Skip to main content
. 2024 Oct 24;21(11):1404. doi: 10.3390/ijerph21111404

Table 1.

Results of the scoping review data extraction process.

Title Year What Is the
Objective of
the Paper?
Concept(s) Being Studied Inclusion/
Exclusion Criteria
Population What Is the Tribe(s) or Urban Areas Involved Identity Scale(s) Used How Are
Indigenous People
Defined in the Study?
What Theoretical Frameworks Are Utilized for the Study? Does the
Paper Mention if Any
Authors Are
Indigenous?
Culturally related anxiety and ethnic identity in Navajo college students 1999 To explore the relationship between ethnic identity and culturally related anxiety Identity; Personal Health; Well-Being Self-Identity Of Navajo University Students Navajo University Students Navajo Nation Native American Cultural Involvement and Detachment Anxiety Questionnaire (CIDAQ); Multigroup Ethnic Identity Measure Self-Identity Orthogonal Cultural Identification Theory No
Assessment of culturally related anxiety in American Indians and Alaska Natives 2000 To develop and provide an initial test of the Native American Cultural Involvement and Detachment Anxiety Questionnaire (CIDAQ) in a sample of American Indian and Alaska Native college
students
Perceived Discrimination; Acculturative, And Physical Stress Native American and Alaska Native College Students in Kansas AI/AN University Students Haskell University Students Native American Cultural Involvement and Detachment Anxiety Questionnaire (CIDAQ); Cultural Identification Scale Self-Identity Orthogonal Cultural Identification Theory No
Anxiety, stress, and health in northern plains Native Americans 2003 To investigate the relationship between self-reported anxiety, stressful events, health, and cultural identification among Native Americans from a rural community in northeastern Nebraska Cultural Identity’s Association with Alcohol and Other Drug Use Enrollment Or Reported Family Lineage and Community Recognition Northern Plains Native Americans Various Tribes: 85% Of Participants Indicated They Were from The Same Tribe Northern Plains Bicultural Inventory Reported Enrollment in A Federally Recognized Tribe or Reported Family Lineage and Community Recognition. Orthogonal Cultural Identification Theory; Orthogonal Theory of Biculturalism Yes
Resilience among native Hawaiian adolescents: ethnic identity, psychological distress, and well-being 2003 To examine the effects of stressful life events and cultural stressors on psychological functioning
To examine effects of ethnic identity as a protective factor on psychological functioning
Examine if ethnic identity moderates’ effect of stressors on psychological functioning
Identity; Tradition; Spirituality; Wellbeing; And Mental Health Native Hawaiian Students from Singular High School, Ages 14–18 Native Hawaiians Native Hawaiians Multigroup Ethnic Identity Measure (MEIM) Self-Identity Model Of Resilience No
Cultural identity, explanatory style, and depression in Navajo adolescents 2004 To understand the relationship between Navajo cultural identity and depression and its risk factors Cultural Connectedness; Physical Health; And Mental Health Navajo Adolescent Students Enrolled in Navajo Reservation Schools Navajo Adolescents Navajo Navajo Cultural Identity Measure (NCIM) Students Enrolled at Navajo Schools and Self-Identify Indigenous Stress and Coping Model No
Initial development of a Cultural Values and Beliefs Scale among Dakota/Nakota/Lakota people: a pilot study 2006 Validate a tool designed to Indigenous incorporate cultural values into a mental health instrument Mental Health; Stress and Coping; Historical Loss; Ethnic Identity; Well-Being Self-Identification Of Current and Former Dakota, Nakota, And Lakota University Students Dakota/Nakota/Lakota University Students Dakota/Nakota/Lakota in Midwestern University Setting Native American Cultural Values and Beliefs Survey (NACVBS) Self-Identity Wellness Grounded in Spirituality, Values, And Beliefs No
Teen Intervention Project–Cherokee 2006 To advance knowledge for practice concerning alcohol abuse intervention among a Native American adolescent population Cultural Identity and Beliefs/Level of Distress Cherokee Adolescents Who Were Referred from Substance Abuse Counseling at School Cherokee Adolescents Cherokee Nation Cherokee Self-Reliance Questionnaire Enrollment Social Learning Theory; Problem Behavior Theory Yes
Stress, coping, and well-being among the Yup’ik of the Yukon-Kuskokwim Delta: the role of
enculturation and acculturation
2007 To report on the relationships between cultural identity and stress, coping, and psychological well-being in Yup’ik communities Identity; Stress, Coping; Psychological Well-Being Self-Identity Yup’ik People in Six Rural Villages in Alaska Yup’ik People in Alaska Measures Of Cultural Identification Consisted of Two Separate Items. One Item Assessed the Level of Kass’aq (White) Identification or Acculturation. A Second Item Assessed Level of Yup’ik Identification, Or Enculturation Self-Identity, From Village Orthogonal Cultural Identification Theory Yes
