Table 9.

Comparison of Corridors-3D (three-hour slices) against Clustering-3D and against a combination of both the approaches on the small instances with short TWs

	Corridors-3D	Clustering-3D	Both
OF	45.79	49.02	45.23
LB	45.79	49.02	45.23
TIME_BUND	0.13	60.49	59.42
TIME_BID	0.41	0.95	18.21
TIME_SOL	3.07	7.11	3.35
TIME_TOT	3.62	68.55	80.98
# BUNDLES	50.30	40.30	72.80
# BIDS	179.6	154.60	249.10
# OD	7.00	6.90	7.00
# SERVED by ODs	11.30	8.50	11.90