Table 2.
Systematic Reviews and Meta-analyses included
| Reference | First Author | Journal | Year | Impact Factor | LOE | Study Design | Intervention | Funding Source | AMSTAR 2 rating | Journal Recomm. to Follow PRISMA? | Reported Adherence to PRISMA Guidelines | Spin Bias Present, Categories Present |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 13 | Krivicich | JAAOS | 2023 | 3.2 | III | SR & MA | Surgery—HA | Not mentioned | Moderate | No | Yes | Yes, inappropriate extrapolation |
| 14 | Lee | Arthroscopy | 2023 | 8.5 | IV | SR | Surgery—HA | Not mentioned | Critically low | Yes | Yes | Yes, inappropriate extrapolation |
| 15 | Murata | OJSM | 2021 | 3.5 | III | SR & MA | Surgery—HA | Not mentioned | Critically low | Yes | Yes | Yes, misleading reporting, misleading interpretation |
| 16 | Murata | OJSM | 2021 | 3.5 | IV | SR | Surgery—HA vs. PAO | Not mentioned | Low | Yes | Yes | No |
| 17 | Kuroda | Arthroscopy | 2020 | 8.5 | IV | SR | Surgery—HA | Not mentioned | Critically low | Yes | Yes | Yes, misleading reporting, misleading interpretation, inappropriate extrapolation |
| 18 | Shah | KSSTA | 2020 | 7.3 | IV | SR | Surgery—HA | Not funded | Low | Yes | Yes | Yes, misleading reporting, misleading interpretation |
| 19 | Adler | Arthroscopy | 2019 | 8.5 | IV | SR | Surgery—HA, PAO | Not mentioned | Critically low | Yes | Yes | No |
| 20 | Ding | AJSM | 2019 | 9.8 | IV | SR | Surgery—HA | Not mentioned | Critically low | Yes | Yes | Yes, misleading reporting, misleading interpretation, inappropriate extrapolation |
| 21 | Barton | IOJ | 2019 | 1.5 | IV | SR | Surgery—HA, PAO | Not funded | Critically low | No | No | Yes, misleading reporting, misleading interpretation, inappropriate extrapolation |
| 22 | Lodhia | Arthroscopy | 2016 | 8.5 | IV | SR | Surgery—HA, PAO | Not funded | Critically low | Yes | No | Yes, misleading reporting, misleading interpretation, inappropriate extrapolation |
| 23 | Jo | JHPS | 2016 | n/a | IV | SR | Surgery—HA | Not funded | Critically low | Yes | Yes | Yes, misleading reporting, misleading interpretation |
| 24 | Yeung | Bone Joint Res | 2016 | 6.9 | IV | SR | Surgery—HA | Not funded | Low | Yes | No | Yes, misleading reporting |
AJSM, The American Journal of Sports Medicine; AMSTAR 2, A Measurement Tool to Assess Systematic Reviews version 2; Bone Joint Res, Bone & Joint Research; HA, hip arthroscopy; IOJ, The Iowa Orthopaedic Journal; JAAOS, Journal of the American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons; JHPS, Journal of Hip Preservation Surgery; KSSTA, Knee Surgery, Sports Traumatology, Arthroscopy; LOE, level of evidence; MA, meta-analysis; n/a, not applicable; OJSM, Orthopaedic Journal of Sports Medicine; PAO, periacetabular osteotomy; PRISMA, Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses; Recomm., recommendation; SR, systematic review.