Table 2.
Study | Design | Participant | Experimental | Control | Result |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Norambuena et al. (2021) [29] | PPS 5 weeks |
Elite athletes Sports: Judo SS: 10 EG: 10; 8 B/2 G; Age: 15.4 ± 2.8yr; |
IV: Suspension-training INT: Intensity gradually increased Freq: 3/week Time: 20min |
No | Single-leg horizontal jumping (right leg↑; left leg↑), Sorensen↑, SAR↑, Y balance (arm↑; leg↑). Grip strength ∼; prone instability test performance ∼; |
Baron et al. (2020) [30] | PPS 12 weeks |
Elite athletes Sports: Football SS: 20 EG: 20 B; Age: 16.8 ± 0.6yr; |
IV: Functional training Time: 70–90min |
No | Functional state (FMS1↑, FMS2↑, FMS3↑); Speed and acceleration Tests (0–5m ∼, 5–20m↑, 10–30m↑, 0–30m↑); Velocity↑. |
Katsanis et al. (2021) [31] | PPS 8 weeks |
Ordinary children SS: 321; 158 B/163 G; Age: 16.54 ± 0.91yr; EG: 154; 76 B/78 G; Age: 16.52 ± 0.88yr; CG: 167; 82 B/85 G; Age: 16.56 ± 0.94yr; |
IV: Suspension-training INT: Increased by 50 %/2weeks. Freq: 2/week Time: 45min |
IV: Regular PE class Freq: 2/week Time: 45min |
In EG (SLJ↑ p < 0.001, Sit-ups for 30 s↑ p < 0.001, push-up↑ p < 0.001, handgrip↑ p < 0.001); in CG ∼. In EG, increased in motivation to participate in the PE class |
Laurent et al. (2018) [32] | RCTs 6 weeks |
Ordinary children SS: 28; 46 % B/54 % G; Age: 9.3 ± 1.5yr; EG: 17; 58.5 % B/41.5 % G; Age: 9.82 ± 1.22yr; CG: 11; 27.3 % B/72.7 % G Age: 8.54 ± 1.57yr; |
IV: Suspension training Freq:2/week Time: 60min |
IV: Regular activities Freq: 2/week Time: 60min |
Pull-Up performance↑(P = 0.01) Lift↑, and FMS score↑, relative to CG. skill-related fitness (SLJ ∼, SR ∼) |
Labib (2014) [33] | PPS 10 weeks |
Ordinary athletes Sports: Handball SS: 20 G EG: 10 G; Age: 13 ± 1.5yr; Training experience 3 ± 0.7yr CG: 10 G; Age: 14 ± 1.8yr; Training experience 3 ± 0.8yr |
IV: Functional training Freq: 3/week Time: 60min |
IV: Normal training Freq: 3/week Time: 60min |
Standing Stork Test↑, DB↑, Static strength↑ and Running shoot↑. Both Handgrip Strength↑ and Static strength test↑ improved in two group, but No Significant Difference between them. |
Yildiz et al. (2018) [34] | PPS 8 weeks |
Ordinary athletes Sports: Tennis SS: 28 B; Age: 9.6 ± 0.7yr; Training experience 3.1 ± 1.3yr EG1: 10 B EG2: 10 B CG: 8 B |
EG1 IV: Functional training Freq:3/week Time: 65–75min EG2 IV: Traditional training Freq: 3/week Time: 65–75min |
IV: Normal tennis training Freq: 3/week Time: 65–70min |
In CG, FMS scores↓ and other parameters ∼. In EG1, DB↑ FMS↓ and other parameters ∼. In EG2, all parameters ↑, (the vertical jump performances↑, flexibility↑, agility↑, DB↑, SB↑, FMS data↑), between groups showed a significant difference, no big difference for right left DB. |
Song et al. (2014) [35] | PPS 16 weeks |
Elite athletes Sports: Baseball SS: 62 B EG: 31 B; Age: 17.0 ± 1.06yr; CG: 31 B; Age: 16.62 ± 0.94yr; |
IV: Functional Screen training INT: NM Freq: 3 T/week Time: NM |
IV: Traditional training Freq: 3/week Time: NM |
Strength↑ and flexibility↑, hand grip strength↑ 12 %, bench-press↑ 9 % |
Liao et al. (2017) [36] | RCTs 12 weeks |
