Skip to main content
. 2024 Nov 22;10(24):e40635. doi: 10.1016/j.heliyon.2024.e40635

Table 7.

Developed and emerging nations' energy consumption outcomes result from several causes.

Dependent Variables (1)
(3)
(3)
(5)
Developing Countries (1–3)
Developed Countries (3–5)
Primary-Model
Robust
Primary Model
Robust
Sys-GMM
3SLS
Sys-GMM
3SLS
Energy Consumption Energy Consumption Energy Consumption Energy Consumption
L. Energy Consumption 1.751∗∗∗ 1.077∗∗∗
(1.155) (1.137)
Technological Transfer 1.307∗∗∗ 1.335∗∗ 1.335∗∗ 1.351∗∗∗
(1.107) (1.710) (1.133) (1.173)
Governance −1.150∗∗ −1.305∗∗∗ 1.155∗∗ 1.171∗∗∗
(1.111) (1.353) (1.133) (1.310)
High-Level Governance 1.101∗ 1.151∗∗ 1.150∗∗∗ 1.351∗∗∗
(1.131) (1.510) (1.153) (1.157)
Low-Level Governance −1.373∗∗ −1.307∗ 1.133∗∗ 1.533∗∗
(1.171) (1.710) (1.115) (1.175)
Percent in Total Environmentally Related Tax Revenue 1.113∗∗ (1.111) 1.110∗∗∗ (1.113) 1.113∗∗ (1.111) 1.117∗∗ (1.117)
Globalization Index −1.350 −1.535 1.135∗∗ 1.375∗∗
(1.105) (1.103) (1.117) (1.313)
Urbanization −1.115∗ −1.371∗∗ −1.173 −1.157
(1.170) (1.150) (1.117) (1.131)
FDI Effect (Dummy) −1.355∗∗∗ −1.100∗∗ −1.135∗ −1.157∗∗
(1.131) (1.135) (1.110) (1.175)
Human Capital and Research 1.130∗∗ 1.107∗∗∗
(1.175) (1.113)
Diagnostic test
Year Effect Yes Yes Yes Yes
Observations 577 750 735 713
AR3 (p-value) −1.053 (1.117) −1.755 (1.110)
AR1 (p-value) −1.351 (1.311) −1.311 (1.033)
Hansen (p-value) 113.111 (1.355) 131.011 (1.173)
Instruments/j. stat. 30 33
Wald test/CHI3 (p-value) 0375 (1.111) 333501 (1.111)
Sargan (p-value) 33.50 (1.330) 57.5130 (1.133) 0.703 (1.030) 5.71 (1.131)
Under-Identification Test, Anderson Canon. corr. LM Statistic (p-value) 10.573 (1.111) 31.717 (1.111)
Endogeneity Test (p-value) 5.353 (1.113) 3.170 (1.117)
Wu-Hausman (p-value) 5.353 (1.115) 3.171 (1.110)
Durbin (score) chi3(p-value) 5.351 (1.113) 3.170 (1.117)
Weak Identification Test (Cragg-Donald Wald F Statistic 17.05 13.07
Stock-Yogo weak ID test critical values criteria Pass Pass
BRI sample countries 73 73 70 70