Skip to main content
. 2024 Oct 31;13(21):3059. doi: 10.3390/plants13213059

Table A1.

Comparative Performance of genomic prediction models in terms of Pearson´s correlation (COR) (A), Normalized Root Mean Square Error (NRMSE) (B), Percentage of Matching in top 10% (PM_10) (C), and top 20% (PM_20) (D) for the TPE_1_2021_2022 data set under Incomplete Block Design (IBD Cross-Validation and Random Cross-Validation.

METRIC CV MODEL MIN MEAN MEDIAN MAX SD RE (%)
COR IBD GBLUP 0.825 0.849 0.845 0.875 0.017 0.323
COR IBD GBLUP_CE 0.742 0.825 0.840 0.869 0.044 3.188
COR IBD GBLUP_CE_Abs 0.729 0.829 0.830 0.873 0.041 2.759
COR IBD GBLUP_CE_mean 0.776 0.833 0.840 0.870 0.029 2.176
COR IBD GBLUP_CE_Res 0.812 0.842 0.842 0.879 0.022 1.085
COR IBD GBLUP_TRN 0.824 0.852 0.849 0.880 0.019 0.000
COR Random GBLUP 0.762 0.799 0.802 0.829 0.019 8.592
COR Random GBLUP_CE 0.739 0.789 0.797 0.818 0.025 9.898
COR Random GBLUP_CE_Abs 0.725 0.785 0.791 0.833 0.037 10.547
COR Random GBLUP_CE_mean 0.766 0.808 0.814 0.829 0.021 7.422
COR Random GBLUP_CE_Res 0.764 0.804 0.803 0.837 0.021 7.971
COR Random GBLUP_TRN 0.834 0.868 0.864 0.896 0.017 0.000
NRMSE IBD GBLUP 0.507 0.612 0.615 0.700 0.062 10.170
NRMSE IBD GBLUP_CE 0.546 0.670 0.676 0.741 0.060 20.681
NRMSE IBD GBLUP_CE_Abs 0.600 0.686 0.672 0.801 0.057 23.602
NRMSE IBD GBLUP_CE_mean 0.587 0.675 0.675 0.771 0.057 21.525
NRMSE IBD GBLUP_CE_Res 0.582 0.664 0.671 0.719 0.043 19.667
NRMSE IBD GBLUP_TRN 0.476 0.555 0.561 0.618 0.043 0.000
NRMSE Random GBLUP 0.564 0.627 0.628 0.679 0.038 23.757
NRMSE Random GBLUP_CE 0.649 0.681 0.667 0.738 0.034 34.315
NRMSE Random GBLUP_CE_Abs 0.615 0.700 0.702 0.776 0.045 38.149
NRMSE Random GBLUP_CE_mean 0.628 0.675 0.666 0.761 0.038 33.242
NRMSE Random GBLUP_CE_Res 0.604 0.664 0.659 0.724 0.031 31.017
NRMSE Random GBLUP_TRN 0.455 0.507 0.508 0.568 0.033 0.000
PM_10 IBD GBLUP 48.485 65.758 62.121 84.848 11.521 −0.922
PM_10 IBD GBLUP_CE 42.424 60.000 63.636 69.697 9.236 8.586
PM_10 IBD GBLUP_CE_Abs 36.364 60.909 60.606 84.848 13.282 6.965
PM_10 IBD GBLUP_CE_mean 36.364 60.303 62.121 78.788 11.014 8.040
PM_10 IBD GBLUP_CE_Res 48.485 63.333 65.152 78.788 8.505 2.871
PM_10 IBD GBLUP_TRN 42.424 65.152 63.636 84.848 12.392 0.000
PM_10 Random GBLUP 48.485 63.333 66.667 78.788 9.416 7.177
PM_10 Random GBLUP_CE 48.485 62.727 63.636 72.727 9.040 8.213
PM_10 Random GBLUP_CE_Abs 54.545 63.939 63.636 72.727 5.794 6.161
PM_10 Random GBLUP_CE_mean 54.545 64.545 63.636 75.758 7.831 5.164
PM_10 Random GBLUP_CE_Res 54.545 63.333 62.121 75.758 6.136 7.177
PM_10 Random GBLUP_TRN 48.485 67.879 69.697 78.788 8.713 0.000
PM_20 IBD GBLUP 63.636 70.606 69.697 84.848 6.235 0.429
PM_20 IBD GBLUP_CE 51.515 65.758 65.152 81.818 8.812 7.834
PM_20 IBD GBLUP_CE_Abs 48.485 66.667 66.667 78.788 9.367 6.364
PM_20 IBD GBLUP_CE_mean 57.576 66.970 66.667 78.788 6.136 5.882
PM_20 IBD GBLUP_CE_Res 57.576 66.970 65.152 81.818 7.619 5.882
PM_20 IBD GBLUP_TRN 63.636 70.909 69.697 84.848 6.731 0.000
PM_20 Random GBLUP 59.091 69.697 71.212 77.273 5.249 3.913
PM_20 Random GBLUP_CE 54.545 65.000 63.636 77.273 7.871 11.422
PM_20 Random GBLUP_CE_Abs 51.515 61.970 57.576 75.758 9.270 16.870
PM_20 Random GBLUP_CE_mean 56.061 67.576 67.424 75.758 5.449 7.175
PM_20 Random GBLUP_CE_Res 59.091 66.818 67.424 74.242 5.553 8.390
PM_20 Random GBLUP_TRN 60.606 72.424 74.242 78.788 5.430 0.000