Table 2.
Article | Primary Intervention | Sleep disorder or disturbance | Determination | Delivery Modality | Comparator | N Tx/Ctrl | Trial Design | Duration (Intervention/FU) |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Acceptance and Commitment Therapy | ||||||||
75. Herbert et al., 2017 | VTC-ACT | - | Potential | Video teleconferencing | In person ACT | 64/65 | 2 arm RCT | 8w/6m |
76. Lang et al., 2017 | ACT | - | Probable | In Person (1:1) | Present-Centered Therapy | 80/80 | 2 arm RCT | 12w/3,6,9,12m |
77. Mosher et al., 2018 | ACT | - | Probable | Telephone | Education/Support | 23/24 | 2 arm RCT | 6w/8,12w post-baseline |
Behavioral Therapy | ||||||||
63,64. Berger et al., 2009a,b1 | BT | - | Potential | In Person (1:1) | Healthy Eating | 88/85 | 2 arm RCT | 1m/90,365d |
69. Gebara et al., 2019 | BBTI | Insomnia | Definite | In Person (1:1) and telephone sessions | Wait-list | 6/5 | 2 arm RCT | 4w/4w |
65. Germain et al., 2012 | BT,IRT | Nightmares + Poor Sleep Quality | Definite | In Person (1:1) and telephone sessions | Medication Arms (Placebo or Prazosin) | 17/ Ctrl.1 18, Ctrl.2 15 | 3 arm RCT | 8w/4m |
66. Germain et al., 2014 | BT | Insomnia | Definite | In Person (1:1) and telephone sessions | Sleep Education | 20/20 | 2 arm RCT | 4w/6m |
67. Johnson et al., 2016 | M-BET | Nocturia | Definite | In person or telephone (1:1) | Standard drug therapy for nocturia (α- blocker) and combined M-BET + α-blocker | 23 / Ctrl.1 25, Ctrl.2 24 | 3 arm RCT | 10w/12w post-baseline |
70. Lee et al., 2020 | BT | - | Potential | In Person (1) and telephone sessions | Attention control group (dietary strategies) | 25/26 | 2 arm RCT | 4w/1,2,3m |
68. Martin et al., 2017 | BT | - | Potential | - | Sleep Education | 21/21 | 2 arm RCT | 4w/4m |
Cognitive Behavioral Therapy | ||||||||
71. Brenes et al., 2016 | CBT | - | Probable | Telephone and workbook | Nondirective Supportive TherapyTelephone | 70/71 | 2 arm RCT | 11w/4,9,15m post-randomization |
72. Heapy et al., 2017 | IVR-CBT | - | Potential | Telephone | In-person CBT | 62/63 | 2 arm RCT | 10w/3,6,9m |
73. Stanley et al., 2016 | CBT | - | Probable | In person (1:1 first session) and patient preference (telephone or in person) | Community Resources and Emotional Support | 20/20 | 2 arm RCT | 3m/- |
74. Stanley et al., 2018 | CBT | - | Probable | Patient preference (telephone or in person) and telephone booster sessions | Enhanced Community Care with Resource Counseling | 70/64 | 2 arm RCT | 6m/9m |
Cognitive Behavioral Therapy for Insomnia | ||||||||
35. Alessi et al., 2016 | CBT-I | Insomnia | Definite | In person (smallgroups of 3–5 ppl or 1:1) | Sleep Education | 106/53 | 2 arm RCT | 6w/6,12m |
50. Cain et al., 2019 | CBT-I | Insomnia | Definite | In Person (Group) and online | Group prenatal visits | 27/26 | 2 arm RCT | 7w/- |
51. Chakravorty et al., 2019 | CBT-I | Insomnia | Definite | In Person (1:1) | Usual Care | 11/11 | 2 arm RCT | 8w/3,6m |
36. Drake et al., 2019 | CBT-I | Insomnia | Definite | In person | Sleep Hygiene, Sleep Restriction | 50/50,50 | 3 arm RCT | 6w/6m |
37. Edinger & Sampson, 2003 | CBT-I | Insomnia | Definite | In Person (1:1) and take-home audiocassettes and educational materials | Sleep Hygiene | 10/9 | 2 arm RCT | 2w/3m after treatment |
38. Edinger et al., 2009 | CBT-I | Insomnia | Definite | In Person (1:1) | Sleep Hygiene | 41/40 | 2 arm RCT | 8w/6m |
