Ultrahigh-frequency SAW |
102 cells per mL |
<7 h |
30 °C |
6.5 |
Rayleigh wave |
Microbial metabolism affects loop capacitance inductance to change the resonant frequency |
Simple, high sensitivity, does not require highly skilled technicians, low cost, and real-time bacteria monitoring |
Time consuming, frequency dependent |
114
|
Love-wave immunosensor |
106 cells per mL |
<1 h |
37 °C |
7.2 |
Love wave |
Antibody–antigen covalent binding, mass-loading effect leading to a resonant frequency shift |
Ultrahigh stability, real-time monitoring, low cost, reusable, short detection time |
High IL, guiding layer effect |
68 and 124
|
Dual-channel SAW biosensor |
105–106 cells per mL |
<3 h |
25 °C |
7.4 |
Love wave |
Mass adsorption effect leading to a frequency difference (Δf) between the test channel and the reference channel |
High sensitivity, good response, and short detection time |
Influenced by temperature, pressure, competitive non-labeled methods |
57, 120 and 125
|
LGS-SH-SAW |
∼106 cells per mL |
2–5 h |
25 °C |
7.4 |
Shear horizontal wave |
Antigen–antibody specific binding changes cause a phase shift |
Label-free detection, reduced attenuation, high-temperature stability and flexibility, good antibody bonding |
Sensitivity, detection limit |
56 and 98
|
SAW impedance sensor |
102–107 cells per mL |
7 h |
37 °C |
7.0 |
Rayleigh wave and Love wave |
Changes in the impedance of the medium produced by bacterial metabolism cause changes in the frequency signal |
Simple, real-time bacteria monitoring, can be used by both scientists and unprofessional |
Exhibits high attenuation in liquids |
108
|
SH-SAW biosensor |
6.54 × 105 CFU mL−1
|
2 h |
30 °C |
7.3–7.5 |
Shear horizontal wave |
Antibody adsorption in the waveguide layer causes a resonant frequency shift |
High specificity, repeatability, reproducibility, and lower detection time |
Loss of energy, orientation of the crystal, corrosion |
11, 45 and 124
|