Conceptions of Wellness among the Yup’ik of the Yukon–Kuskokwim Delta: The Vitality of Social and Natural Connection 2007 To understand the plausible health benefits of enculturation, including the role of cultivating harmonious relationships, core values, and self-defining features of the traditional Yup’ik worldview Identity; Mental Health; Well-Being; Yup’ik Adults Yup’ik Indigenous People Yup’ik Indigenous Communities Qualitative Study Self-Identified Yup’ik People Residing in Villages Grounded Theory No
Culture and Context: Buffering the Relationship Between Stressful
Life Events and Risky Behaviors in American Indian Youth
2011 The Sacred Mountain Youth Project was conducted to investigate risk and protective factors related to alcohol and drug use among American Indian youth Identity; Resilience; Stress; Alcohol and Drug Use Must Be American Indian and In One Of Two Eligible Dormitories Between the Ages Of 15 And 24 Indigenous Youth Not Disclosed Orthogonal Cultural Identification Scale Self-Identity Orthogonal Cultural Identification Theory Yes
Measuring historical trauma in an American Indian community sample: contributions of substance dependence, affective disorder, conduct disorder, and PTSD 2013 To evaluate the extent to which the frequency of thoughts of historical loss and associated symptoms are influenced by current traumatic events, post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD), cultural identification, percent Native American Heritage, substance dependence, affective/anxiety disorders, and conduct disorder/antisocial personality disorder (ASPD) Trauma; PTSD; Cultural Identity; Substance Dependence At Least 1/16th Native American Heritage (NAH), Be
Between the Ages Of 18 And 70 Years, And Be Mobile Enough to Be Transported from His or Her Home to The Scripps Research Institute (TSRI)
Reservation Based Indigenous People Not Made Public Orthogonal Cultural Identification Scale (OCIS) Blood Quantum Based None Listed No
Cultural Identity among Urban American Indian/Native Alaskan Youth: Implications for Alcohol and Drug Use 2016 To develop culturally relevant and developmentally appropriate alcohol and other drug use interventions for urban AI/AN youth Alcohol And Substance Use; Risky Behavior; American
Indian Youth; Cultural Identity; Depressed Mood; Risk Factors; Protective Factors
Does Not Explicitly Say but Participants Are AI/AN From Northern or Southern California and Of All Different Ages. Urban AI/AN Youth, Parents, Providers in California Urban Communities in Northern and Southern California Qualitative Study Self-Identification And Recruitment Through Third Party Health Services Historical Trauma; Community Based Participatory Research No
Cultural values, coping, and hope in Yup’ik communities facing rapid cultural change 2018 To build knowledge of culturally based strategies, values, resources, and protective factors that facilitate adaptation to rapid cultural change and that could be used in community-driven interventions to promote wellness in rural Alaska Native communities Culture; Coping; Intergenerational Knowledge; Historical Trauma; Resilience Factors Residents Of Yup’ik Villages Yup’ik Communities in Alaska Yup’ik Tribe Qualitative Study Self-Identity Of Indigenous People Within Communities Grounded Theory Yes
Academic stress of Native American undergraduates: The role of ethnic identity, cultural congruity, and self-beliefs 2019 To explore the relation of self-beliefs, ethnic identity, and cultural congruity with academic stress amongst Indigenous university students Cultural Identity; Sense of Community; Emotional/Behavioral Health Self-Identification, Recruitment Through Student Support Services Indigenous Undergraduate University Students University Setting Modified version of Multidimensional Inventory of Black Identity (MIBI-T) Self-Identity Theory Of Academic Persistence Yes
The Culture is Prevention Project: Measuring Culture as a Social Determinant of Mental Health for Native/Indigenous Peoples 2020 Will the incorporation of Indigenous culture affect health outcomes for Indigenous people Ethnic Identity; College Outcomes; Academic Success Self-Identification San Francisco Bay Area Indigenous Community Members Urban Indigenous Population in The San Francisco Bay Area And the Surrounding Area Cultural Connectedness Scale-California (CCS-CA) Self-Identity Community-Based Participatory Research Approach; Strength-Based Approach Yes
Indigenous Alaskan and mainstream identification explain the link between perceived discrimination and acculturative stress 2021 To examine the effect of discrimination on acculturative and physical stress Ethnic-Racial Identity; Gender Identity; Adolescence; American Indians; Psychosocial Adjustment Self-Identification Alaska Native Identifying People Aleut, Alaska Native, Eskimo, Yup’ik, Inupiaq, Athabascan, Tlingit and Haida Branscombe’s Gender Identity Scale, Replacing “Gender Group” With “Alaska Native” Self-Identity Rejection-Identification Hypothesis; Acculturation Hypothesis No
