Table 7.
Dependent Variables | (1) |
(3) |
(3) |
(5) |
---|---|---|---|---|
Developing Countries (1–3) |
Developed Countries (3–5) |
|||
Primary-Model |
Robust |
Primary Model |
Robust |
|
Sys-GMM |
3SLS |
Sys-GMM |
3SLS |
|
Energy Consumption | Energy Consumption | Energy Consumption | Energy Consumption | |
L. Energy Consumption | 1.751∗∗∗ | 1.077∗∗∗ | ||
(1.155) | (1.137) | |||
Technological Transfer | 1.307∗∗∗ | 1.335∗∗ | 1.335∗∗ | 1.351∗∗∗ |
(1.107) | (1.710) | (1.133) | (1.173) | |
Governance | −1.150∗∗ | −1.305∗∗∗ | 1.155∗∗ | 1.171∗∗∗ |
(1.111) | (1.353) | (1.133) | (1.310) | |
High-Level Governance | 1.101∗ | 1.151∗∗ | 1.150∗∗∗ | 1.351∗∗∗ |
(1.131) | (1.510) | (1.153) | (1.157) | |
Low-Level Governance | −1.373∗∗ | −1.307∗ | 1.133∗∗ | 1.533∗∗ |
(1.171) | (1.710) | (1.115) | (1.175) | |
Percent in Total Environmentally Related Tax Revenue | 1.113∗∗ (1.111) | 1.110∗∗∗ (1.113) | 1.113∗∗ (1.111) | 1.117∗∗ (1.117) |
Globalization Index | −1.350 | −1.535 | 1.135∗∗ | 1.375∗∗ |
(1.105) | (1.103) | (1.117) | (1.313) | |
Urbanization | −1.115∗ | −1.371∗∗ | −1.173 | −1.157 |
(1.170) | (1.150) | (1.117) | (1.131) | |
FDI Effect (Dummy) | −1.355∗∗∗ | −1.100∗∗ | −1.135∗ | −1.157∗∗ |
(1.131) | (1.135) | (1.110) | (1.175) | |
Human Capital and Research | 1.130∗∗ | 1.107∗∗∗ | ||
(1.175) | (1.113) | |||
Diagnostic test | ||||
Year Effect | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes |
Observations | 577 | 750 | 735 | 713 |
AR3 (p-value) | −1.053 (1.117) | −1.755 (1.110) | ||
AR1 (p-value) | −1.351 (1.311) | −1.311 (1.033) | ||
Hansen (p-value) | 113.111 (1.355) | 131.011 (1.173) | ||
Instruments/j. stat. | 30 | 33 | ||
Wald test/CHI3 (p-value) | 0375 (1.111) | 333501 (1.111) | ||
Sargan (p-value) | 33.50 (1.330) | 57.5130 (1.133) | 0.703 (1.030) | 5.71 (1.131) |
Under-Identification Test, Anderson Canon. corr. LM Statistic (p-value) | 10.573 (1.111) | 31.717 (1.111) | ||
Endogeneity Test (p-value) | 5.353 (1.113) | 3.170 (1.117) | ||
Wu-Hausman (p-value) | 5.353 (1.115) | 3.171 (1.110) | ||
Durbin (score) chi3(p-value) | 5.351 (1.113) | 3.170 (1.117) | ||
Weak Identification Test (Cragg-Donald Wald F Statistic | 17.05 | 13.07 | ||
Stock-Yogo weak ID test critical values criteria | Pass | Pass | ||
BRI sample countries | 73 | 73 | 70 | 70 |