Chart 1. Changes in CNRM resolutions on the evaluation of resident physicians. Source: authors.
ITEM | PREVOUSLY (2006) | CURRENTLY (2023) |
---|---|---|
Assessment frequency | Quarterly | Every four months |
Responsibility for residence supervision | Professors with a Medical Residency certificate in the specialty area, or with a higher degree, or with equivalent qualification, according to COREME | Supervisor and set of preceptors; joint evaluation between programs from other institutions in the same modality is prohibited |
Evaluation methods | Written, practical, or performance test by attitude scale | Multiple methods and instruments of summative and formative assessments in 3 modalities: 1) Cognitive (theoretical), 2) Psychomotor (practical), and 3) Affective-Professional. Structured feedback |
Evaluation concepts | Post-Evaluation: concept of sufficiency defined by COREME by the average value of the conducted evaluations | Pre-Assessment: concept of sufficiency defined in the preparation of the assessment, representing the expected performance for the evaluated domains |
Can be included in the Evaluation System by COREMEs | Monograph and/or presentation or publication of a scientific article at the end of training. | - Record of procedures and activities: Logbook, portfolio, and Scientific Research during training; - Progress Test (120 to 200 questions) prepared by the Specialty Society. |
Resident Approval for the following year | - Full compliance with the program’s workload; - Approval by the average value of the evaluations conducted at the discretion of COREMEs. |
- Full compliance with the workload and evaluations of the program; - Mandatorily achieve a minimum score of 7 in the 3 cognitive evaluations; - “Satisfactory” concept of the quadrimester evaluations in the psychomotor and affective-attitudinal components; - EPAs could serve as bases for verifying progress at the levels of supervision and autonomous practice. |
Program Certification | - Full compliance with the program’s workload; - Approval by the average value of the evaluations conducted at the discretion of COREMEs. |
- Full compliance with the program’s workload; - Full compliance with the criteria of periodic evaluations; - Full compliance with the promotion criteria in all years of residency; - Presentation of the final work for the conclusion of the course |