Table 1.
Species | Dose | Effect | Reference |
---|---|---|---|
Nile tilapia (Oreochromis niloticus) |
100 ppb 200 ppb |
Growth impaired Mortality |
El-Banna et al. [56] |
2000 or 4000 ppb | Reduced weight gain and decreased body lipid content | Hussain, Manteen, and Gatlin [5] | |
200 ppb | Decreased total erythrocyte and leucocyte count, serum liver enzymes leakage, hemoglobin count decreased; reduced weight gain | Selim, El-hofy, and Khalil [44] | |
375, 752, 940, 1500, 1880, 3000 ppb | Decreased FI and growth rate, liver atrophy | Chávez-Sánchez, Martinez-Palacios, and Osorio-Moreno [57] | |
100,000 ppb | Lipofuscin and irregularly hepatocellular nuclei, weight loss, severe hepatic necrosis, and mortality | Tuan et al. [58] | |
100 ppb | Increased liver enzymes, reduced growth rate, and weight gain | Mahfouz and Sherif [66] | |
100 ppb | Weight loss, changes in blood parameters, and liver necrosis | Abdelhamid et al. [67] | |
3000 ppb | Lower SGR | Shehata, El-Melegy, and Ebrahim [68] | |
200, 250 ppb | Mortality | Naiel, Ismael, and Shehata [69] | |
100 ppb | Severe liver tissue vacuolation and lipid accumulation | Kenawy et al. [70] | |
100 ppb | Decreased growth | Encarnacao et al. [71] | |
150 ppb | Serious toxic impacts and negative effects on health performance | Mehrim and Salem [72]; Zychowski et al. [73] | |
| |||
Tetrahybrid red tilapia | <5 ppb | Pale gills, liver damage, poor growth rates, and immune suppression | Conroy [74] |
| |||
Rohu (L. rohita) | 1250 ppb | Reduction in nonspecific immunity | Sahoo and Mukherjee [75] |
7500, 1125 ppb 1250, 2500 ppb 12,000, 13,300 ppb |
Acute toxicity Subchronic toxicity Necrosis of gill lamellae, primary lamellar hyperplasia |
Sahoo and Mukerjee [76] | |
10, 20 ppb 40 ppb |
Liver tissue mild edema Swollen hepatocytes, kidney mild hemorrhages, decrease total erythrocyte, and hemoglobin count |
Mohapatra et al. [77] | |
25, 50 ppb 100 ppb |
Reduced growth performance, growth depression Reduced growth indices and survival rate |
Bhatt et al. [49] | |
100 ppb | Cytoplasmic vacuolization in hepatocytes and hepatic tissue showing loss of membrane integrity, along with diffused hepatocytes and hyperplasia | Bhatt et al. [78] | |
1250 ppb | Increased serum lysozyme activity, enhanced phagocytic ratio, and immunostimulatory effects | Sahoo and Mukherjee [76] | |
| |||
Seabass (D. labrax) | 180 ppb 18 ppb 4.25 ± 0.85 ppb |
Abnormal behavioral Increased ALT, AST, and ALP enzymes, decrease in plasma proteins Serious health problems in exposed fish and a high risk to fish consumers |
El-Sayed and Khalil [79] |
| |||
Rainbow trout (O. mykiss) | 500 ppb | Acute toxicities | Lovell [80] |
810 ppb | Acute toxicities | Bauer, Li, and Sinnuhuber [81] | |
25 ppb≥ 50 ppb≤ |
Persisting inflammatory response without mortality Decreased LYZ, TP, and ALB and increased inflammatory cytokines Villi destruction and necrosis, hyperplasia, and edema of gill lamellae |
Ghafarifarsani et al. [50] | |
25 ppb≥ 50 ppb≤ 50 ppb |
Infiltration of inflammatory cells into the underlying layers, necrosis, hyperplasia, atrophy, and severe destruction of gills Liver tissue damage and hepatocyte changes |
Imani et al. [82] | |
