Skip to main content
. 2024 Oct 29;15(12):100329. doi: 10.1016/j.advnut.2024.100329

TABLE 1.

Health benefit examples of established, novel, and emerging prebiotics in humans.

Prebiotic type Established/novel/emerging1 Health effect/benefit Dosage (per day) and formulation Outcome Reference Jadad score and limitations
Acacia gum Established Glycemia 20 g powder mixed with hot water, tea, milk, or with food Lowers fasting blood glucose response and increases satiety [70] 3.5; none reported
Dyslipidemia 30 mg tablets Reduces cholesterol by 26%, LDL by 31%, and triglycerides by 38% [71] 1; none reported
Diabetes 30 g powder Improves fasting and postprandial plasma glucose, postprandial insulin, glycosylated hemoglobin (HbA1c), total cholesterol, and triglycerides [72] 5; study design flaw
10 g powder mixed into lukewarm water [73] 1; none reported
Irritable bowel syndrome 10 g sachets mixed in orange juice Significant improvement in stool frequency [74] 5
  • Statistical power slightly underpowered

  • Study design flaw short study duration

  • Data analysis flaw no subgroup analysis or stratification

Amino acids Emerging Obesity Two 15-g packs dissolved in water Reduces levels of Bacillota (previously Firmicutes) and Actinomycetota (previously Actinobacteria) [66] 3; none reported
Fructo-oligosaccharides Established Crohn disease 15 g sachets dissolved in water Increases fecal bifidobacterial concentrations and mucosal dendritic cell function [28] 0; none reported
Constipation 6, 9, or 12 g in infant formula Reduces bowel transit time and increases counts of Bifidobacterium spp. [75] 5
  • Sample size insufficient

  • Research design limitation unexpected effect of secondary intervention

Galactooligosaccharides Established Behavioral changes 5.5 g powder mixed with water or food Increases Bifidobacterium levels [76] 2
  • Study design flaw appetite was not measured

Irritable bowel syndrome 3.5 g & 7 g powder in sachets Decreases flatulence, bloating and abdominal pain, improves stool consistency [29] 4.5; none reported
Immunity 5.5 g powder in sachets Improves cytokine responses, natural killer cell activity and phagocytosis [77,78] 4; none reported
4; none reported
Hyperpnea-induced bronchoconstriction 5.5 g Bimuno galactooligosaccharide supplement Reduced airway inflammation markers [79] 5; none reported
Lactose intolerance 1.5–15 g in water Improves lactose digestion and reduces abdominal pain [80] 5; none reported
Human milk oligosaccharides (HMOs) Established Irritable bowel disease 5 or 10 g supplement Gut microbiome modulation and mucosal response [81] 5
  • Subject data limitation

Inulin Established Bone mineralization 8 g mixed with calcium-fortified orange juice Enhances calcium absorption and whole-body bone mineral content and density [82] 5; none reported
Constipation 4 g mixed in a dairy product Improves stool consistency [83] 5; none reported
ω-3 Fatty acids Novel Cardiovascular markers 500 mg (165 mg EPA, 110 mg DHA, in gelatin capsules) Gut microbiome modulation and short-chain fatty acid (SCFA) production [43] 2
  • No placebo arm

  • Limited population mostly female subjects

  • Data collection techniques

Stress 56 g of walnuts Improves gut microbiome diversity [33] 3
  • Potential sex bias in data analysis

  • No blinding

  • Differences in data collection conditions

Polyphenols Novel Diabetes 333 mg strawberry cranberry polyphenols (SCP) in a beverage Improves insulin sensitivity [84] 4; none reported
Arterial stiffness 105.9 mg polyphenols from aronia berry capsules Increases gut microbial richness and SCFA production [85] 4
  • Population generalizability

  • Impact limitation no cause-effect relationship can be concluded

Hypertension 500 mg polyphenolic blend (175 mg Hibiscus sabdariffa and 325 mg Lippia citriodora) Reduce daytime parameters of blood pressure [86] 4
  • Instrument limitations

Resistant dextrin (RD) Novel Type 2 diabetes 10 g RD (NUTRIOSE 06FM) powder supplement Decreases fasting insulin, homeostasis model assessment of insulin resistance, quantitative insulin sensitivity check index, IL-6, TNF-α, endotoxin, and malondialdehyde [87] 5
  • Sample size

  • Short intervention duration

  • Study design flaw gut or fecal microbiota were not assessed, nor were serum SCFA and nonesterified fatty acid levels

Resistant starch (RS) Established Glycemia RS from high amylose corn (Hi-maize 260) and raw potato starch Increases insulin sensitivity [[88], [89], [90]] 5
  • Study size small

  • Study design flaw very restrictive exclusion criteria

4
  • Sample size small

  • Study design flaw demanding study regimen

4
  • Study technique/design flaw dietary fiber intake was not assessed and multiple relevant biomarkers were not measured.

Type 2 diabetes 4.5 g RS from green banana Decreases fasting glucose and HbA1c [91] 3
  • Study technique/design flaw

Cancer 30 g RS (1:1 blend of Novelose 240 and Novelose 330) Substantial protective effects against noncolorectal cancers in patients with lynch syndrome [92] 4; none reported
Hypertension 40 g acetylated and butyrylated high amylose maize starch (HAMSAB) supplement Increases SCFA production and lowers blood pressure [93] 5
  • Sample size

  • Lack of long-term follow-up

  • Differences in the intervention vs. control diets

Metabolic syndrome 20 g of green banana flour dissolved in milk, yogurt, or juice Reduces blood pressure and fasting glucose [94] 1; none reported
Constipation 20 g Hi-maize RS2 high amylose corn starch delivered in biscuits Constipation improved [95] 4
  • Sample size small

  • The study population had a large age difference

  • Study design flaw short study duration

Xylans Established Obesity Females: 25 g fermentable corn bran arabinoxylan
Males: 35 g fermentable corn bran arabinoxylan
Increases propionate and Bifidobacterium longum. Enhances satiety and decreases HOMA-IR [26,96,97] 4.5
  • Sample size

  • Study technique/design flaw

Overweight and obesity 7.5 or 15 g arabinoxylan Influences gene transcription, microbial diversity, fecal pH, and fecal SCFA concentrations [98] 5
  • Study design flaw fecal SCFAs assessed and not intestinal SCFAs

  • Hepatic parameters not tested

  • Diet and exercise were not controlled

Metabolic syndrome 15 g arabinoxylan supplement Improves postprandial metabolic responses including serum glucose, insulin, and triglycerides [27] 2.5
  • Sample size

1

Established: introduced with the discovery of prebiotics category or shortly after and have been extensively studied for their prebiotic effect. Novel: discovered recently and is increasingly researched as a prebiotic. Emerging: discovered recently and research is underway for its potential as a prebiotic.