Skip to main content

Table 1.

General characteristics of the included literature.

Study Year Country Study design Subjects, n Population Primary diagnosis Operative location Irrigation techniques and Volumes
E C E C
Cheng et al. (27) 2005 China RCT 208 206 Adult Varied Varied 0.35% P-I, 2L Normal saline, 2L
Chang et al. (28) 2006 China RCT 120 124 Adult LIS LS 0.35% P-I , 2LC: Normal saline, 2L
Tomov et al. (29) 2015 USA RCS 1173 1252 Adult Varied Varied 0.3% P-I , N/A N/A
van Herwijnen et al. (30) 2016 UK RCS 71 15 Pediatric Scoliosis Varied 1% P-I , 6L Saline with 80 mg gentamicin, 7L
De Luna et al. (31) 2017 Italy RCT 25 25 Adult Scoliosis Varied 3% P-I , 2L Normal saline, 2L
Fei et al. (32) 2017 China RCT 40 40 Adult PLID Lumbar 0.1% P-I , 0.2L Normal saline, N/A
Yamada et al. (33) 2018 Japan RCS 301 741 Adult N/A Varied 0.38% P-I , 0.52L Normal saline, N/A
Onishi et al. (34) 2019 Japan RCS 177 146 Adult N/A Varied 1% P-I , N/A Normal saline, N/A
Lemans et al. (35) 2019 Netherlands RCS 217 257 Adult N/A Varied 500mL P-I solution; concentration: 1.3g/L Normal saline, N/A
Sigari et al. (36) 2020 Germany RCT 468 468 Adult Scoliosis, DD Varied 3% P-I , N/A Normal saline, N/A
Carballo Cuello et al. (37) 2021 USA RCS 144 134 Adult Varied Lumbar 0.35% P-I , 1L Normal saline, 1L
Roberto et al. (38) 2021 USA RCS 13 88 Pediatric Spinal deformity Varied 3.5% w/v P-I , N/A No irrigation techniques
Lin et al. (39) 2022 China RCS 120 124 Adult Varied Lumbar 0.35% P-I , 1L Normal saline, N/A
Inojie et al. (40) 2023 Nigeria RCT 40 40 Adult N/A Varied 0.35% P-I , 1L 1L saline with 80 mg gentamicin

C, Controlled group; DD, degenerative diseases; E, Experimental group; LIS, lumbar instability; LS, lumbosacral; PLID, prolapsed lumbar intervertebral discs; P-I, povidone-iodine; RCS, Retrospective cohort study; RCT, randomized controlled trial.