39. Epstein & Dirksen, 2007 | CBT-I | Insomnia | Definite | In Person (Group) and telephone sessions | Sleep Education and Hygiene | 34/38 | 2 arm RCT | 6w/2w posttreatment |
40. Fiorentino et al., 2010 | CBT-I | Insomnia | Definite | In Person (1:1) | Delayed Treatment | 6/8 | 2 arm RCT | 6w/6w posttreatment |
41. Fung et al., 2016 | CBT-I | Insomnia | Definite | In Person (1:1 and Group) | Sleep Education | - | 2 arm RCT | 6w/6m and 12m post-baseline |
52. Kalmbach et al., 2019 | CBT-I | Insomnia | Definite | In Person (1:1) | Sleep Hygiene, Sleep Restriction | 50/50 | 3 arm RCT | 6w/2w,6m |
42. Laurel Franklin et al., 2018 | Telephone based CBT-I | Insomnia | Definite | Telephone | In person CBT-I | 11/7 | 2 arm RCT | 8w/1,3m |
54. Manber et al., 2019 | CBT-I | Insomnia | Definite | In Person (1:1) | Modified Pseudo Desensitization Therapy for Insomnia | 89/90 | 2 arm RCT | 5w/- |
43. Margolies et al., 2013 | CBT-I, IRT | Insomnia | Definite | In Person (1:1) | Wait-list | 20/20 | 2 arm RCT | 6w/- |
44. Matthews et al., 2014 | CBT-I | Insomnia | Definite | In Person (1:1) | Behavioral Placebo Treatment | 30/26 | 2 arm RCT | 6w/3,6m |
45. McCurry et al., 2016 | Telephonebased CBT-I | Insomnia | Definite | Telephone (first session in person or telephone) | Menopause Education | 53/53 | 2 arm RCT | 8w/8,24w posttreatment |
46. Palesh et al., 2018 | BBT-CI | Insomnia | Definite | In person and telephone | Health Eating Education Learning | 37/37 | 2 arm RCT | 3–4w/1m |
47. Pigeon et al., 2017 | Brief CBT-I | Insomnia | Definite | In person and telephone | Sleep Hygiene | 13/14 | 2 arm RCT | 4w/3m posttreatment |
53. Pigeon et al., 2019 | Brief CBT-I | Insomnia | Definite | In Person (1:1) | Usual Care | 24/26 | 2 arm RCT | 6w/- |
48. Scogin et al., 2018 | Integrated CBTD+CBT-I | Insomnia | Definite | Video teleconferencing | Usual C are | 22/18 | 2 arm RCT | 10w/3m |
49. Ulmer et al., 2011 | CBT-I, IRT | Insomnia | Definite | In Person (1:1) | Usual Care | 12/9 | 2 arm RCT | 12w/10y |
Cognitive Processing Therapy | ||||||||
78. Galovski et al., 2016 | CPT,H | Insomnia | Definite | In Person (1:1) | Symptom monitoring control condition before beginning standard CPT | 44/48 | 2 arm RCT | 15w/3m posttreatment |
79. Galovski et al., 2009 | CPT | - | Probable | In Person (1:1) | Prolonged Exposure | 54/54 | 2 arm RCT | 6w/2w, 9m posttreatment |
80. Gutner et al., 2013 | CPT | - | Probable | In Person (1:1) and home practice assignments | Prolonged Exposure | 81/90 | 2 arm RCT | 6w/3,9m, longterm: 5 to 19y |
Complementary and Alternative Therapy | ||||||||
55. Innes & Selfe, 2012 | Y | RLS | Definite | In Person (Group) and home practice assignments | Educational film | 10/10 | 2 arm RCT | 8w/- |
56. Irwin et al., 2017 | TCC | Insomnia | Definite | In Person (Group) | CBT-I | 45/45 | 2 arm RCT | 3m/6,15m |
61. Jamison et al., 2019 | CART | - | Probable | In Person (1:1) | Wait-list | 47/33 | 2 arm RCT | 4w/1,6m |
58. Nakamura et al., 2011 | MBB | Poor sleep quality | Definite | - | Sleep Hygiene | 35/28 | 2 arm RCT | 2w/- |
57. Nakamura et al., 2017 | MBB | Poor sleep quality | Definite | In Person (Group) | Sleep Education | 33/27 | 2 arm RCT | 3w/3m |
59. Nidich et al., 2016 | TM | - | Potential | In Person (Group) | No-treatment | 90/91 | 2 arm RCT | 4m/4m |
62. Porter et al., 2019 | Y | - | Potential | In Person (1:1) | Social Support Group | 43/20 | 2 arm RCT | 8w/6m |
