Table 5.
Comparative Studies of Dosimetry of Heart and Left Anterior Descending Artery (LAD) (Gy- Gray)
Study | Region | Parameter | Free breathing | Deep inspiratory breath hold | P value | ||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Mean±SD | Median (IQR) | Mean±SD | Median (IQR) | ||||
Knöchelmann et al. (2022)[13] | Heart | Dmean | 2.64±1.26 | -- | 1.39±0.47 | -- | <0.001 |
V5 | 10.6 ± 12.4 | -- | 6.6 ± 8.5 | -- | <0.001 | ||
V10 | 3.21±3.03 | -- | 1.26±1.21 | -- | <0.001 | ||
V25 | 2.20±3.63 | -- | 0.67±0.80 | -- | <0.001 | ||
LAD | Dmax | 12.43±12.18 | -- | 11.05±9.18 | -- | >0.05 | |
Dmean | 5.68±5.24 | -- | 3.88±2.59 | -- | <0.001 | ||
Darapu et al. (2017)[6] | Heart | V5 | 21.44±09.43 | -- | 15.74±9.15 | -- | 0 |
V10 | 12.42±05.65 | -- | 7.72±5.98 | -- | 0 | ||
V25 | 9.12±04.71 | -- | 4.85±5.21 | -- | 0 | ||
V30 | 8.43±4.48 | -- | 4.71±04.57 | -- | 0 | ||
Dmean | 6.827±2.69 | -- | 4.775±02.59 | -- | 0 | ||
LAD | V5 | 25.24 ±53.47 | -- | 41.3±19.81 | -- | 0.03 | |
V10 | 39.52±24.61 | -- | 19.94±15.43 | -- | 0.002 | ||
V25 | 31.91±24.47 | -- | 12.48±15.74 | -- | 0.002 | ||
Dmean | 17.84±10.73 | -- | 9.66±6.454 | -- | 0.001 | ||
Al-Hammadi N et al. (2018)[11] | Heart | Dmean | 6.1±2.5 | -- | 3.2±1.4 | -- | < 0.05 |
Dmax | 51.1± 1.4 | -- | 48.5±6.8 | -- | |||
V50 | 0.7±1.1 | -- | 0.2±0.6 | -- | |||
V40 | 6.2±3.5 | -- | 2.1±1.9 | -- | |||
V30 | 7.8±4 | -- | 2.8±2.3 | -- | |||
V25 | 8.5±4.2 | -- | 3.2±2.5 | -- | |||
V20 | 9.2±4.4 | -- | 3.6±2.7 | -- | |||
V15 | 10±4.6 | -- | 4.1± 2.9 | -- | |||
V10 | 11.2±5 | -- | 4.9±3.2 | -- | |||
LAD | Dmean | 23.0±6.7 | -- | 14.8±7.6 | -- | < 0.05 | |
Dmax | 49.7±3.4 | -- | 44.3±12.2 | -- | |||
D50 | 20.4±17.6 | -- | 8.4±11.1 | -- | |||
Present study | Heart | V20 | 12.83±3.53 | 13.0 (10.5, 15.3) | 6.15±2.77 | 5.70 (4.0, 7.3) | 0.001 |
V25 | 11.90±3.46 | 12.0 (9.6, 14.4) | 5.17±2.37 | 4.70 (3.4, 6.1) | 0.001 | ||
Dmean | 8.69±1.65 | 8.9 (7.58, 9.75) | 5.73±1.41 | 5.82 (5.16, 6.06) | 0.001 | ||
LAD | Dmax | 51.68±1.65 | 51.34 (50.73, 52.31) | 46.91±9.90 | 49.16 (47.67, 51.23) | 0.006 | |
Dmean | 29.05±7.38 | 29.08 (22.90, 32.93) | 20.95±7.65 | 23.10 (12.22, 25.97) | 0.001 |