Ordinary children SS: 144 G; Age: 12.47 ± 0.57yr EG: 72 G; CG: 72 G; |
IV: Functional strength training INT: a moderate intensity Freq: 3/week Time: 45min |
IV: Traditional strength training INT: a moderate intensity Freq: 3/week Time: 45min |
FMS data↑, deep squat↑, turn stability↑, muscular strength↑, flexibility↑ and power↑, FST is better at improving the quality of movement Curl-ups, SAR and SLJ. |
Marta et al. (2019) [37] | RCTs 8 weeks |
Prepubescent children SS: 57 B EG1: 19 B; Age: 10.71 ± 0.43yr EG2: 20 B; Age: 10.92 ± 0.45yr CG: 18 B; Age: 10.81 ± 0.57yr |
EG1 IV: Resistance training INT: low to moderate Freq: 2/week Time: 45min EG2 IV: Suspension training INT: low to moderate Freq: 2/week Time: 45min |
IV: Regular PE course INT: low to moderate Freq: 2/week Time: 45min |
1-kg ball throw large↑ (P < 0.001, 2p = 0.463), 3-kg ball throw medium↑ (P < 0.001, 2p = 0.395), and time-at-20m test small ES. no big difference between in the CVJ or the SLJ. but in ST training the CVJ↑, SLJ↑. |
Eather et al. (2016) [38] | RCTs 8 weeks |
Ordinary children SS: 96; 46 B/50 G; Age: 15.4 ± 0.5yr; EG: 51 CG: 45 |
IV: CrossFit Teens Freq: 2/week Time: 60min |
IV: Regular PE class Freq: 2/week Time: 60min |
SAR↑ (+3.0 cm, P < 0.001), SLJ↑ (+0.1 m.021) and SR (+10.3laps, P = 0.019) SAR↑ Curl-up test↑, push-up ↑, SLJ↑ grip strength↑, SR test ↑ |
Carvutto et al. (2021) [39] | RCTs 8 weeks |
Ordinary children Sports: Score SS: 28 B; Age: 12.6 ± 8.8; EG: 14 B CG: 14 B |
IV: High-intensity functional training INT: High-intensity Freq: 3/week Time: Lasts 90 min |
IV: Traditional training based on technical and tactical abilities. Freq: 3/week Time: 90min |
Group x Time-agility ↑ no significant in sprint performance |
Baron et al. (2020) [51] | PPS 12 weeks |
PT: Elite athletes Sports: Football SS: 20 B EG: 20 B; Age: 16.8 ± 0.6yr; |
IV: Functional training Time: 70–85min |
No | Functional state↑; FMS↑, FMS↑, FMS3↑; CM, power and height↑ CMJ without swing power and height↑, SQUAT Jump power and height↑ |
Bonney et al. (2019) [40] | RCTs 14 weeks |
PT: Obesity SS: 52 G EG: 26 G Age: 14.4 ± 0.9yr CG: 26 G Age: 14.3 ± 0.8yr |
IV: Task-oriented functional training Freq: 1/week Time: 45min |
IV: Wii Fit intervention Freq: 1/week Time: 45min |
Aerobic↑, coordination↑, knee extensors strength↑, dorsiflexors↑, plantar flexors↑, anaerobic↑ in both groups. lower extremity functional strength↑, manual dexterity↑, balance↑ in both groups. These changes were not different between groups. |
Gorter et al. (2009) [17] | PPS 9 weeks |
Cerebral Palsy SS: 13; 8 B/5 G EG: 13; 8 B/5 G; Age: 9.9 ± 1.15yr normal intelligence (n = 1), mild mental retardation (n = 12). CP and at GMFCS level 1 (n = 12) or level 2 (n = 1). |
IV: Functional physical training Freq: 1/week Time: 30min |
No | Aerobic Endurance HR6↓ T max↑; walking distance and velocity ↑, Ambulation TUDS Seconds↓. VO2max ↑ 9 %, max treadmill time↑ 23 %, walking distance ↑ 7 %, ambulation ↑ 21 %. |
Mikołajczyk et al. (2014) [50] | PPS 12 weeks |
Intellectual disability SS: 34; 28 B/6 G; moderate ID, mean IQ 45.1 ± 3.3; Age: 15.06 ± 0.9yr; EG: 17; CG: 17; |