60. Stoerkel et al., 2018 | SCT | - | Potential | Audio-files | Usual Care | 51/49 | 2 arm RCT | 2w/2w |
Elective Therapy | ||||||||
85. Alschuler et al., 2018 | RI | - | Potential | Teleconference for groups and take-home materials | Wait-list | 12/16 | 2 arm RCT | 6w |
86. Church et al., 2016 | TAU,EFT | - | Probable | In Person (1:1) | Treatment as usual wait-list | 12/9 | 2 arm RCT | 6m/3,6m |
87. Kahn et al., 2016 | MR | - | Potential | Internet and mobile | MR + PREP for Strong Bonds program, PREP only, waitlist | 40/MR+PREP 40; PREP 40; Waitlist Control 40 | 4 arm RCT | 16w/8,16 |
Imagery Rehearsal Therapy | ||||||||
89. Cook et al., 2010 | IRT | Nightmares+ Poor sleep quality | Definite | In Person (Group) | Sleep and Nightmare Management Treatment | 61/63 | 2 arm RCT | 6w/1,3,6m |
90. Harb et al., 2019 | IRT, CBT-I | Nightmares + Poor sleep quality | Definite | In Person (1:1) | CBT-I | 53/55 | 2 arm RCT | 6w3,6m |
88. Krakow et al., 2001 | IRT | Nightmares + Insomnia | Definite | In Person (Group) | Wait-list | 88/80 | 2 arm RCT | 6w/3,6m |
Mindfulness-based Stress Reduction | ||||||||
81. Cash et al., 2015 | MBSR | - | Potential | In Person (Group) and home practice assignments | Wait-list | 51/40 | 2 arm RCT | 8w/2m |
82. Lengacher et al., 2015 | MBSR | - | Potential | - | Usual Care | 38/41 | 2 arm RCT | 6w/12w |
83. Shapiro et al., 2003 | MBSR | - | Potential | In Person (Group) | Stress management | 31/32 | 2 arm RCT | 6w/3,9m |
84. Witek Janusek et al., 2019 | MBSR | - | Potential | In Person (Group) | Active Control | 84/80 | 2 arm RCT | 8w/1,6m |
Problem-solving Therapy | ||||||||
91. Bedford et al., 2018 | ePST | - | Potential | Online | Minimal contact | 12/12 | 2 arm RCT | 6w/12 following the initial treatment session |
Note: Determination refers to the likelihood of the sleep disorder or disturbance based on review of the participant inclusion and exclusion criteria. Reference number precedes author name in Article column. ACT=Acceptance and Commitment Therapy; BBT-CI=Brief Behavioral Therapy for Cancer-Related Insomnia; BT=Behavioral Therapy; BTI-MV=Brief Behavioral Treatment of Insomnia; CBT=Cognitive Behavioral Therapy; CBT-I=Cognitive Behavioral Therapy for Insomnia; CPT=Cognitive Processing Therapy; EFT=Clinical Emotional Freedom Techniques; ePST=computer guided Problem-Solving Treatment; H=Hypnosis; IRT=Imagery Rehearsal Therapy; Integrated CBT-D+CBT-I= Integrated CBT (CBT for depression and CBT for insomnia); IVR-CBT=Interactive voice response-based cognitive behavioral therapy; MBB=Mind-body Bridging; M-BET=Multicomponent behavioral combined with exercise therapy; MBSR=Mindfulness-based stress reduction; MR=Mission Reconnect program; RI=Resilience intervention; SCT=Self-care toolkit; TAU=Treatment as usual ; TCC=Tai Chi Chih; TM=Transcendental Meditation; VTC-ACT=Video teleconferencing Acceptance and Commitment Therapy; Y=Yoga.
Definite= directly assessed for and confirmed the existence of a sleep disorder or sleep disturbance and included this in the inclusion criteria; Probable=directly assessed for any sleep disturbance but did not include endorsement of a sleep disturbance as part of the inclusion criteria. Potential= sleep did not assess for a sleep disturbance but based on the scientific literature would likely have a sleep disturbance concomitant with the co-morbid health or mental health condition.
Values reported are from Berger et al., 2009b.