Skip to main content
. 2024 Oct 31;19(10):e0309912. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0309912

Table 6. Association of carotid wall volume (mm3) with O3 within co-pollutant exposure tertiles.

Overall
N = 6223
Low PM 2.5
(1.78–5.64 μg/m 3 ) N = 1903
Mid PM 2.5
5.65–8.18 μg/m 3 N = 1898
High PM 2.5
8.18–11.2 μg/m 3
N = 2422
Effect
(95% CI)
p- Effect
(95% CI)
p- Effect
(95% CI)
p- Effect
(95% CI)
p-
Model 1 8.25 (3.84,12.65) 0.0002 7.16 (-1.00,15.32) 0.0855 9.56 (2.26,16.85) 0.0103 8.31 (0.24,16.39) 0.0436
Model 2 10.45 (6.34,14.55) <.0001 9.73 (2.20,17.26) 0.0113 7.52 (-0.35,15.40) 0.0612 12.99 (5.55,20.44) 0.0006
Model 3 10.36 (6.23,14.48) <.0001 9.96 (2.39,17.54) 0.0100 7.51 (-0.39,15.41) 0.0625 11.95 (4.49,19.42) 0.0017
Model 4 9.34 (4.75,13.92) <.0001 8.91 (0.08,17.73) 0.0480 6.43 (-1.76,14.62) 0.1240 10.87 (3.21,18.53) 0.0055
Low NO 2
(0.88–8.10 ppb)
N = 1539
Mid NO 2
(8.12–15.5 ppb)
N = 2202
High NO 2
(15.5–38.7 ppb)
N = 2482
Effect
(95% CI)
p- Effect
(95% CI)
p- Effect
(95% CI)
p-
Model 1 8.25 (3.84,12.65) 0.0002 12.32 (0.91,23.74) 0.0343 0.56 (-7.10,8.21) 0.8869 -5.30 (-16.4,5.78) 0.3483
Model 2 10.45 (6.34,14.55) <.0001 11.99 (0.90,23.08) 0.0341 4.21 (-3.01,11.42) 0.2533 -6.42 (-17.1,4.25) 0.2382
Model 3 10.36 (6.23,14.48) <.0001 12.63 (1.55,23.70) 0.0255 4.28 (-2.93,11.48) 0.2443 -6.81 (-17.5,3.86) 0.2108
Model 4 9.34 (4.75,13.92) <.0001 10.82 (-1.23,22.87) 0.0784 3.82 (-3.37,11.01) 0.2974 -7.66 (-18.4,3.08) 0.1622

Presented data are adjusted CWV estimates (95% CI) per, 3 ppb increase for O3, from a linear mixed model with centre modelled as a random intercept. Model 1, unadjusted. Model 2, adjusted for age, (sex), and ethnicity. Model 3 further adjusted for the INTERHEART risk score, education and workplace location. Primary model 4 further adjusted for walkability categories, material factor score and social factor score.