Table 1.
Study | Year | Country | Study design | Subjects, n | Population | Primary diagnosis | Operative location | Irrigation techniques and Volumes | ||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
E | C | E | C | |||||||
Cheng et al. (27) | 2005 | China | RCT | 208 | 206 | Adult | Varied | Varied | 0.35% P-I, 2L | Normal saline, 2L |
Chang et al. (28) | 2006 | China | RCT | 120 | 124 | Adult | LIS | LS | 0.35% P-I , 2LC: | Normal saline, 2L |
Tomov et al. (29) | 2015 | USA | RCS | 1173 | 1252 | Adult | Varied | Varied | 0.3% P-I , N/A | N/A |
van Herwijnen et al. (30) | 2016 | UK | RCS | 71 | 15 | Pediatric | Scoliosis | Varied | 1% P-I , 6L | Saline with 80 mg gentamicin, 7L |
De Luna et al. (31) | 2017 | Italy | RCT | 25 | 25 | Adult | Scoliosis | Varied | 3% P-I , 2L | Normal saline, 2L |
Fei et al. (32) | 2017 | China | RCT | 40 | 40 | Adult | PLID | Lumbar | 0.1% P-I , 0.2L | Normal saline, N/A |
Yamada et al. (33) | 2018 | Japan | RCS | 301 | 741 | Adult | N/A | Varied | 0.38% P-I , 0.52L | Normal saline, N/A |
Onishi et al. (34) | 2019 | Japan | RCS | 177 | 146 | Adult | N/A | Varied | 1% P-I , N/A | Normal saline, N/A |
Lemans et al. (35) | 2019 | Netherlands | RCS | 217 | 257 | Adult | N/A | Varied | 500mL P-I solution; concentration: 1.3g/L | Normal saline, N/A |
Sigari et al. (36) | 2020 | Germany | RCT | 468 | 468 | Adult | Scoliosis, DD | Varied | 3% P-I , N/A | Normal saline, N/A |
Carballo Cuello et al. (37) | 2021 | USA | RCS | 144 | 134 | Adult | Varied | Lumbar | 0.35% P-I , 1L | Normal saline, 1L |
Roberto et al. (38) | 2021 | USA | RCS | 13 | 88 | Pediatric | Spinal deformity | Varied | 3.5% w/v P-I , N/A | No irrigation techniques |
Lin et al. (39) | 2022 | China | RCS | 120 | 124 | Adult | Varied | Lumbar | 0.35% P-I , 1L | Normal saline, N/A |
Inojie et al. (40) | 2023 | Nigeria | RCT | 40 | 40 | Adult | N/A | Varied | 0.35% P-I , 1L | 1L saline with 80 mg gentamicin |
C, Controlled group; DD, degenerative diseases; E, Experimental group; LIS, lumbar instability; LS, lumbosacral; PLID, prolapsed lumbar intervertebral discs; P-I, povidone-iodine; RCS, Retrospective cohort study; RCT, randomized controlled trial.