Skip to main content
. 2024 Aug 9;103(12):2348–2372. doi: 10.1111/aogs.14934

TABLE 3.

Inclusion and exclusion criteria.

Author, year Inclusion Exclusion
Country

Acharya, 2002

UK

  • All patients with a confirmed first‐trimester missed miscarriage who chose to undergo expectant management

Banerjee, 2013

UK

  • Ultrasound confirmed missed miscarriage (crown‐rump length <6 mm with no fetal heart beat) or early fetal demise (gestational sac diameter >20 mm without fetal pole or yolk sac)

  • Upper limit for gestational age was 12 weeks by menstrual date or by ultrasound scan

  • If active vaginal bleeding

  • Previously received medical management for miscarriage in the current pregnancy

Casikar, 2013

Australia

  • Women diagnosed with incomplete, missed, and empty sac miscarriage were included

  • An incomplete miscarriage was defined as the presence of heterogeneous tissue seen on ultrasound within the uterine cavity and distorting the endometrial midline echo

  • Missed miscarriage was defined as the presence of a crown‐rump length (CRL) </=6 mm with absent fetal heart activity seen on ultrasound

  • An empty sac was defined as a gestational sac diameter >20 mm with no visible CRL seen on ultrasound

  • Severe vaginal hemorrhage with hemodynamic instability,

  • Infection

  • Complete miscarriage diagnosed at the first scan (in the context of a previously documented intrauterine pregnancy)

  • Molar pregnancy

  • Missed miscarriage diagnosed at the nuchal translucency (NT) scan

  • Missed miscarriage when the crown‐rump length (CRL) was 3 weeks smaller than the gestational age based on the last menstrual period (LMP)

Casikar, 2013

Australia

  • Women diagnosed with incomplete, missed, and empty sac miscarriage were included

  • An incomplete miscarriage was defined as the presence of heterogeneous tissue seen on ultrasound within the uterine cavity and distorting the endometrial midline echo

  • Missed miscarriage was defined as the presence of a crown‐rump length (CRL) </=6 mm with absent fetal heart activity seen on ultrasound

  • An empty sac was defined as a gestational sac diameter >20 mm with no visible CRL seen on ultrasound

  • Severe vaginal hemorrhage with hemodynamic instability

  • Infection

  • Complete miscarriage diagnosed at the first scan (in the context of a previously documented intrauterine pregnancy)

  • Molar pregnancy

  • Missed miscarriage diagnosed at the nuchal translucency (NT) scan

  • Missed miscarriage when the crown‐rump length (CRL) was 3 weeks smaller than the gestational age based on the last menstrual period (LMP)

Casikar, 2010

Australia

  • Women diagnosed with incomplete, missed, and empty sac miscarriage were included

  • An incomplete miscarriage was defined as the presence of heterogeneous tissue seen on ultrasound within the uterine cavity and distorting the endometrial midline echo

  • Missed miscarriage was defined as the presence of a crown‐rump length (CRL) </=6 mm with absent fetal heart activity seen on ultrasound

  • An empty sac was defined as a gestational sac diameter >20 mm with no visible CRL seen on ultrasound

  • Severe vaginal hemorrhage with hemodynamic instability,

  • Infection

  • Complete miscarriage diagnosed at the first scan (in the context of a previously documented intrauterine pregnancy)

  • Molar pregnancy

  • Missed miscarriage diagnosed at the nuchal translucency (NT) scan

  • Missed miscarriage when the crown‐rump length (CRL) was 3 weeks smaller than the gestational age based on the last menstrual period (LMP)

Casikar, 2012

Australia

  • Diagnosis of incomplete miscarriage: defined by the presence of a measurable focus of hyperechoic material within the endometrial cavity using two‐dimensional (2D) greyscale TVS

  • Hemodynamic stability

  • Absence of infection

  • Severe vaginal hemorrhage or hemodynamic instability

  • Signs of infection: temperature, tachycardia, offensive vaginal loss and lower abdominal tenderness

