Table 3.
Study | Description of exercise intervention | Intervention start post-surgery | Duration of rehabilitation | Training frequency [per week] | Session duration | Overall training sessions | Intensity / control of intensity | Adherence in training sessions / (serious) Adverse events |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Anderson et al. |
a) supervised strength and cardiovascular training b) supervised and home-based strength and cardiovascular training c) voluntarily supervised training + home-based training |
a) 4–12 weeks b) after a c) after b |
a) 12 weeks b) 12 weeks c) 24 weeks |
a) 2x b) > 1x c) voluntarily |
65 min | a) Resistance training: 50% established 1RM weekly increased by 1–5lbs; cardiovascular training: 14–16 RPE | 71.2% R:0–97 | |
Bøhn et al. 2021* |
a) Group-based moderate to high aerobic and strength exercise b) home-based exercise |
21–28 days | 48 weeks |
a) 2x b) 120 min |
a) 60 min | VO2max not described in detail | ||
Cantarero-Villanueva et al. 2016 | Core stabilization exercises |
12.0 ± 7.4 months 14.6 ± 10.0 months |
8 weeks | 3x | 20–30 min | 22.0 ± 1.1 | RPE | 88.36% / IG: 2, CG: 1 |
Courneya et al. |
Supervised cycle ergometry sessions |
IG: 14 ± 6 months CG: 14 ± 7 months |
15 weeks | 3x |
Wk1-3: 25 min; increased by 5 min every third week |
44.3 | 5 min warm-up + cool-down 50% of VO2max; training intensity at 70–75% of VO2max |
98.4% / Adverse events: IG: 20,8% CG: 7.1% |
Courneya et al. |
a) supervised aerobic exercise (AET) b) supervised resistance exercise (RET) − 9 exercises á 2 sets á 8–12 reps |
Not given | Mean: 17 weeks | 3x |
a) Wk1-3: 25 min; increased by 5 min every third week |
a) 60% of VO2max wk1-6, 70% of VO2max wk 7–12, 89% of VO2max wk > 12 b) 60–70% of 1RM increased by 10% if 12 reps completed |
AET: 72% RET: 68.2% / Adverse events: 2 |
|
Falz et al. 2023 | Home-based, bodyweight strength-endurance training | Not given | 24 weeks | 2-3x | 30 min | 1.5 sessions per week (36 overall sessions) | Entity-specific, individually performance adapted and heart rate limited; targeted 5–8 CR10 scale |
56.4% Adverse events: 18 |
Lee et al. 2017 |
a) home based endurance exercise b) home based resistance exercise |
IG: 10.7 ± 8.8 CG: 8.8 ± 7.2 |
12 weeks | Daily | b) 30 min | 3000 steps with HR > 65% of estimated HRmax, 18–27 MET-hours per week |
> 18 MET-hours: 86.3% 27 MET-hours: 74.5% |
|
Lin et al. 2013* | Group based supervised combined aerobic and resistance exercise | 37.8 (16.4) days | 12 weeks | 2x | 40–60 min | 24 | Increasingly from 40–75 of HRmax | 73% (17.3) |
Murtezani et al. |
supervised group moderate intensity aerobic exercise program |
19.0 ± 6.9 vs. 19.1 ± 4.8 |
10 weeks | 3x | 25 min | Increasingly from 50–75 of estimated HRmax and from 25 min to 45 min | ||
Mutrie et al. |
a) group based supervised diverse exercise b) home based exercise session |
Not given | 12 weeks |
a) 2x b) 1x |
45 min | 50–72% of age adjusted HRmax | ||
Travier et al. 2015 | supervised combined aerobic and muscle strength training | within 10 weeks post diagnosis | 18 weeks | 2x | 60 min | different aerobic methods according to HR on ventilatory threshold + strength exercises between 45–75% of 1RM (increasing repetitions or intensity) | 83% (IQR: 69–91%) | |
Van Vulpen et al.2016 | supervised combined aerobic and muscle strength training | within 10 weeks post diagnosis | 18 weeks | 2x | 60 min | different aerobic methods according to HR on ventilatory threshold + strength exercises between 45–75% of 1RM (increasing repetitions or intensity) | 89% (IQR: 72–97%) |
Mean and standard deviation are presented. Other data (median MD, 95% Confidence interval 95%CI; interquartile range IQR; Range R) are marked
HR max maximal reached heart rate, 1RM one repetition maximum, RPE rating of perceived exertion, CR-10 Category-Ratio Scale anchored at 10, MET metabolic equivalent of task, MAP maximal aerobic power
*Excluded for meta-analysis