Skip to main content
. 2024 Nov 7;19(11):e0310771. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0310771

Table 3. Included articles.

Study Type of rodent Type of task Aversive or non-aversive
Original search (2000 to 2020)
Avital, Aga-Mizrachi & Zubedat, 2016 [52] Rats Cooperation (learning task) Non aversive
Bartal, Decety & Mason, 2011 [17] Rats Helping (freeing task–tube) Aversive (restraint)
Bartal, Rodgers, Sarria, Decety, & Mason, 2014 [53] Rats Helping (freeing task–tube) Aversive (restraint)
Bartal, Shan, Molasky, Murray, Williams, Decety & Mason, 2016 [54] Rats Helping (freeing task–tube) Aversive (restraint)
Blystad, Andersen & Johansen, 2019 [32] Rats Helping (freeing task–tube) Aversive (restraint)
Carvalheiro, Seara-Cardoso, Mesquita, de Sousa, Oliveira, Summavielle & Magalhães, 2019 [55] Rats Helping (freeing task–tube) Aversive (restraint)
Conde-Moro, Rocha-Almeida, Sánchez-Campusano, Delgado-García & Gruart & 2019 [56] Rats Cooperation (learning task) Non aversive
Cox & Reichel, 2020 [26] Rats Helping (freeing task–soaked area) Aversive (water)
Daghestani, Selim, Abd-Elhakim, Said, Abd-Hameed, Khalil & El-Tawil, 2017 [57] Rats Helping (freeing task–tube) Aversive (restraint)
de Carvalho, Dos Santos, Regaço, Barbosa, Da Silva, de Souza & Sandaker, 2018 [58] Rats Cooperation (learning task) Non aversive
Delmas, Lew & Zanutto, 2019 [59] Rats Cooperation (Prisoner’s dilemma) Non aversive
Dolivo & Taborsky 2015 (A) [60] Rats Sharing (repeated donation game) Non aversive
Dolivo & Taborsky 2015 (B) [61] Rats Sharing (repeated donation game) Non aversive
Donovan, Ryan & Wood, 2020 [62] Rats Cooperation (Prisoner’s dilemma) Non aversive
Festucci, Buccheri, Cerniglia, Paciello, Cimino, Curcio & Adriani, 2020 [63] Rats Sharing task (repeated donation game) Non aversive
Fontes-Dutra, Nunes, Santos-Terra, Souza-Nunes, Bauer-Negrini, Hirsch, Green, Riesgo, Gottfried & Bambini-Junio, 2019 [64] Rats Helping (freeing task–tube) Aversive (restraint)
Gerber, Schweinfurth & Taborsky, 2020 [65] Rats Sharing task (repeated donation game) Non aversive
Hachiga, Schwartz, Silberberg, Kearns, Gomez & Slotnick, 2018 [66] Rats Helping (freeing task–tube) Aversive (restraint)
Han, Yoon, Shin, Um & Ko, 2020 [67] Mice Cooperation (learning task) Non aversive
Havlik, Sugano, Jacobi, Kukreja, Jacobi & Mason, 2020 [68] Rats Helping (freeing task–tube) Aversive (restraint)
Hernandez-Lallement, van Wingerden, Marx, Srejic & Kalenscher, 2015 [19] Rats Sharing (prosocial choice task) Non aversive
Hernandez-Lallement, van Wingerden, Schäble & Kalenscher, 2016 [69] Rats Sharing (prosocial choice task) Non aversive
Hernandez-Lallement, Attah, Soyman, Pinhal, Gazzola & Keysers, 2020 [70] Rats Helping (not harming) Aversive (electric shocks)
Hosgorler, Koc, Kizildag, Canpolat, Argon, Karakilic, Kandis, Guvendi, Ates, Arda & Uysal, 2020 [71] Rats Helping (freeing task–soaked area) Aversive (water)
Kandis, Ates, Kizildag, Camsari, Yuce, Guvendi, Koc, Karakilic, Camsari & Uysal, 2018 [72] Rats Helping (freeing task–soaked area) Aversive (water)
