Suggested minimum cfNA input | Relative complexity of analysis and clinical interpretation | Relative cost £-££££ | Fragment information preserved? | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Genomic analyses | |||||||
ddPCR | 1 mutation hotspot/assay | VAF (quantitative) | 2–5 days | 0.1 ng/well | Low | £ | No |
Targeted NGS | Up to 1000 genes | Base pair sequence | 1–2 weeks | 10 ng | Medium | ££ | At selected regions only for hybrid capture-based methods |
WES | All protein coding regions (∼1.5% genome) | Base pair sequence, copy-number changes | 2 weeks | 10 ng | Medium-High | £££ | At exome only |
WGS | Whole genome | Base pair sequence, copy-number changes | 2–3 weeks | 10 ng | High | ££££ | Yes |
Methylation analyses | |||||||
Bisulfite conversion based sequencing | Up to whole methylome but loss of 84–96% DNA | Methylation status at base pair level. | 2 weeks | 10 ng, ideally more for WGBS | High | ££-£££a | At regions covered |
Methylation capture-based enrichment | Genome-wide methylation | Methylation status at fragment level (5-mC only) | 2–3 weeks | 1 ng | High | £££ | Only for enriched methylated regions |
Enzyme-based methylation (e.g., EM-seq, TAPs) | Up to whole methylome | Methylation status at base pair level. | 2–3 weeks | 10 ng | High | £££-££££a | Yes |
Combined genomic and methylation analyses | |||||||
5/6 letter sequencing (Duet) | Up to whole methylome/whole genome | 5-mC/5-hMC status at base pair level. Preserves base pair sequence. | 2–3 weeks | 5 ng | High | £££- ££££a | Partially, dependent on read length |
Native DNA sequencing e.g., nanopore | Up to whole methylome/whole genome | 5-mC/5-hMC status at base pair level. Preserves base pair sequence. Sequences longer fragments | 24–48 h | 5 ng | High | £££-££££a | Yes |
Transcriptomic analyses | |||||||
ddPCR | 1 gene/assay | VAF (quantitative) | 2–5 days | 0.1 ng/well | Low | £ | No |
Targeted panel | Up to 1000 genes | Base pair sequence, fusions | 1–2 weeks | 10 ng | Medium | ££ | n/a |
RNA-seq (whole exome/whole transcriptome) | All protein coding (exome)/transcribed regions | Base pair sequence, copy-number changes | 2 weeks | 10 ng | Medium-High | £££ | n/a |
VAF, variant allele frequency; ddPCR, digital droplet polymerase chain reaction; NGS, next-generation sequencing; WGS, whole-genome sequencing; WES, whole-exome sequencing.
Cost varies dependent on sequencing coverage and depth.