Study
|
Randomization
|
Deviations from intended interventions
|
Missing outcome data
|
Outcome measurement
|
Selection of reported results
|
Overall risk
|
Villanova-Lรณpez et al.ย [11]
|
๐ข Low: Adequately described randomization and allocation
|
๐ข Low: Double-blinding maintained
|
๐ข Low: No significant missing data
|
๐ข Low: Outcome assessors were blinded
|
๐ข Low: No selective reporting
|
๐ข Low
|
Di Sante et al.ย [12]
|
๐ก Some concerns: Randomization method not fully described
|
๐ก Some concerns: Blinding details insufficient
|
๐ข Low: Minimal missing data
|
๐ก Some concerns: Unclear maintenance of blinding of outcome assessors
|
๐ข Low: No selective reporting
|
๐ก Some concerns
|
Dallari et al.ย [13]
|
๐ข Low: Well-described with allocation concealment
|
๐ข Low: Double-blinding maintained
|
๐ข Low: Minimal missing data
|
๐ข Low: Blinded assessors and consistent outcome measurement
|
๐ข Low: Pre-specified outcomes reported
|
๐ข Low
|
Nouri et al.ย [14]
|
๐ก Some concerns: Inadequate description of allocation concealment
|
๐ก Some concerns: Blinding unclear across multiple groups
|
๐ข Low: Minimal missing data
|
๐ก Some concerns: Unclear blinding of outcome assessors
|
๐ข Low: No selective reporting
|
๐ก Some concerns
|
Doria et al.ย [15]
|
๐ก Some concerns: Allocation concealment not described
|
๐ก Some concerns: Blinding insufficient for providers
|
๐ข Low: Minimal missing data
|
๐ก Some concerns: Unclear blinding of assessors
|
๐ข Low: No selective reporting
|
๐ก Some concerns
|