Identifying as American Indian/Alaska Native in Urban Areas: Implications for Adolescent Behavioral Health and Well-Being 2021 To examine Indigenous identity’s association with behavioral health and well-being Ethnic Identity; Academic Stress; Cultural Congruity; Self-belief Adolescents Had to Be 14 To 18 Years Old (Inclusive) And Either Verbally Identify as AI/AN Or Be Identified As AI/AN By a Family Member. Urban Indigenous Adolescents Urban Areas Across Central, Southern, And Northern California Multigroup Ethnic Identity Measure (MEIM) Self-Identity Theoretical Conceptualization of Behavioral Health and Well-Being as It Relates To AI/AN Racial-Ethnic and Cultural Identity No
Unveiling an ‘invisible population’: health, substance use, sexual behavior, culture, and discrimination among urban American Indian/Alaska Native adolescents in California 2021 To address gaps in urban Indigenous communities by sharing qualitative research with urban Indigenous communities Cultural Identity; Stress; Discrimination; Urban/Reservation To Be Eligible for The Project, Adolescents Had to Be 14–18 Years Old (Inclusive) And Either Verbally Self-Identify as AI/AN Or Be Identified As AI/AN By a Parent/Guardian or Community Elder. Eligible Adolescents Were Scheduled to Complete a Baseline Survey at A Time and Place
That Was Convenient to Them.
Urban Indigenous Adolescents Northern, Central, And Southern California Urban Areas Multigroup Ethnic Identity Measure (MEIM) Self-Identification Or Identification by Elder or Parent None Specified No
Ethnic-racial identity, gender identity, and well-being in Cherokee early adolescents 2021 Examine Cherokee adolescents’ ethnic identities and how they relate to self-esteem and well-being Stress; Cultural Identity; Anxiety Citizens Of Eastern Band of Cherokee Indians Cherokee Adolescents Eastern Band of Cherokee Indians Modified version of Multidimensional Inventory of Black Identity (MIBI-T) Enrollment Self-Categorization Theory; Social Identity Theories No
The Health Effects of a Cherokee
Grounded Culture and Leadership
2022 To assess the effectiveness of Cherokee culture-based program on changes in health and well-being Cultural Identity; Anxiety; Stress; Involvement in Western Culture Participants Selected from Their Respective Tribes Cherokee Nation Youth Cherokee Nation; Eastern Band of Cherokee Indians Multigroup Ethnic Identity Measure Enrolled Members Selected by Tribal Authorities Indigenous/CBPR Outcomes Evaluation Yes
The Culture is Prevention Project: measuring cultural connectedness and providing evidence that culture is a social determinant of health for Native Americans 2023 To report on Culture is Prevention and the assessment of cultural connectedness, physical health, and mental health Anxiety; Ethnic Identity; Culture Self-Identification Urban Dwelling Native Americans San Francisco, Santa Rosa, Fresno Cultural Connectedness Scale-California (CCS-CA) Self-Identity None Specified Yes
The Impact of Historical Loss on Native American College Students’
Mental Health: The Protective Role of Ethnic Identity
2023 To examine the theorized pathways among historical loss, well-being, psychological distress, and the proposed cultural buffer of ethnic identity in the indigenist stress-coping model (ISCM) Well-being; Ethnic Identity; And Psychological Distress Not Explicitly Stated Indigenous University Students University Setting Multigroup Ethnic Identity Measure-Revised (MEIM-R) Self-Identity Indigeneist Stress-Coping Model Yes
Knowing Who You Are (Becoming): Effects of a University-Based Elder-Led Cultural Identity Program on Alaska Native Students’ Identity Development, Cultural Strengths, Sense of Community, and Behavioral Health 2023 To provide outcomes of a pilot test of the Cultural Identity Project, an Elder-led cultural identity development program Psychological Well-Being; Enculturation; Acculturation; Stress; Collectivism Self-Identified Indigenous Undergraduate Students Who Are Over Eighteen Alaska Native College Students University Setting Multigroup Ethnic Identity Measure–Revise; Native Cultural Health Assessment Tool Self-Identity Through Recruitment at Indigenous Serving Center None Specified Yes
How Ethnic Identity Affects Campus Experience and Academic Outcomes for Native American Undergraduates 2023 To understand how ethnic identity affects campus experience and academic outcomes for Native American Undergraduates Indigenous identity; Self-Reliance; substance Abuse; Stress Self-Identification And Current Undergraduate Students Who Are Over Eighteen Native American Undergraduate Students University Setting Multigroup Ethnic Identity Measure (MEIM) Self-Identity Social Identity Theory; Tribal Critical Race Theory No