Creinin, 2006

USA

  • Women who had an anembryonic gestation or embryonic/fetal demise were eligible for inclusion if they had an ultrasound examination demonstrating an embryonic pole or crown‐rump length between 5 and 40 mm without cardiac activity, an anembryonic gestational sac with a mean diameter between 16 and 45 mm, growth of gestational sac less than 2 mm over 5 days or less than 3 mm over 7 days, or an increase in human chorionic gonadotropin by less than 15% over 2 days with a yolk sac visualized by ultrasound examination
  • Women who had incomplete or inevitable miscarriages were also included
  • Incomplete spontaneous miscarriage was defined as passage of some products of conception with the residual anterior–posterior endometrial lining greater than 30 mm by transvaginal ultrasonography and uterine size less than 13 weeks. This cut‐off was based on evidence from prior studies of women treated with misoprostol for medical miscarriage or early pregnancy failure
  • Inevitable miscarriage was defined as an intrauterine gestational sac less than 45 mm or embryonic pole less than 40 mm and an open internal cervical os to digital examination with active vaginal bleeding
Women were excluded from the primary study if they were:
  • anemic (hemoglobin level below 9.5 mg/dL)

  • hemodynamically unstable

  • history of a clotting disorder

  • using anticoagulants

  • allergic to prostaglandins or nonsteroidal anti‐inflammatory drugs

  • previously undergone surgical or medical miscarriage, either self‐induced or by other physicians during the current pregnancy

Elson, 2005

UK

  • A diagnosis of missed miscarriage was made if the size of gestational sac was >20 mm in diameter with no visible embryo; if the fetal crown–rump length was >5 mm with no detectable fetal heart rate; or if the gestational sac had failed to develop on a follow‐up scan >6 days after the initial examination

  • An incomplete miscarriage was diagnosed in women with a history of bleeding, who had no visible gestational sac on ultrasound scan, but there was clear evidence of retained trophoblast tissue within the uterine cavity

  • All clinically stable women with history of mild lower abdominal pain and bleeding and a conclusive ultrasound diagnosis of miscarriage were offered expectant management

Fernlund, 2020

Sweden

  • ≥18 years old
  • understanding written and spoken Swedish
  • hemoglobin concentration >80 g/L
  • no contraindications to misoprostol treatment
  • fulfilling ultrasound criteria of anembryonic or embryonic miscarriage
  • fetal crown‐rump‐length ≤33 mm
  • Women with heavy bleeding needing urgent surgical evacuation of the uterine cavity, as judged clinically, were not eligible

Grewal, 2019

UK

  • Women presented after miscarriage with the following clinical scenarios: incomplete miscarriage (n = 23), failed medical management of miscarriage with RPOC (n = 8) and failed surgical management of miscarriage (n = 9)

  • EMV was defined as a hypervascular area within the myometrium, detected on transvaginal color Doppler ultrasonography with a PSV on pulsed Doppler of ≥20 cm/s, within the collection of vessels

Guedes‐Martins, Portugal

2015

  • Cases of early pregnancy loss, defined as intrauterine pregnancy with reproducible evidence of lost fetal heart activity and/or the lack of increased crown–rump length over one week or the persisting presence of an empty sac at less than 12 weeks of gestation

  • Clinically stable women

  • Ectopic pregnancy

  • Complete or incomplete pregnancy

  • Known allergy to prostaglandins or NSAIDs

  • Multiple gestation

  • Heavy vaginal bleeding

  • Hemodynamic instability

  • Blood clotting problems or current treatment with anticoagulants

  • Hb <10

  • Body temperature >38 degrees

  • CRL >12 weeks gestation

  • Prostaglandin contraindications, including uncontrolled blood pressure, mitral stenosis, severe asthma, or glaucoma

Hamel, 2022

Netherlands

  • Women aged 16 years or older

  • Diagnosed with a non‐viable intrauterine pregnancy between 6 and 14 weeks of gestational age

  • Women who were clinically unfit for medical management

  • Women with a miscarriage in progress (defined as increasing or heavy vaginal bleeding and/or abdominal cramping) or with an incomplete miscarriage

Lavecchia, 2015

Canada

  • ED discharge prescription for medical management

  • Women whose medical charts lacked their sonograms

Luise, 2002

UK

(BMJ)

  • Women with retained products of conception opting for expectant management

  • Molar pregnancy

Luise, 2002

UK

(UOG)

  • All women with a spontaneous, incomplete miscarriage before the 13th week of gestation

  • Molar pregnancy

Lusink, 2018

Australia

  • The crown rump length should be ≤25 mm and the MGSD ≤50 mm

  • The woman should have no medical contraindications to misoprostol and have adequate social support at home

  • Received mifepristone

  • Protocol violations

  • Incomplete records

Sairam, 2001

UK

  • Incomplete miscarriage was diagnosed when the endometrial thickness was more than 5 mm with loss of midline echo suggestive of retained products.