Karakilic, Kizildag, Kandis, Guvendi, Koc, B. Camsari, M. Camsari, Ates, Arda & Uysal, 2018 [6] Rats Helping (freeing task–soaked area) Aversive (water)
Kentrop, Kalamari, Danesi, Kentrop, van IJzendoorn, Bakermans-Kranenburg, Joëls & van der Veen, 2020 [73] Rats Sharing (lever presses) Non aversive
Kozma, Kassai, Ernyey & Gyerytán, 2019 [74] Rats Cooperation (learning task) Non aversive
Li & Wood, 2017 [75] Rats Sharing (repeated donation game) Non aversive
Lopuch & Popik, 2011 [25] Rats Cooperation (learning task) Non aversive
Márquez, Rennie, Costa & Moita, 2015 [76] Rats Sharing (prosocial choice task) Non aversive
Oberliessen, Hernandez-Lallement, Schäble, van Wingerden, Seinstra & Kalenscher, 2016 [77] Rats Sharing (prosocial choice task) Non aversive
Raz, 2013 [78] Rats Cooperation (learning task) Non aversive
Rutte & Taborsky, 2007 [79] Rats Sharing (lever presses) Non aversive
Rutte & Taborsky, 2008 [80] Rats Sharing (repeated donation game) Non aversive
Sato, Tan, Tate & Okada, 2015 [18] Rats Helping (freeing task–soaked area) Aversive (water)
Schmid, Schneeberger & Taborsky, 2017 [81] Rats Sharing (stick pulling) Non aversive
Schneeberger, Dietz & Taborsky, 2012 [82] Rats Sharing (repeated donation game) Non aversive
Schönfeld, Schäble, Zech & Kalenscher, 2020 [83] Rats Sharing (prosocial choice task) Non aversive
Schwartz, Silberberg, Casey, Kearns & Slotnick, 2017 [84] Rats Helping (freeing task—soaked area) Aversive (water)
Schweinfurth & Taborsky, 2016 [85] Rats Sharing (repeated donation game) Non aversive
Schweinfurth & Taborsky, 2017 [86] Rats Sharing (repeated donation game) Non aversive
Schweinfurth & Taborsky, 2018 (A) [87] Rats Sharing (repeated donation game) Non aversive
Schweinfurth & Taborsky, 2018 (B) [88] Rats Sharing (repeated donation game) Non aversive
Schweinfurth & Taborsky, 2018 (C) [89] Rats Sharing (stick pulling) Non aversive
Schweinfurth, Aeschbacher, Santi & Taborsky, 2019 [90] Rats Sharing (repeated donation game) Non aversive
Schweinfurth & Taborsky, 2020 [91] Rats Cooperation (Prisoner’s dilemma) Non aversive
Silberberg, Allouch, Sandfort, Kearns, Karpel & Slotnick, 2014 [24] Rats Helping (freeing task–soaked area) Aversive (water)
Silva, H. Silva, Lima, Meurer, Ceppi & Yamamoto, 2020 [92] Rats Helping (freeing task–tube) Aversive (restraint)
Tomek, Stegmann & Olive, 2019 [93] Rats Helping (freeing task–tube) Aversive (restraint)
Tomek, Stegmann, Leyrer-Jackson, Piña & Olive, 2020 [94] Rats Helping (freeing task–tube) Aversive (restraint)
Tsoory, Youdim & Schuster, 2012 [95] Rats Cooperation (learning task) Non aversive
Ueno, Suemitsu, Murakami, Kitamura, Wani, Matsumoto, Okamoto & Ishihara, 2019 (A) [96] Mice Helping (freeing task–tube) Aversive (restraint)
Ueno, Suemitsu, Murakami, Kitamura, Wani, Matsumoto, Okamoto & Ishihara, 2019 (B) [97] Mice Helping (freeing task–tube) Aversive (restraint)
Viana, Gordo, Sucena & Moita, 2010 [98] Rats Cooperation (Prisoner’s dilemma) Aversive (tail pinches)
