Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2024 Nov 13.
Published in final edited form as: Child Maltreat. 2018 Apr 11;23(3):303–315. doi: 10.1177/1077559518767337

Table 2.

Percent of Definitional Aspects By Cluster

State Percent By Cluster
Definitional Aspect Count Minimal Cornerstones Expanded




NIS-4 Physical Neglect
  Medical Care Delay or Failure 47 80% 100% 80%
  Inadequate Nutrition 43 53% 100% 80%
  Inadequate Supervision 37 87% 71% 40%
  Abandonment/Refusal of Custody 36 67% 74% 60%
  Inadequate Shelter 35 100% 40%
  Inadequate Clothing 31 90% 40%
  Illegal Transfer of Custody 8 20% 40%
  Other Refusal of Custody (runaway) 2
  Inadequate Personal Hygiene 2
NIS-4 Educational Neglect
  Failure to Register/Enroll 6 20% 20%
  Permitted Chronic Truancy 2
NIS-4 Emotional Neglect
  Exposure to Maladaptive Environments 19 20% 48% 20%
  Refusal to Seek Care for Emotional Problem 8 80%
  Refusal to Provide Care for Emotional Problem 5 80%
  Knowingly Permitting Substance Abuse 3 40%
  Domestic Violence 2
Exclusions
  General Religious Exemption 33 80% 61% 40%
  Involuntary Neglect 21 52% 60%
  Specific Religious Exemption 2 20%
Categories from Literature
  Threat of Harm Enough 34 20% 87% 80%
  Child-Focused Definition 21 47% 35% 60%
  Substance Exposed Infant 12 32% 20%
  Exposure to Drug Activity 10 60%

Note: Categories with fewer than 2 states’ endorsement were not included in the analysis.

Values less than 20% are not presented; Values above 80% are bolded for ease of interpretation.