Skip to main content
. 2024 Oct 31;19(10):e0309912. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0309912

Table 5. Association of carotid wall volume (mm3) with pollutants exposure stratified by workplace location.

Overall (n = 6223) Working away (n = 2188) Work in community (n = 4035)
Effect (95% CI) p- Effect (95% CI) p- Effect (95% CI) p-
PM 2.5
Model 1 -10.1 (-24.7,4.49) 0.1747 -1.27 (-24.7,22.21) 0.9157 -13.2 (-31.1,4.67) 0.1476
Model 2 -14.9 (-28.4,-1.42) 0.0303 -5.83 (-27.8,16.16) 0.6034 -16.3 (-32.9,0.25) 0.0536
Model 3 -15.0 (-28.5,-1.55) 0.0288 -5.50 (-27.5,16.44) 0.6229 -16.8 (-33.4,-0.20) 0.0473
Model 4 -8.40 (-23.3,6.48) 0.2685 0.87 (-22.8,24.55) 0.9429 -9.81 (-28.3,8.64) 0.2974
Model 5:+NO2 2.26 (-13.2,17.70) 0.7747 3.77 (-20.8,28.29) 0.7630 5.21 (-14.0,24.40) 0.5944
Model 5:+O3 0.60 (-14.7,15.91) 0.9391 5.53 (-18.2,29.26) 0.6477 0.67 (-18.1,19.40) 0.9441
NO 2
Model 1 -10.1 (-14.3,-5.95) <.0001 -3.62 (-10.6,3.31) 0.3059 -13.1 (-18.2,-7.93) <.0001
Model 2 -11.2 (-15.0,-7.32) <.0001 -4.35 (-10.8,2.06) 0.1833 -14.4 (-19.1,-9.64) <.0001
Model 3 -11.0 (-14.9,-7.10) <.0001 -3.62 (-10.1,2.82) 0.2702 -14.5 (-19.3,-9.69) <.0001
Model 4 -11.8 (-16.2,-7.31) <.0001 -3.40 (-10.9,4.15) 0.3771 -15.5 (-21.0,-10.1) <.0001
Model 5:+O3 -9.66 (-14.8,-4.55) 0.0002 -1.64 (-9.81,6.52) 0.6927 -12.9 (-19.2,-6.53) <.0001
Model 5:+PM2.5 -11.9 (-16.5,-7.32) <.0001 -3.70 (-11.5,4.10) 0.3524 -16.0 (-21.6,-10.3) <.0001
O 3
Model 1 8.25 (3.84,12.65) 0.0002 5.98 (-1.20,13.17) 0.1023 9.52 (4.29,14.75) 0.0004
Model 2 10.45 (6.34,14.55) <.0001 6.65 (-0.07,13.37) 0.0524 12.58 (7.69,17.46) <.0001
Model 3 10.36 (6.23,14.48) <.0001 6.27 (-0.45,12.98) 0.0675 12.64 (7.72,17.56) <.0001
Model 4 9.34 (4.75,13.92) <.0001 4.93 (-2.42,12.27) 0.1884 11.92 (6.42,17.43) <.0001
Model 5:+NO2 4.27 (-1.06,9.60) 0.1167 4.14 (-3.93,12.20) 0.3146 5.16 (-1.33,11.65) 0.1191
Model 5:+PM2.5 9.39 (4.62,14.15) 0.0001 5.34 (-2.15,12.83) 0.1622 11.97 (6.31,17.63) <.0001

Presented data are adjusted estimates (95% CI) per 5 μg/m3 increase for PM2.5, 5 ppb increase for NO2, and 3 ppb increase for O3, from a linear mixed model with centre modelled as a random intercept. Model 1, unadjusted. Model 2, adjusted for age, sex, and ethnicity. Model 3 further adjusted for the INTERHEART risk score and education. Primary model 4 further adjusted for walkability categories, material factor score and social factor score. Model 5 further adjusted for co-pollutants.