Wood, Kim & Li, 2016 [99] Rats Cooperation (Prisoner’s dilemma) Non aversive
Yamagishi, Okada, Masuda & Sato, 2020 (A) [100] Rats Helping (freeing task–soaked area) Aversive (water)
Yamagishi, Lee & Sato, 2020 (B) [101] Rats Helping (freeing task–soaked area) Aversive (water)
Yüksel, Ates, Kizildag, Yüce, Koç, Kandis, Güvendi, Karakilic, Gümüs & Uysal, 2019 [102] Mice Helping (freeing task–soaked area) Aversive (water)
Updated search (2021 to 2023) Type of rodent Type of task Aversive or non-aversive
Asadi, Khodagholi, Asadi, Kamsorkh, Kaveh & Maleki, 2021 [103] Rats Helping (freeing task—soaked area) Aversive (water)
Bartal, Breton, Sheng, Long, Chen, Halliday, Kenney, Wheeler, Frankland, Shilyansky, Deisseroth, Keltner & Kaufer, 2021 [104] Rats Helping (freeing task—tube) Aversive (restraint)
Breton, Eisner, Gandhi, Musick, Zhang, Long, Perloff, Hu, Pham, Lalchandani, Barraza, Kantor, Kaufer & Bartal, 2022 [29] Rats Helping (freeing task—tube) Aversive (restraint)
Conde-Moro, Rocha-Almeida, Gebara, Delgado-Garcia, Sandi & Gruart, 2022 [105] Rats Cooperation (learning task) Non-aversive
Cox, Kearns, Woods, Brown, Brown & Reichel, 2022 [106] Rats Helping (freeing task—soaked area) Aversive (water)
Cox, Brown, Woods, Brown, Kearns & Reichel, 2022 [107] Rats Helping (freeing task—soaked area) Aversive (water)
de Carvalho, dos Santos, Regaço, Couto, de Souza & Todorov, 2020 [108] Rats Cooperation (learning task) Non-aversive
Gachomba, Esteve-Agraz, Caref, Maroto, Bortolozzo-Gleich, Laplagne & Márquez, 2022 [30] Rats Sharing (prosocial choice task) Non-aversive
Heslin & Brown, 2021 [109] Rats Helping (freeing task—tube) Aversive (restraint)
Joushi, Taherizadeh, Esmaeilpour & Sheibani, 2022 [110] Rats Sharing (prosocial choice task) Non-aversive
Kalamari, Kentrop, Danesi, Graat, van Ijzendoorn, Bakermans-Kranenburg, Joëls & van der Veen, 2021 [111] Rats Helping (freeing task—tube) Aversive (restraint)
Misiolek, Klimczak, Chrószcz, Szumiec, Bryksa, Przyborowicz, Parkitna & Harda, 2023 [33] Mice Sharing (prosocial choice task) Non-aversive
Paulsson & Taborsky, 2021 [112] Rats Sharing (repeated donation game) Non-aversive
Scheggia, La Greca, Maltese, Chiacchierini, Italia, Molent, Bernardi, Coccia, Carrano, Zianni, Gardoni, Di Luca & Papaleo, 2022 [31] Mice Sharing (nose poking) Non-aversive
Schweinfurth, 2021 [113] Rats Sharing (repeated donation game) Non-aversive
Segura, Clavijo & Bouzas, 2019 [126] Rats Cooperation (learning task) Non-aversive
Sen, Kara, Koyu, Simsek, Kizildag & Uysal, 2021 [35] Rats Helping (freeing task—soaked area) Aversive (water)
Shima, Kawabata-Iwakawa, Onishi, Jesmin & Yoshikawa, 2022 [114] Mice Helping (freeing task—soaked area) Aversive (water)
Subhadeep, Srikumar, Shankaranarayana & Kutty, 2022 [115] Rats Helping (freeing task—tube) Aversive (restraint)
Wan, Kirkman, Jensen & Hackenberg, 2021 [116] Rats Helping (freeing task—tube) Aversive (restraint)
Wu, Cheng, Liang, Lee & Yen, 2023 [117] Rats Helping (freeing task—tube) Aversive (restraint)