Skip to main content
. 2024 Oct 31;13(21):3059. doi: 10.3390/plants13213059

Table A4.

Comparative Performance of genomic prediction models in terms of Pearson´s correlation (COR) (A), Normalized Root Mean Square Error (NRMSE) (B), Percentage of Matching in top 10% (PM_10) (C), and top 20% (PM_20) (D) for the Across-data sets under Incomplete Block Design (IBD Cross-Validation and Random Cross-Validation.

METRIC CV MODEL MIN MEAN MEDIAN MAX SD RE (%)
COR IBD GBLUP 0.553 0.819 0.840 0.885 0.064 3.234
COR IBD GBLUP_CE 0.545 0.786 0.798 0.900 0.066 7.625
COR IBD GBLUP_CE_Abs 0.563 0.781 0.796 0.881 0.067 8.353
COR IBD GBLUP_CE_Res 0.557 0.795 0.809 0.894 0.062 6.341
COR IBD GBLUP_CE_mean 0.584 0.791 0.804 0.886 0.062 6.906
COR IBD GBLUP_TRN 0.723 0.846 0.849 0.890 0.028 0.000
COR Random GBLUP 0.574 0.802 0.812 0.873 0.054 4.538
COR Random GBLUP_CE 0.549 0.758 0.770 0.841 0.064 10.548
COR Random GBLUP_CE_Abs 0.517 0.757 0.773 0.844 0.072 10.748
COR Random GBLUP_CE_Res 0.589 0.777 0.798 0.854 0.058 7.893
COR Random GBLUP_CE_mean 0.583 0.773 0.788 0.857 0.061 8.470
COR Random GBLUP_TRN 0.594 0.838 0.858 0.904 0.067 0.000
NRMSE IBD GBLUP 0.480 0.597 0.567 0.873 0.093 2.138
NRMSE IBD GBLUP_CE 0.538 0.685 0.674 0.882 0.072 17.235
NRMSE IBD GBLUP_CE_Abs 0.570 0.696 0.687 0.881 0.071 19.113
NRMSE IBD GBLUP_CE_Res 0.517 0.674 0.664 0.942 0.079 15.271
NRMSE IBD GBLUP_CE_mean 0.541 0.681 0.678 0.824 0.068 16.618
NRMSE IBD GBLUP_TRN 0.467 0.584 0.551 1.090 0.113 0.000
NRMSE Random GBLUP 0.500 0.616 0.601 0.879 0.080 5.335
NRMSE Random GBLUP_CE 0.597 0.711 0.708 0.858 0.056 21.566
NRMSE Random GBLUP_CE_Abs 0.601 0.716 0.711 0.882 0.061 22.390
NRMSE Random GBLUP_CE_Res 0.572 0.689 0.684 0.909 0.065 17.804
NRMSE Random GBLUP_CE_mean 0.589 0.698 0.695 0.830 0.059 19.245
NRMSE Random GBLUP_TRN 0.428 0.585 0.530 1.014 0.156 0.000
PM_10 IBD GBLUP 9.091 55.393 57.576 84.848 12.836 3.462
PM_10 IBD GBLUP_CE 12.500 48.956 48.732 73.469 12.735 17.067
PM_10 IBD GBLUP_CE_Abs 9.091 48.453 48.485 84.848 14.124 18.283
PM_10 IBD GBLUP_CE_Res 18.182 51.463 54.545 78.788 13.780 11.365
PM_10 IBD GBLUP_CE_mean 16.667 48.828 48.980 78.788 13.503 17.373
PM_10 IBD GBLUP_TRN 27.273 57.311 57.955 84.848 10.870 0.000
PM_10 Random GBLUP 27.273 54.581 54.824 78.788 12.279 2.546
PM_10 Random GBLUP_CE 15.152 48.416 47.159 72.727 14.479 15.603
PM_10 Random GBLUP_CE_Abs 12.121 48.571 50.000 72.727 14.630 15.234
PM_10 Random GBLUP_CE_Res 18.182 49.453 50.510 75.758 13.908 13.179
PM_10 Random GBLUP_CE_mean 18.182 48.628 48.980 79.167 14.235 15.100
PM_10 Random GBLUP_TRN 9.091 55.970 54.545 87.500 14.294 0.000
PM_20 IBD GBLUP 22.727 64.066 66.667 84.848 10.220 5.696
PM_20 IBD GBLUP_CE 22.727 59.846 60.606 81.818 10.276 13.149
PM_20 IBD GBLUP_CE_Abs 22.727 59.565 60.606 78.788 10.733 13.683
PM_20 IBD GBLUP_CE_Res 31.818 61.310 63.636 81.818 9.749 10.448
PM_20 IBD GBLUP_CE_mean 27.273 60.405 60.915 78.788 10.281 12.102
PM_20 IBD GBLUP_TRN 40.909 67.715 67.929 84.848 8.298 0.000
PM_20 Random GBLUP 40.909 63.410 64.899 78.571 8.349 3.038
PM_20 Random GBLUP_CE 36.364 59.309 59.184 77.273 8.738 10.163
PM_20 Random GBLUP_CE_Abs 37.879 58.871 59.091 75.758 8.495 10.982
PM_20 Random GBLUP_CE_Res 40.909 60.861 60.606 74.242 7.140 7.353
PM_20 Random GBLUP_CE_mean 40.909 60.746 60.606 75.758 7.820 7.557
PM_20 Random GBLUP_TRN 40.909 65.336 67.007 79.592 8.849 0.000