Table 1. Data collection from published literature.
Reference | Study type | System | Distance | Phase | ReU | ReA |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Kim et al., 2010 | Numerical | Flapping flags | Head-to-head | 200 –400 |
– | |
Zhu et al., 2014 | Numerical | Heaving flexible foils | – | 500 | 200 | |
Ramananarivo et al., 2016 | Experimental | Heaving foils | Tail-to-head | 103 –104 |
102 –103 |
|
Peng et al., 2018 | Numerical | Heaving flexible foils | Tail-to-head | 509 | 200 | |
Newbolt et al., 2019 | Experimental | Heaving foils | Tail-to-head | 103 –104 |
102 –103 |
|
Li et al., 2020 | Experimental | Goldfish | Head-to-head | 105 | 104 | |
Kurt et al., 2021 | Experimental | Pitching foils | Tail-to-head | 9950 | 18,850 | |
Heydari and Kanso, 2021 | Numerical | Heaving plates | Tail-to-head | – | – | |
Pitching plates | Head-to-head | – | – | |||
Arranz et al., 2022 | Numerical | Heaving flexible foils (3D) | Tail-to-head | 176 | 200 | |
Thandiackal and Lauder, 2023 | Experimental | Fish-foil interactions | Tail-to-head | 20·103 (foil) | 50·103 (foil) | |
40·103 (fish) | ||||||
Becker et al., 2015 * | Experimental | Heaving foils | Tail-to-head |
, |
– | 102 –104 |
Park and Sung, 2018 * | Numerical | Heaving flexible foils | – | 60 –1100 |
100 –1200 |
|
Dai et al., 2018 * | Numerical | Pitching + heaving foils | – |
, |
440 | 600 |
Data not included in Figure 3.