Skip to main content
. 2024 Oct 30;14:26068. doi: 10.1038/s41598-024-77196-x

Table 7.

Comparative analysis of state-of-the-art algorithms in terms of different performance metrics with our proposed approach.

Previous Work DL Model used for FL Task Dataset Performance Measures
Covid-19, Pneumonia, Lung opacity and Normal X-Ray Image classification
[82] Lightweight Communication efficient CNN
CXR Dataset Accuracy= 92.96%
Classify Pneumonia and Normal using CXR images AUC = 0.9185 and Accuracy = 0.8029
[83] CNN CXR Dataset
Classification of Covid-19, Pneumonia, Lung opacity and Normal X-Ray Images
[84] CNN and Image Augmentation
CXR Dataset Accuracy = 89.43%
Classify MRI images into Yes -Tumors and Non-Tumor Precision 0.91, recall 0.96 and F1 Score 0.93 for No Tumor, While Precision 0.91, recall 0.82 and F1 Score 0.86 for Yes Tumor
[85] Vgg16, Inception V2, DenseNet 121 MRI Dataset
[55] FedFocus: Integrated CNN and FL Covid-19 detection using CXR images CXR Dataset Accuracy = 92%
Accuracy = 97%, Sensitivity 98.11% and Specificity 95.89% for FL-ResNet50 while Accuracy = 94.40%, Sensitivity 96.15% and Specificity 92.66 for FL-VGG-16
[86] VGG-16, ResNet50 Screening Covid-19 using CXR CXR Dataset
[87] MobileNet v2, ResNeXt and ResNet18 Detection of Covid-19 using Pneumonia CXR images ResNet18 performed best with Sensitivity = 91.26%
CXR Dataset
Classifying into COVID-19, TB, PNA, and healthy individuals using CXR images as well as Glioma, Meningioma, Pituitary and no tumor using MRI images Accuracy = 99.24%, Error Rate = 0.0076, Cohen’s Kapp = 0.9967, and Average F1 Score = 0.995 for CXR Dataset. For MRI dataset, Accuracy = 99%, Error Rate = 0.01, Cohen’s Kapp = 0.9698 and Average F1 Score = 0.995
Proposed Work FDEIoL CXR and MRI Datasets