IV: Obligatory physical education classes + original dual-task functional training Freq: 3/week Time: 45min |
IV: Regular PE class Freq: 2/week Time: 45min |
Balance↑ (eyes open conditions, eyes closed conditions), path length of the center of pressure (eyes open conditions↓ significant shortening length by 28 %, eyes closed conditions↓, significant shortening 36 %). |
Emara et al. (2016) [42] | RCTs 12 weeks |
Spastic diplegia SS: 20; 7 B/13 G; Age: 6–8 EG: 10; 4 B/6 G Age: 6.9 ± 0.6yr CG: 10; 3 B/7 G Age: 6.6 ± 0.7yr |
IV: Traditional therapeutic exercises + body-weight suspension training Freq: 3/week Time: 40 + 30min |
IV: Wii Fit intervention Freq: 1/week Time: 45min |
standing↑, walking↑, 10-Meter walking speed↑. five times sit to stand, walking speed, sit to stand transitional skills, no significant difference between groups |
Ansa et al. (2020) [43] | PPS 8 weeks |
Cerebral Palsy SS: 10; 7 B/3 G SS: 10; 7 B/3 G Age: 14.4 ± 1.53yr; Type of CP: 4 Diplegia/1 Hemiplegia/5 Quadriplegia |
IV: Community-based functional aerobic exercise INT: 40–80 % max heart rate Freq: 4/week Time: 50min |
No | GMF D-standing ↑ 8.2 %, E-walking + running + jumping ↑ 5.12 %, walking distance↑ 6.09 %. physical health ↑ 105.04 %, by children parent proxy. And physical health ↑ 60.00 %, by Self-reported. |
Surana et al. (2019) [18] | RCTs 9 weeks |
Unilateral spastic cerebral palsy SS: 24; 10 B/14 G EG: 12; 5 B/7 G Age: 5.8 ± 2.3yr GMFCS, 5 I/7 II CG: 12; 5 B/7 G Age: 5.1 ± 2.6yr GMFCS 3 I/9 II |
IV: LE intensive functional training Freq: 5/week Time: 120min |
IV: Obligatory physical education classes + NR | 1MWT↑, ABILOCO-kids↑, single-leg stance↑, fast velocity↑, 30-s chair rise↑. LIFT improved more than H-HABIT. no significant differences between LIFT and H-HABIT for self-selected walking velocity |
Ketelaar et al. (2001) [44] | RCTs 18 months |
Spastic cerebral palsy SS: 55; 33 B/22 G; Age: 2–7yr EG: 28; 16 B/12 G Age: 54 ± 20 months; Cerebral palsy distribution: 16 Hemiplegia/5 Diplegia/6 Quadriplegia. CG: 27; 17 G/10 G; Age: 56 ± 20 months Cerebral palsy distribution: 16 Hemiplegia/6 Diplegia/6 Quadriplegia. |
IV: Functional physical therapy | IV: Traditional therapeutic exercises + the treadmill Freq: 3/week Time: 40 + 30min |
GMFM↑ and PEDI score ↑in both groups; basic gross motor abilities↑, no differ between groups. The mean scores↑ higher than in the CG. functional skills in daily situations↑, self-care and mobility activities↑. |
Salavat et al. (2017) [45] | PPS 18 weeks |
PT: Cerebral palsy and cerebral visual impairment SS: 5 2 B/3 G; Cerebral palsy; Age:114 ± 52 month; distribution: 5 Spastic, GMFCS classified levels: 2 I/1 II/1 V/1 IV; |
IV: Functional therapy programmed Freq: 3/week Time: 30min |
No | Gross motor functioning↑, Functional Skills↑ |
Blundell et al. (2002) [46] | PPS 4 weeks |
PT: Cerebral palsy SS: 8; 7 B/1 G EG: 8; 7 B/1 G; Age: 6.3 ± 1.3yr Cerebral palsy distribution: 7 spastic Diplegia/1 Quadriplegia. |
IV: Functional strength training +a group circuit training INT: intensive repetitive practice Freq: 2/week Time: 60min |
