Table 1.
Overview of studies included.
| First author, date | Study location | Participant dependence status | N (dependent) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Alcohol, n = 11 | |||
| Alba-Ferrara 2016 | California, USA | Early (<12 months) or sustained (>12 months) remission | 10 |
| Charlet 2014 | Mannheim, Germany | 4–24 days abstinent | 33 |
| Gilman 2008 | Maryland, USA | 3 weeks abstinent | 12 |
| Jansen 2019 | Amsterdam, Netherlands | Minimum 3 weeks abstinent | 39 |
| Kim 2014 | Seoul, South Korea | 3–21 days abstinent | 38 |
| Marinkovic 2009 | Massachusetts, USA | 4 weeks abstinent | 15 |
| O’Daly 2012 | London, UK | Minimum 2 weeks abstinent | 29 (12 MSDs) |
| Salloum 2007 | Maryland, USA | Mean 28 days since last drink ± 15 days | 11 |
| Seo 2013 | Connecticut, USA | 4–8 weeks abstinent | 45 |
| Zakiniaiez 2017 | Connecticut, USA | 4–6 weeks abstinent (mean 34 days) | 45 |
| Yang 2013 | Texas, USA | 3–5 weeks abstinent | 15 |
| Cocaine, n = 6 | |||
| Albein-Urios 2014 | Grenada, Spain | Minimum 15 days abstinent | 17 |
| Asensio 2010 | Valencia, Spain | 72 hours abstinent | 32 |
| Canterberry 2016 | USA (unspecified) | Not stated | 20 |
| Potenza 2012 | Connecticut, USA | Minimum 2 weeks abstinent | 30 |
| Sinha 2005 | Connecticut, USA | Minimum 2 weeks abstinent | 20 |
| Xu 2013 | Connecticut, USA | 2–4 weeks in treatment | 67 |
| Opioids, n = 4 | |||
| Schmidt 2014 | Basel, Switzerland | Maintained on heroin for at least 6 months | 22 |
| Schmidt 2015 | Basel, Switzerland | Maintained on heroin for at least 6 months | 22 (as above) |
| Wang 2010 | Shantou, China | Abstinent 2–5 months | 17 |
| Smoski 2011 | Washington, USA | Maintained on buprenorphine/naloxone for average 14.8 weeks | 12 |
| Cannabis, n = 3 | |||
| Wesley 2016 | Kentucky, USA | Abstinent the day of scanning | 16 |
| Wetherill 2014 | Pennsylvania, | Self-reported abstinence 1.5 ± 1.5 days | 20 |
| Zimmermann 2018 | Bonn, Germany | At least 28 days abstinent | 19 |
Abbreviations: MSD medically supervised detoxification, USA United States of America.