Table 2.
N | Brand name | AIFA decision | Clinical development timea | EMA assessment timea | Lag time between EC and AIFAa.d | AIFA assessment timeb | Regulatory timeb | Average time to first patient accessc |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1 | Holoclar | Reimbursed | 6474 | 692 | 367 | 361 | 1430 | 430 |
2 | Strimvelis | Reimbursed | 8447 | 364 | −51 | 116 | 431 | – |
3 | Spherox | Not reimbursed | 5650 | 1656 | 886 | 682 | 3256 | – |
4 | Kymriah | Reimbursed | 2787 | 273 | −51 | 397 | 627 | 387 |
5 | Yescarta | Reimbursed | 3084 | 371 | −48 | 481 | 816 | 611 |
6 | Luxturna | Reimbursed | 3605 | 462 | 31 | 709 | 1241 | 305 |
7 | Alofisel | Not reimbursed | 2452 | 729 | −93 | 271 | 928 | – |
8 | Zolgensma | Reimbursed | 1608 | 564 | 8 | 283 | 863 | 148 |
9 | Tecartus | Reimbursed | 1522 | 321 | −45 | 483 | 773 | 155 |
10 | Libmeldy | Reimbursed | 3500 | 385 | −13 | 450 | 861 | – |
11 | Abecma | Not reimbursed | 1591 | 454 | −41 | 768 | 1185 | – |
12 | Upstaza | Reimbursed | 1908 | 902 | 122 | 348 | 1406 | – |
13 | Carvykti | Under ev. | 2036 | 370 | 33 | – | – | – |
14 | Breyanzi | Under ev. | 1636 | 627 | 58 | – | – | – |
15 | Roctavian | Under ev. | 2141 | 405 | 83 | – | – | – |
16 | Hemgenix | Under ev. | 2827 | 333 | −10 | – | – | – |
17 | Ebvallo | Under ev. | 9732 | 386 | 109 | – | – | – |
Mean | 3588 | 547 | 79 | 446 | 1151 | 340.6 | ||
Median | 2787 | 405 | 8 | 424 | 896 | 216.0 | ||
Std. Dev. | 2500 | 333 | 234 | 195 | 729 | 328.5 | ||
IQR | 1697 | 257 | 128 | 201 | 477 | 425.0 |
AIFA, Italian Medicines Agency; ATMPs, advanced therapy medicinal products; EC, European Commission; under ev, under evaluation; Std. Dev., standard deviation; IQR, inter-quartile range
aStatistics calculated on n = 17 ATMPs
bStatistics calculated on n = 12 ATMPs
cStatistics calculated on n = 6 ATMPs
dFor eight ATMPs the dossier was submitted to AIFA before the EC decision.