IV: Hand-Arm Bimanual Intensive Therapy Freq: 5/week Time: 120min |
Isometric strength↑; Left and right Lateral Step-up ↑; time of 10-m walk↑; stride length↑. |
Mikołajczyk et al. (2014) [50] | RCTs 12 weeks |
Moderate mental disabilities SS: 34 Age: 15.06 ± 0.9yr; EG: 17 CG: 17 |
IV: Unstable-surface functional exercises Freq: 3/week Time: 45min |
IV: Did not perform any exercises | Static balance - COP deviation range↑, Path length↓, Path area↓. Eye open and eye closed. |
Ahl et al. (2005) [47] | PPS 5 months |
PT: Children with cerebral palsy SS: 14; 11 B/3 G; Age: 1 year 6 months to 6 years. With diplegia and tetraplegia cerebral palsy; EG: 8; 7 B/1 G; GMFCS classified between levels II–V; |
IV: Goal-directed functional therapy Freq: 2/week Time: NM |
IV: Reference normalisation | 76 goals fulfilled completely, 19 partially completed; gross motor function↑; self-care performance↑; mobility ↑; social function↑ |
Farrokhian et al. (2021) [48] | RCTs 5 weeks |
Intellectual disability SS: 30 Gender: G EG: 15; CG: 15 Age: Elementary school students(Not specific) |
IV: Functional training Freq: 3/week Time: 45–60min |
IV: Did not perform any exercises | SB↑, DB↑, flexibility↑, and student performance are statistically significant. |
Van Tittelboom et al. (2023) [49] | PPS 4 weeks |
PT: A diagnosis of bilateral spastic CP SS: 36 Gender: 19 B/17 G; Age: 8.58 ± 1.96yr QFT: 24 Gender: 10 B/14 G; GMFCS level II: 15, GMFCS level III: 9; Age: 8.5 ± 1.84yr FT: 12 Gender: 9 male/3 female; GMFCS level II: 7, GMFCS level III: 5; Age: 8.83 ± 2.23yr |
IV: Functional training INT: NR Freq: 5/week Time: 4.5 h |
IV: Qualitative functional training INT: NR Freq: 5/week Time: 4.5 h |
QFM: ↑ with qualitative functional training (QFT), but not improved with function training. GM88-D and E ↑ (QFT) TCMS: static and dynamic balance ↑ (QFT) |
Abd-Elfattah et al. (2022) [28] | RCTs 12 weeks |
PT: Spastic hemiplegic cerebral palsy Sports: NR SS: 66 Gender: 42 B/24 G. EG: 24 Gender: 22 B/11G; GMFCS level I: 10, GMFCS level II: 23; Age: 11.31 ± 0.62yr HT: 142.55 ± 4.1 cm; BM: 38.31 ± 3.93 kg; CG: 12 Gender: 20 B/13 G; GMFCS level I: 13, GMFCS level II: 20; Age: 11.11 ± 0.63yr HT: 142.41 ± 4.21 cm; BM: 37.12 ± 2.83 kg; |
IV: loaded functional strengthening exercises INT: NR Freq: 3/week Time: 60 min |
IV: physical therapy INT: NR Freq: 3/week Time: 60 min |
6MWT: the 6MWT in EG (20.09 %) and CG (9.69 %) ↑, EG > CG. |
Abbreviation: PT, participant; SS, sample size; EG, experiment group; CG, control group; PPS, pre-post-test; HT, height; BW, body weight; IV, Interventions; INT, intensity; Freq, frequency; ES: effect size; GFT, general physical fitness; LS, locomotor skills; Bs, balance skill; OCS, objective control skills; B, boy; G, girl; NM, not mentioned; FMS, functional movement screen; GMFCS, gross motor function classification system. DB, dynamic balance; SB, Static balance; SAR, sit-and-reach; SLJ, standing long jumping; T, times; FST, functional strength training; ST, Suspension training. SR, shuttle run; CVJ: countermovement vertical jump; QFM: Qualitative functional training; 6MWT: 6-min walk test.