50 ppb | Destruction of intestinal villi | Mahmoudi et al. [83] | |
| |||
Juvenile turbot (Scophthalmus maximus L.) |
100 ppb | Negatively affected liver catalase activity and intestinal microbiota | Zhang et al. [84] |
| |||
Silver catfish, Jundia (R. quelen) |
204 ppb 350 ppb |
Lower weight and length gain Alterations in the liver and tissues |
Lopes et al. [85] |
| |||
Channel catfish (I. punctatus) |
10,000 ppb | Decreased growth performance, anemia, and liver and gastric necrosis | Jantrarotai and Lovell [64] |
12,000 ppb | Regurgitating stomach contents, pale organs of moribund fish, istological lesions, and mortality | Jantrarotai, Lovell, and Grizzle [86] | |
| |||
Yellow catfish (Pelteobagrus fulvidraco) |
200 ppb< | Growth performance (WG, SGR), lower survival rate, and increased FCR | Wang et al. [87] |
| |||
Tra catfish (Pangasius hypophthalmus) |
500, 1000 ppb 50, 100, 250 ppb |
Increased HIS AST, ALT, and liver damage |
Gonçalves et al. [88] |
| |||
White surgeon (H. huso) | 75, 100 ppb | Altered feed conversion and weight gain and decreases in growth | Sepahdari et al. [55] |
| |||
Juvenile hybrid sturgeon (A. ruthenus ♂ × A. baeri ♀) |
40 ppb 80 ppb |
Mortality High mortality, decreased hematocrit value, nuclear hypertrophy, and hyperchromasia |
Raghavan et al. [18] |
| |||
Stellate sturgeon (Acipenser stellatus) |
1500 ppb 3500 ppb |
8% mortality 50% mortality |
Santacroce et al. [7] |
75, 100 ppb | Bleeding points in the gills and head, hyperplasia and destruction of the epithelial tissue of the gills lamellae, and necrosis of the liver cell | Motallebi Moghanjouei [89] | |
1500, 1850, 2300, 2850, 3500 ppb | Increased liver enzymes (AST, ALT, and ALP) and mortality rate | Jalilpour et al. [90] | |
| |||
Grass carp (Ctenopharyngodon idella) |
147 ppb | Suppressed Nrf2 signaling—a decrease in growth and antioxidant enzymes—and disruption of the integrity and TJ protein | Zeng et al. [91] |
85.94 ppb< | Decreased expression of genes β-defensin-1, LEAP-2A, Mucin2, and LEAP-2B | He et al. [92] | |
| |||
Gibel crap (C. gibelio) |
5 ppb | Reduced growth | Han et al. [45] |
2000 ppb< | Fecundity is reduced and tissue accumulation | Huang et al. [93] | |
| |||
Common carp (C. carpio) | 100,000 ppb | Immunosuppression | Sahoo and Mukherjee [94] |
200, 400 ppb | No mortality | Al-Rubaiy et al. [95]; Tasa et al. [96] | |
500, 1000, 2000 ppb | Decreased weight gain, histopathological changes | Rhadi, Rudainy, and Attee [97] | |
| |||
Salmon (Oncorhynchus kisutch) |
10,000 ppb | Acute toxicities | Schoental [98] |
| |||
Mosquitofish (Gambusia affinis) | 4640 ppb | Acute toxicities and mortality | McKean et al. [99] |
| |||
Tambaqui fingerlings (Colossoma macropomum) |
500 ppb< | Decreases in the WG, FI, and FE | Nunes et al. [100] |
| |||
Lambari fish (Astyanax altiparanae) |
10 ppb | Accumulation in fish liver and muscle | Michelin et al. [101] |
Abbreviations: ALB, albumin; ALP, alkaline phosphatase; ALT, alanine transaminase; AST, aspartate aminotransferase; FCR, feed conversion ratio; FE, feed efficiency; FI, feed intake; HIS, hepatosomatic index; LYZ, lysozyme; Nrf2, NF-E2-related factor 2; SGR, specific growth rate; TJ, tight junction; TP, total protein; WG, weight gain.