Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2025 Jan 6.
Published in final edited form as: Neuromodulation. 2024 Sep 4;28(1):1–15. doi: 10.1016/j.neurom.2024.07.008

Table 2.

LIFU Trials in Sensory Perception.

Author, year Sonication target LIFU parameters Outcome measures Findings Adverse events
Badran et al,27 2022 Right anterior thalamus FF: 0.65 MHz
PRF: 0.00001 MHz
PW: 5 ms
DC: 5%
SD: 30 s
ISI: 30 s
ISPTA: 0.719 W/cm2*
ISPPA: not reported
MI: not reported
Total duration: 20 min
Sham controlled: yes
  • QST

  • Attenuation of the sensory component to pain perception

  • Significant increase in thermal pain thresholds

  • Blunted sensitization to thermal stimuli

None
Legon et al,28 2014 SI FF: 0.5 MHz
PRF: 0.001 MHz
PW: 0.36 ms
DC: 36%
SD: 0.5 s
ISI: 6 s
ISPTA: not reported
ISPPA: 5.895 W/cm2
MI: 1.13
Total duration: 120 sonications
Sham controlled: yes
  • Sensory-evoked brain activity

  • Sensory discrimination task

  • Significant attenuation of the SEP amplitudes

  • Significant modulation of spectral content sensory-evoked brain oscillations

  • Above changes not present when LIFU shifted 1 cm anterior or 1 cm posterior

  • Enhanced performance on sensory discrimination tasks

None
Liu et al,66 2021 SI FF: 0.5 MHz
PRF: 0.0003 MHz
PW: 0.2 ms
DC: 6%
SD: 0.5 s
ISI: 2 s
ISPTA: 0.06713 W/cm2
ISPPA: 1.10 W/cm2
MI: not reported
Total duration: 56 sonications
Sham controlled: yes
  • Somatosensory cortical activity

  • Sensory discrimination task

  • Excitatory neuromodulatory effects at S1

  • Higher source profile amplitude at S1

  • Enhanced performance on sensory discrimination task

None
Lee et al,67 2015 SI FF: 0.25 MHz
PRF: 0.0005 MHz
PW: 1 ms
DC: 50%
SD: 0.3 s
ISI: 2.7 s
ISPTA: 0.35 W/cm2
ISPPA: maximum 2.5 W/cm2
MI: 0.62
Total duration: 200 sonications
Sham controlled: yes
  • LIFU evoked sensations

  • Somatosensory cortical activity

  • Safety

  • Elicited explicit tactile sensations

  • Sensations occurred in the hand area contralateral to the sonicated hemisphere

  • Stimulatory effects were transient and reversible

  • Cortical evoked potentials akin to classical SEP generated by median nerve stimulation

  • No acute neurologic or neuroradiologic abnormalities after stimulation

None
Lee et al,68 2016 SI
SII
FF: 0.21 MHz
PRF: 0.0005 MHz
PW: 1 ms
DC: 50%
SD: 0.5 s
ISI: 6.5 s
ISPTA: 3.5–4.4 W/cm2
ISPPA: 7.0–8.8 W/cm2
MI: not reported
Total duration: 20 sonications
Sham controlled: yes
  • LIFU evoked sensations across different target regions

  • Simultaneous stimulation of the SI/SII in the same hemisphere and elicited various tactile sensations

  • Stimulation of the SII area induced perception of tactile sensations

  • Multiple FUS transducers can be used for simultaneous stimulation of different targets

None
Legon et al,69 2018 Ventro-posterior lateral nucleus of the thalamus FF: 0.5 MHz
PRF: 0.001 MHz
PW: 0.36 ms
DC: 36%
SD: 0.5s
ISI: 4 s
ISPTA: not reported
ISPPA: 7.03 W/cm2
MI: 0.56
Total duration: 300 sonications
Sham controlled: yes
  • Activity of unilateral sensory thalamus and cortical somatosensory SI area

  • Acoustic modeling

  • Sensory discrimination task

  • Inhibited the SEP amplitude at unilateral sensory thalamu

  • No effect of LIFU on somatosensory cortex SI area

  • Frequency inhibition in mostly beta and gamma power

  • Skull produces some LIFU beam distortion

  • Significantly worse than chance on a discrimination task

None
Hameroff et al,70 2013 Fronto-temporal cortex Unfocused transcranial ultrasound
FF: 8 MHz
PRF: N/A
PW: N/A
DC: N/A
SD: 15 s
ISI: N/A
ISPTA: 0.152 W/cm2
ISPPA: N/A
MI: 0.7
Total duration: 15 s
Sham controlled: yes
  • VAMS

  • NRS

  • Vital signs

  • Significant improvement in global affect at 10 min

  • Significant improvement in global affect at 40 min

  • Slight improvement in pain ratings (NRS) 40 min

  • No changes in any vital signs 40 min after exposure

None
Legon et al,71 2023 AI
PI
FF: 0.5 MHz
PRF: 0.001 MHz
PW: 0.36 ms
DC: 36%
SD: 1 s
ISI: 12–20 s
ISPTA: not reported
ISPPA: 3.5 W/cm2*
MI: not reported
Total duration: 40 sonications
Sham controlled: yes
  • CHEP

  • Autonomic measures

  • Pain ratings

  • LIFU of PI affected earlier EEG amplitudes ~300 ms

  • LIFU of AI affected EEG amplitudes ~500 ms

  • LIFU to both AI and PI reduced the amplitude at 824–903 ms

  • LIFU to both AI and PI reduced perceived pain ratings

  • LIFU of the AI affected HRV

None

AI, anterior insula; CHEP, contact head evoked potentials; HRV, heart rate variability; ISI, interstimulus interval (s); NRS, numerical rating scale; PI, posterior insula; QST, quantitative sensory thresholding; SI, primary hand somatosensory cortex; SII, secondary hand somatosensory cortex; SEP, sensory evoked potentials; VAMS, Visual Analog Mood Scale.

Total duration is reported in total time of LIFU intervention or the number of sonications delivered in one session.

*

Intensity reported is not the intracranial estimation. The reported values represent either the intensity measured in freeform water or a parameter output of the LIFU system. Both values can be used to estimate intracranial intensity.