  • Missed miscarriage was diagnosed when either the mean diameter of the empty gestation sac was ≥20 mm (anembryonic gestation) or when the crown rump length was ≥7 mm without a detectable heart beat (missed miscarriage)

  • Heavy vaginal bleeding
  • Severe abdominal pain
  • Clinical evidence of intrauterine infection
  • Suspected molar/ectopic pregnancy
  • Other medical complications
  • Gestation age greater than 14 weeks

Sajan, 2020

India

  • Anembryonic pregnancy: Gestational sac mean diameter of at least 25 mm with no embryonic/extra embryonic structures present
  • Early fetal demise (EFD): CRL of at least 7 mm with no cardiac activity, or no change in size on weekly serial scanning
  • Incomplete miscarriage: Disrupted endometrial echo measuring more than 15 mm measured in the anteroposterior plane, with the presence of heterogeneous and irregular tissues
  • Gestational age more than13 weeks
  • Severe vaginal bleeding
  • Severe abdominal pain
  • Hemodynamic instability at presentation
  • Fever
  • Chronic illness

Schreiber, 2015

USA

  • Women presenting with first trimester pregnancy failure (anembryonic pregnancy, embryonic demise, incomplete miscarriage, and inevitable miscarriage)

Schwarzler, 1999

UK

  • Pregnancies with an estimated gestation age of <13 weeks from the last menstrual period (LMP) were included.

  • All women included in the study were symptomatic and had reported vaginal bleeding and/or abdominal pain.

  • Those shown by ultrasonography to have either a missed miscarriage or an anembryonic pregnancy

  • Severe hemorrhage or pain

  • Pyrexia above 37.5°C

  • Severe asthma

  • Hemolytic disease or blood dyscrasias

  • Current anticoagulation or systemic corticosteroid treatment

  • Twin or higher order pregnancy

  • Smoker aged over 35

  • Inability to understand written English

Trinder, 2006

UK

  • Women with a pregnancy of less than 13 weeks' gestation

  • Diagnosed as having either an incomplete miscarriage (defined an incomplete miscarriage as areas of mixed echogenicity within the uterine cavity with or without a disordered gestation sac) or early fetal/embryonic demise (defined early embryonic demise as an intact gestation sac of greater than 20 mm mean diameter with no other internal structures and early fetal demise as a fetus of over 6 mm crown rump length with no heart activity on transvaginal ultrasound scan)

Sonalkar, 2021

USA

  • Women 18 years and older

  • Diagnosed with a nonviable intrauterine pregnancy (anembryonic gestation or embryonic/fetal demise)

  • Between 5 and 12 weeks gestation

  • Diagnosis: incomplete or inevitable miscarriage

  • Women clinically ineligible for EPL medical management

Vejborg, 2007

Denmark

Group A missed miscarriage: a foetus of at least 6 mm (crown rump length; CRL) without cardiac activity (Group A1) or a foetus <6 mm and either no growth or development of cardiac activity over 1 week or declining hCG values (Group A2) or

Group B_anembryonic pregnancy: either an empty gestational sac of at least 18 mm (Group B1) or an empty gestational sac of <18 mm with no growth over at least 7 days or a declining hCG value (Group B2)

  • Twin pregnancies

Wada, 2021

Japan

  • Patients who had spontaneously or artificially aborted before 22 weeks of gestation

  • RPOC diagnosis was made by ultrasound as follows: (1) an intrauterine high‐echoic or heterogenetic lesion adjacent to the myometrium, (2) a hypervascular lesion in the uterine cavity

Abbreviations: CRL, crown rump length; ED, emergency department; EFD, early fetal demise; EMV, enhanced myometrial vascularity; EPL, early pregnancy loss; Hb, hemoglobin; LMP, last menstrual period; MSGD, mean gestational sac diameter; NSAID, non‐steroidal anti inflammatory drug; NT, nuchal translucency; PSV, peak systolic velocity; RPOC, retained products of conception; TVS, transvaginal scan.